4 ms·

Sort of; they were likely never engineers in the first place. Engineer is a licensed profession, like physician or lawyer. You can graduate law school, but that

Sort of; they were likely never engineers in the first place. Engineer is a licensed profession, like physician or lawyer. You can graduate law school, but that doesn't make you a lawyer; passing the bar does. In the US, it depends on the state, but the easiest path towards licensure is to graduate from an ABET-accredited undergraduate program. Some allow you to proceed to licensure without that, but it requires extra experience to compensate. ABET does accredit international programs.

mynameisvlad 12y ago
> ABET does accredit international programs. Some international programs. They don't have nearly enough capacity to accredit every single international engineering program all over the world. I'm sure they have the major ones down, but there's plenty that are probably not which still teach engineering. > Engineer is a licensed profession, like physician or lawyer. The license only gives you the right to call yourself a Professional Engineer. Like I said before, unless it is illegal to call yourself an engineer without being a PEng and being licensed, then the "licensed profession" part of it really does not matter. A company can require you to be a PEng in order to receive an "engineer" title in your role, but there is still nothing, short of law that prevents you from using it yourself. > like physician or lawyer. And they're both different from engineer, because those licensed professions are actually legally enforced, whereas "engineer" is not legally enforced everywhere.
- mcmancini 12y ago
  No, the license allows one to offer engineering services to the public and the PE title is granted in recognition of that right. It is generally illegal to call yourself an engineer, but most people are able to use the industrial exemption. Nevertheless, in using the industrial exemption one is not offering engineering services to the general public. I don't know what happens if you tried to use the industrial exemption but offered services to the public, but I think it's prohibited. This all varies between states, but in general, if you for example started a software consulting firm called Vlad Engineering and the principals were not licensed, your local licensing board would likely have beef with you. If you were a software engineer at Vlad Consulting you would probably be okay. The bottom line is that it's tricky to navigate, and so it was recommended at my school we avoid using engineering anywhere unless we had our PE license.
  - jacalata 12y ago
    http://www.growthengineering.co.uk/ http://www.growthengineering.co.uk/
- kec 12y ago
  "Engineer" is legally enforced everywhere. If you don't believe me, try to get a building built without having a licensed Civil Engineer sign off on the blueprints.
  - jacalata 12y ago
    That has nothing to do with enforcement of calling yourself an engineer. That's saying that people enforce who can build buildings.

mynameisvlad 12y ago

> ABET does accredit international programs. Some international programs. They don't have nearly enough capacity to accredit every single international engineering program all over the world. I'm sure they have the major ones down, but there's plenty that are probably not which still teach engineering. > Engineer is a licensed profession, like physician or lawyer. The license only gives you the right to call yourself a Professional Engineer. Like I said before, unless it is illegal to call yourself an engineer without being a PEng and being licensed, then the "licensed profession" part of it really does not matter. A company can require you to be a PEng in order to receive an "engineer" title in your role, but there is still nothing, short of law that prevents you from using it yourself. > like physician or lawyer. And they're both different from engineer, because those licensed professions are actually legally enforced, whereas "engineer" is not legally enforced everywhere.

mcmancini 12y ago
No, the license allows one to offer engineering services to the public and the PE title is granted in recognition of that right. It is generally illegal to call yourself an engineer, but most people are able to use the industrial exemption. Nevertheless, in using the industrial exemption one is not offering engineering services to the general public. I don't know what happens if you tried to use the industrial exemption but offered services to the public, but I think it's prohibited. This all varies between states, but in general, if you for example started a software consulting firm called Vlad Engineering and the principals were not licensed, your local licensing board would likely have beef with you. If you were a software engineer at Vlad Consulting you would probably be okay. The bottom line is that it's tricky to navigate, and so it was recommended at my school we avoid using engineering anywhere unless we had our PE license.
- jacalata 12y ago
  http://www.growthengineering.co.uk/ http://www.growthengineering.co.uk/
kec 12y ago
"Engineer" is legally enforced everywhere. If you don't believe me, try to get a building built without having a licensed Civil Engineer sign off on the blueprints.
- jacalata 12y ago
  That has nothing to do with enforcement of calling yourself an engineer. That's saying that people enforce who can build buildings.