5 ms·
Asians may face tougher college admission process, study finds
- TheElder 17y agoAs a white, it makes me somewhat sick to my stomach to think that I might have benefited from affirmative action. If Asians are better than me, score better than me, I shouldn't displace any of them in the university. I almost always assume that blacks who are in any kind of engineering, math, physics, or hard science schools are placed there because of their race. I don't want to be thought of in that manner. Now, was it wrong that the first thing I thought of when I saw a black in the engineering department was affirmative action? Maybe so, but what is one to think when affirmative action programs are in place?
- tokenadult 17y agowhat is one to think when affirmative action programs are in place? I wish I could be 100 percent sure that today's affirmative action programs operate like the first one I heard of (in 1968), when the idea of the program is that it connected students who didn't have college-educated parents to colleges that easily gained applications from children of alumni, but didn't get many applications from first-generation college students. Then what I would think of anyone admitted under an affirmative action program is, "It's only fair that he is here too, even though he didn't have the advantage I had of being a third-generation college student." But it's not clear now, college-by-college, just what happens in detail when the admission committee meets to decide whom to admit. The great majority of United States colleges admit nearly all of their applicants. Hundreds of colleges have explicit open-enrollment policies. So this whole issue only pertains to a small subset of the most desired colleges, colleges that reject the majority of their applicants.
- amichail 17y agoFYI, the whole idea of affirmative action used to bother me enormously. But not so much now that I realize that working for others is not a desirable goal.
- amichail 17y agoAs a white, it makes me somewhat sick to my stomach to think that I might have benefited from affirmative action. If Asians are better than me, score better than me, I shouldn't displace any of them in the university. I think this issue of fairness is a distraction. Focus on changing the world instead.
- cowmoo 17y agoAffirmative action doesn't bother me. So what if the SAT-tutored and AP/IB class-taking kids from suburbia couldn't get into Harvard, Princeton or Yale? Boohoo! It's the end of the world when they go to the Duke, CMU, or Cornell where upon graduation, you have finally (phew!) saved the family face after all by going to medical school, law school or becoming that engineer - so that your Asian or Jewish mother has something to good to say about her son at her friends' dinner party. Without the elite ivy league schools offering 100% financial aid (vs. middle-tier state schools that try to amp up their U.S News & Report Ranking by offering full-rides to high SAT scorers from the 'burbs, and hence could not accommodate 100% to need-based financial aid), a lot of urban kids wouldn't be able to afford college at all, not even state school. Also, schools that could afford to let down their average SAT scores often pick students based on their "narrative". A technical forum may sneer at the qualitative over quantitative, but it means that schools consider their applicants' background, what odds they had to overcome in their environment vs. say, how much money someone's parents spent for their child's Princeton Review classes. However, I agree with you in that affirmative action have a lot of inefficiencies. For instance, a lot of under-represented minorities from the 'burbs and prep school game the system by offering a offer that colleges can't refuse: high SAT score and diversity, but haven't overcome any serious odds as an urban student would. A lot of colleges game the system by claiming diversity on their admissions broshure, when recruiting a lot of black/hispanic students to their freshman pool - but do not do a proper job of trying to graduate their minority students at all.
- nkassis 17y ago"As a white, it makes me somewhat sick to my stomach to think that I might have benefited from affirmative action. If Asians are better than me, score better than me, I shouldn't displace any of them in the university." I didn't know this when I first heard of affirmative actions (moved to the US in junior year) but predominantly Black Colleges have to adhere to quotas too but have a hard time doing so. Many of those colleges simply do not get enough white or other ethnicity applicants. In fact, some give full scholarships to white students to try to attract them. So a measure that is supposed to help bring more minorities to college actually causes them to loose places they previously had. Frankly, having grown up in Canada, I had never really thought of the question until I moved to the US. I guess we sorta have a blind eye to those issues up here. Dunno if that's good or bad.
- tokenadult 17y agopredominantly Black Colleges have to adhere to quotas too Actually, quotas are strictly against the law under the Bakke decision http://www.oyez.org/cases/1970-1979/1977/1977_76_811/ http://www.oyez.org/cases/1970-1979/1977/1977_76_811/ for all state universities, and I have every reason to expect that an explicit quota would be found illegal for a private university under the general federal civil rights statute enforced by the Department of Education. But colleges appear to have suspiciously consistent numbers from year to year without admitting to having quotas. See http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/1063172559-post8.html http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/1063172559-post8.html for examples of colleges with large numbers of students officially reported to the federal government as "race unknown."
