2 ms·
The fact that other things are protected by patent is irrelevant, because it appears this creator has no patents for this project. It's hard for me to imagine
by baddox 12y ago
The fact that other things are protected by patent is irrelevant, because it appears this creator has no patents for this project.
It's hard for me to imagine myself in the shoes of someone with views on intellectual property which are fundamentally very different from my own. I believe that views on IP like his harm the software community immensely. The fact that his specific take on IP (and his interpretation of relevant US law, which may or may not be accurate) is one which he believes benefits himself, combined with the "put yourself in his shoes" argument, is not sufficient for me to change my views.
- prutschman 12y agoHe has applied for a patent but appear not to have been issued yet: "System and method for phonetic representation" https://www.google.com/patents/US20090043584 https://www.google.com/patents/US20090043584 EDIT: Downthread someone looked it up and determined that it failed to issue
- acqq 12y agoEven with all what you say, do you really believe that there should exist any agreement that can never be annulled, no matter why? That if you agree with something not knowing full effects, somebody actually has the right to find you "guilty" for not knowing better? Do you really agree with the world where everybody who ever manages to trick somebody else is absolutely guaranteed to win?
- baddox 12y ago> do you really believe that there should exist any agreement that can never be annulled, no matter what? Definitely. I believe that most everyday transactions, like when I buy a loaf of bread from a store, should be like that. In general, most simple transactions that occurs within a very short time period without any stipulations for future action from any present party need not be annullable. My claim is that code licensing is an example of this of course any given license only applies to the state of the code when it was released with that license.
- acqq 12y agoLicensing is certainly not an "everyday transaction" by any means. Ask Google and Oracle.