8 ms·
Interesting. It is entirely possible it is survivor bias on my part but I get the suspicion that a global sort of 'cyberwar' that has been rumbling along for y
by ChuckMcM 12y ago
Interesting.
It is entirely possible it is survivor bias on my part but I get the suspicion that a global sort of 'cyberwar' that has been rumbling along for years is heating up rapidly. I've seen a 10x increase in various scripted attacks being attempted (patch early and often folks!) and a number of APT level compromises of systems either staging malware or deploying it (see the latest bulletin on the Afghan government compromise). And of course the whole Free Syrian Army / ISIS / terrorist nom de jure attacks.
I can't shake the analogy to pictures from WW II where shop keepers were huddled in the back while soldiers fought from the front of the store. I see innocent servers being 'occupied' by enemy malware so that it can launch attacks on other servers further into a protected network.
Fortunately in this modern version of war you can "kick the soldiers out" of your server by bringing it down and re-imaging it. And they won't turn around and shoot you, but that is not all that comforting somehow.
- _RPM 12y agoDoes ISIS really have the resources to carry out criminal computer activities? From what I understand, they are a group with limited technological advantage, and there is no way they could carry out a major attack on the Internet.
- ossreality 12y agoWhat "resouces" do you need? A credit card and a curious 20 year old could inflict a massive amount of damage with little effort, given a vulnerability to exploit. I can spin up a thousand VMs in 4 cloud providers in seconds. By the way, I'm aware I was hellbanned. It was well over a year ago. My comments were on-topic and polite before I was banned. The funny thing is, the person I was banned for arguing with has burned through half a dozen accounts. I refuse to play ball with HN's shitty policy of hellbanning and so I post like an asshole. Hellbanning is exceedingly rude and everytime I want to comment I remember how much it pisses me off so I decide to let it affect my comments. (For context, my original HN account was nearly in the Top 10 [with an average of ~10] when it was banned for arguing with the same person ironically.) Awe, that's too bad. Jamesaguilar and I see eye-to-eye on most things and I respect their attention to bs sexism and racism on HN :)
- geographomics 12y ago(Note to ossreality, who also replied to this comment: you appear to be hellbanned.)
- jamesaguilar 12y agoWith good reason, based on his posting history. It's pointless to warn someone like this that they are hell-banned. Any new account they make will suffer a similar fate within a small handful of posts.
- jamesaguilar 12y agoRe: his edit, thank you for your compliment, but I just think there are more constructive ways to approach most conversations than accusing people of talking out of their ass, or calling them losers. :( If you truly were banned for arguing with someone important, that's unfortunate, but I saw two good reasons to ban you in your most recent three comments. Maybe I just caught you on a bad day.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- Havoc 12y agoMust admit I'm slightly amused that this is even being considered as a plausible theory. They're busy executing elderly with AK47s...thats very far away from physically cracking open servers in a western data center and inserting USB devices with targeted attack software.
- Crito 12y agoIt is not merely the uneducated who can subscribe to extremist ideologies. When the unskilled highschool grad gets off the plane and signs up, they are going to give him a rifle. When the engineer gets off the plane and announces himself as such, there is a chance that he will be put to better use.
- junto 12y agoSadly, the fastest route to martyrdom is quite literally by biting a bullet, so no, AK-47's all round. Keyboards don't have quite the same sacrificial qualities.
- nilbot 12y agoI can imagine that those AKs are just the front. There might be someone or some organizations that sponsor the extremists. Money or otherwise. People who might benefit from instability, hatred towards the US etc.
- JonnieCache 12y agoIslamist groups are not so fixated on martyrdom and the proverbial 72 virgins as you may have been led to believe.
- vegedor 12y agoIslamist Groups ight not be as homogenous as the GP implies, either. Some higher ups might actually have perfidious goals. But what am I talking about, religion was never used as means to manipulate followers, ever.