- brandnewlow 17y agoHey, I got into Princeton because they hadn't admitted anyone, much less a white middle class male, from Western Michigan in a few years. Everyone catches a break. No use crying over it. Exploit it.
- Alex3917 17y agoCollege admissions ain't YC. If schools actually admitted students based on merit, I'd be against this. But since they admit mostly based on grades and SAT scores, I find it difficult to complain. (And while they do theoretically factor in other stuff, for the most part that just means that in the event of a tie they choose the person who made a documented appearance at more after school 'clubs'.)
- bilbo0s 17y agoI actually have some experience in university admissions procedures at the University of Wisconsin. It is interesting that Princeton is being sued because it was one of the schools following a program that many had considered to hold some promise. It is based on socio-economic standing. So Mr. Li is saying Blacks, Hispanics, and Whites were admitted to Princeton, even though they were less qualified. Now I don't work at Princeton, but I am familiar with the admissions there. I am almost positive that lower and middle class students were admitted to the University in lieu of better qualified students from the elite classes. Probably causing Mr. Li to be rejected. The article alludes to this fact when it talks about poor whites being given admission over better qualified wealthy whites. I am also all but certain that poor asians were given admission over better qualified wealthy asians at Princeton that same year. Though I don't have the data to back up these assertions, it seems that the gentleman in the article does. It is pretty safe to say that the nation's universities will be watching this law suit with great interest. It will determine whether this socio-economics based admissions practice is wrong or if it is acceptable. More importantly, if it is acceptable, under what circumstances is it acceptable? This one will be VERY interesting. Not just an ordinary affirmative action suit. This one is quite out of the everyday.
- tokenadult 17y agoIt is interesting that Princeton is being sued Strictly speaking, Princeton is not being sued by anyone. There is no lawsuit here. There was a complaint by a rejected applicant to the federal Department of Education Office of Civil Rights http://www.ed.gov/about/offices/list/ocr/complaintprocess.html http://www.ed.gov/about/offices/list/ocr/complaintprocess.ht... and while the complainant first matriculated at Yale and then transferred to Harvard the inquiry was expanded. http://www.dailyprincetonian.com/2008/09/08/21307/ http://www.dailyprincetonian.com/2008/09/08/21307/ There still has not been any announcement of findings from the inquiry. The controlling law is a federal statute prohibiting discrimination by race in any higher education institution receiving federal funds. http://www.ed.gov/policy/rights/guid/ocr/raceoverview.html http://www.ed.gov/policy/rights/guid/ocr/raceoverview.html (All elite institutions of higher education receive federal funds.) Amazingly, this law has been on the books since the 1960s, but apparently most students have not been aware of their opportunity to make complaints to the federal Department of Education Office of Civil Rights in regard to the practices of privately operated colleges and universities. Previous Supreme Court cases on affirmative action have been based on a different body of law, the equal protection clause of the fourteenth amendment of the Constitution as applied to state universities.
- patio11 17y agoI find it darkly humorous that people express surprise that institutions which publish studies in support of racial discrimination, file briefs with the Supreme Court in favor of racial discrimination, write (and write, and write) in favor of racial discrimination, and have officers with six figure salaries put in charge of their departments of racial discrimination, might actually be engaged in racial discrimination.
- pmorici 17y agoI don't think it's so much that they are surprised it happens. They are just surprised to find they aren't considered a minority.
- jimmybot 17y agoTrue and nicely put. But, I would say the "surprise" here is not that it's harder for Asian Americans to get in relative to African Americans. You'd think that if you are guaranteeing or biasing towards a certain number of select groups, then the unselected groups would be equally biased against. But that's not what this study is finding. It's pointing towards the possibility that Asians are not just disadvantaged relative to their fellow minorities; they are disadvantaged relative to whites as well.