- 12y ago
- grrowl 12y agoTo assume the only adversary is ISIS would be extremely foolish. Any actors within a system side with particular groups and ideologies. The Tor project maintainers align to an ideology shared with many other groups, just as ISIS align with a shared ideology, NSA/FBI etc share another... More likely NSA/FBI/nation-state level, or a large hacking group, although the former has clear motive here. ISIS has little motive for this. Use your common sense.
- nikolak 12y agoWell they do have money, while they may not have members that possess the necessary knowledge I'm sure they could finance such attacks. That being said, they do not look to me like a group that would be using, and generally be interested in, such tactics.
- ridgewell 12y agoISIS has foreign supporters, and I promise you there's at least one sysadmin or netsec professional out there backing the outfit.
- internetisthesh 12y agoI considered partnering with a data center owner in the US until I learned that his organisation was monitored by NSA for doing bad stuff in Syria. As you say, of course ISIS and similar organizations has supporters among "ordinary people" in EU and US.
- foobarqux 12y agoWhen it hits hedge funds and private equity firms people will start caring.
- jerf 12y agoOh, the whole cyberwar situation is far from "hopeless". The truth is nobody to speak of has taken it seriously yet. Security is still mostly an afterthought, if that, almost everywhere you look. Even in nominally security-focused contexts. And much of the activity in places that really are security focused are built around an environment in which software must be assumed to basically be constructed out of styrofoam and radioactive waste, so they end up looking very restrictive in reaction to this reality. I'm fairly convinced that if we all really tried we could secure things much better than they are today. The personal tripwire I've been watching for is when it finally becomes simply general knowledge that C is completely unsuitable to write security software in and C++ is pretty damned dangerous. (Many people know this, but a large contingent will still push back on that. Once we get serious about security, one of the things that will have to happen is C is going to have be evicted from its current privileged position.) Lest I sound utopian, yes, this will require immense effort. My point is precisely that we've never really tried that level of effort yet, not that the effort will be low. There's no real reason that the Internet actually has to be made out of swiss cheese, but it will take a significant change of viewpoint before it will be resolved.
- jrochkind1 12y ago> Security is still mostly an afterthought, if that, almost everywhere you look... yes, this will require immense effort. What I keep thinking, though, is, what would be the total dollar cost to make security a forethought, with information technology being pretty ubiquitous? I think it might actually have serious economic impact -- is it possible we literally can't afford security, as a society?
- mbrutsch 12y agoThe problem with "how much" is this: as the dollar amount of loss increases, the distance between "the owners of the money" and "the people responsible for keeping it safe" also increases. I make sure I know where my wallet is, but Jeff in IT won't lose billions (or a clueless CIO, for that matter).
- drcomputer 12y ago> It is entirely possible it is survivor bias on my part but I get the suspicion that a global sort of 'cyberwar' that has been rumbling along for years is heating up rapidly. It might have been a freudian slip or some kind of intuition, but when I was describing my life plans to my family, I said something along the lines of "I don't want to manage people, I want to stay on the front lines with the code." Except I don't want it to be scary, because I can't take anymore of that in my life. So what I really mean is "deploy knowledge bases" and that I choose to work in education. So I continue to stand on a soapbox of 'ethical coding' and I continue to request the ability to separate the responsibility of the developer from the technological applications to warfare. I just want to code difficult stuff, with intense mathematics and abstractions, and solve hard problems. I don't want people using that to hurt other people, and people who don't code don't seem to get that. People wonder why I get depressed, and to a lot of people it probably looks super dumb and selfish, and I've lost a lot of friends over the years over things I couldn't really explain. People say I over-analyze things and that I think too much. Maybe I do, maybe I don't think enough. It's pretty easy for me to have these opinions when my life is stable.
- ay1n 12y agoI've heard opinions along the lines of "thinking too much" countless of times, at first it was kind of depressing but later I've concluded that if you just like to think and analyze things in your mind (which is not so popular thing to do when you consider general population, sadly), people who voice such (negative, I'd say) comments didn't really think about this deeply. Over-analying can be a serious problem (consider some forms of OCD), but when you can somehow control it (but not constrain) it's ok to think as much as one like ;).
- drcomputer 12y agoYea, the repetitive analysis usually stems from using the same model of which to analyze the data by. It's insufficient. That helps me turn it off, listen to other people, go about my life, learn new ways of thinking, connecting, interacting, helping, participating, and then I continue to re-evaluate myself, existence, and my place in it. I still can't shake the depression, though. Unless the entire world existed in a state of neutrality or bliss, I don't think I could. It's just an echo of sadness, something I have to distance myself from internally and examine scientifically, which allows me to remove it's control over me, and instead direct myself in ways I can improve the world, but, /shrug. I'm not perfect and I'm never going to exist perfectly and life is never going to be perfect, if perfect even could exist.
- bashinator 12y agoIf the USB device from the article is doing anything along the lines of BadUSB or EFI compromise, then re-imaging your server won't accomplish much. https://trmm.net/EFI https://trmm.net/EFI
- ChuckMcM 12y agoWell that is not reassuring :-(. Particularly the part about it copying itself to other Thunderbolt devices.
- throwaway2048 12y agoit is pretty likely the USB device is this http://www.cru-inc.com/products/wiebetech/mouse_jiggler/ http://www.cru-inc.com/products/wiebetech/mouse_jiggler/ to prevent the computer going to sleep while this is utilized http://www.cru-inc.com/products/wiebetech/hotplug_field_kit/ http://www.cru-inc.com/products/wiebetech/hotplug_field_kit/ These are pretty standard plays in seizing computers these days. One should note that the grsec linux patchset has functionality to not load drivers for any plugged usb devices, as well as log when it happens, possibly resulting in action being taken.
- mmaunder 12y agoMight be an interesting strategy to only allow one USB port to be used and if any other port is activated the machine self-wipes. Dell servers have an internal port along with the front and back externals.
- sauere 12y agoOr use USB-ID white/blacklists.
- ossreality 12y agoso, the very thing that are fakeable and changeable via these hacks. try agian
- 12y ago
- new299 12y agoFortunately in this modern version of war you can "kick the soldiers out" of your server by bringing it down and re-imaging it. And they won't turn around and shoot you, but that is not all that comforting somehow. Until "DeathRay3000" becomes a standard peripheral it is slightly comforting... Overall, I worry more about the hacks I haven't detected than those I have. Re-imaging is a pain, but not as much as not knowing your server is secure.
- higherpurpose 12y agoDid you even read the post? This has nothing to do with "cyberwar", "terrorism" and other scaremongering words you used. His servers were taken over by law enforcement. You're free to call them cyberterrorists if you wish. These days it's hard to tell the difference in tactics between malicious rivals and your own government anyway.
- alexivanovs 12y agoIt has already happened, you just don't know about it, and neither do I. I've had experience in the scene for many years. Though I don't go there these days, I can almost guarantee that the big players have long had their databases downloaded and spread throughout multiple nations. Your guess is as good as mine...
- jnbiche 12y agoI'm surprised that this comment has been voted to the top. First, it has little to nothing to do with the comment posted, which concerns not a "cyberwar" but the possible police seizure of a Tor server. The assumption is it's either a false alarm or a police raid. No one thinks this was done by ISIS. Second, a post using the word "cyberwar" in a non-ironic manner at the top of HN?! O tempora o mores! So while your observation about an increased number of scripting attacks is interesting (assuming you did in fact establish a reliable baseline) it's in a strange place. Did you mean to post elsewhere?
- harkyns_castle 12y agoI don't know, sometimes something in an article triggers another stream of thought or tangent, and its a comments section, and other people might want to discuss that. I don't necessarily agree with the comment (as I have next to no visibility of this) but certainly don't mind reading comments on it. Maybe I'm wrongly using the site!