- patio11 17y agoThat's an interesting perspective that honestly had not occurred to me. I've have an unhealthy interest with admissions policies for, crikey, more than a decade now. The fact that affirmative action would require a disproportionate discrimination against Asians was obvious from the public data, and much remarked upon, more than a decade ago. It was also frequently remarked that this concern was just a stalking horse for white Republicans, for what its worth. Speaking of public data: universities have gotten very good at shutting it up like a drum because when it surfaces (in, for example, the Grantz vs. Bollinger litigation) it typically reveals that they are bald-faced liars on this subject. Relatedly, Princeton's written Affirmative Action Plan is available for inspection only if you go to campus and read it in their presence, but you won't be allowed to make copies.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- sachinag 17y agoSchools are not looking to admit the best students - they are looking to admit the best class. That means that they have an idea of what the shape and character of that class will look like, after taking into account certain restrictions (legacies, athletes, the band needs a tuba player, whatnot). There are only so many slots for high-achieving student council presidents. I look like every other Indian kid to the admissions committees; I needed to distinguish myself in other ways. If you're poor and Latino and you qualify academically, guess what, you've already distinguished yourself. Anti-Asian quotas aren't anti-Asian. They're anti-homogenous.
- codexon 17y agoI would think a school wants more future billionaires and Nobel prize winners instead of cherry picking 10 whites 10 asians 10 hispanics 10 blacks majoring in Art History and Divinity. This is certainly the image that Harvard et al. are cultivating.
- amichail 17y agoPerhaps diversity is part of the education.
- uuilly 17y agoDiversity in what? Color of skin? What about political or Religious beliefs? Those attributes are a lot more definitive than skin color.
- btilly 17y agoAbsolutely. Elite schools are selling a product. And the product that Harvard, Yale, etc sell is the image that they create well-rounded future leaders who are going places. There is an easy way to see whether you're part of the target market the school is selling to. Just look at how much financial aid they are willing to give you. If they are willing to give you generous financial aid, then you're part of the product being sold, not the target market. According to Harvard's current financial aid packages, if your parents make under $60,000, you're part of the product. If they make up to $120,000, you get steep discounts. If you're honest, there is an even easier way to judge. When I was at Dartmouth College the figure I heard was that they got more in donations each year than tuition. If your family is able to make those donations, then you are really in their target market.
- albertsun 17y agoAt least part of the problem is that it isn't well defined what colleges look for in applicants. For applying to something like YC, the goal is pretty clear. Applications are selected based on their likelihood of making lots of money in the future. Colleges select (I think) looking for people who will be "successful". Being "successful" in life is fortunately very hard to define.
- johnnybgoode 17y agoI don't really want to fight the last war. The real evil to be fought here is credentialism. Apparently even PG might agree: http://www.paulgraham.com/credentials.html http://www.paulgraham.com/credentials.html If you take care of that, both from a social angle and for employment, it won't feel like your life has taken a hit if you don't get into one of these schools. In fact you might not even want to go anymore.
- tokenadult 17y agoThe real evil to be fought here is credentialism. That's a very good point, and thanks for the link to pg's essay on that issue.
- johnnybgoode 17y agoI remember reading an article about this a while back. A college admissions officer was interviewed, and she admitted to thinking something like, "Oh great, another one of these kids" whenever she saw another Asian applicant who plays a musical instrument, (insert other stereotypical activities), etc. Your first reaction might be to accuse her of racism, but you can see why she would have the reaction she does. In certain areas, especially with large, high-achieving Asian communities, a lot of Asian children are encouraged by their parents to do essentially the same things to increase their chances of being admitted to the "top" schools. Is it any surprise that college admissions officers are getting bored of seeing very similar applications? Not that this necessarily justifies the decisions, or that this is the only reason for this phenomenon; obviously, it is not.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- johnnybgoode 17y agoThanks for sharing. I'm not sure how you feel about it, but that sounds terrible to me.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- johnnybgoode 17y agoWow, that sucks. At least you've been able to see the truth about what's actually happened and why.
- sayrer 17y agoThe study could show that Asian applicants are less likely to apply to lower ranking private colleges. Or, the "soft factors" they talk about could be something obvious, like admitting student athletes with lower SAT scores. Asian students might be less likely to focus on sports in high school.
- tokenadult 17y agoA different study reported in various news sources this year http://www.insidehighered.com/news/2009/04/20/mismatch http://www.insidehighered.com/news/2009/04/20/mismatch suggests other possibilities.