4 ms·
That doesn't necessarily imply the people asking are sexist. They might simply be Bayesians.
by yummyfajitas 17y ago
That doesn't necessarily imply the people asking are sexist. They might simply be Bayesians.
- jacquesm 17y agoYou could not have made the point of the author of the article better than by showing exactly how that comes about. An employer does not have a right to ask that question of either partner. It is a question concerning their private life. If the question is not sexist then it should turn out that it is asked as much of guys as it is asked of women and it turns out that is not the case. It ends right there. No amount of 'buts' or other terms like that going to make that go away. The condition is already satisfied, no need to inspect other variables to see if we can change the outcome of the program, they are now irrelevant. Imagine the reverse, if an employer would ask a guy: "I take it your wife is home and looks after the children ?". My response would be 'none of your business'. You can safely assume that people are not going to leave their children unattended, how they go about that is their problem, and none of your business as an employer. No matter whether the person in front of you is male or female.
- yummyfajitas 17y agoThe issue of whether employers can ask questions about one's private life is rather orthogonal to the issue of sexism, no? Not that it matters, but I agree that children, hobbies, drug use and sex partners are not the business of my employer.
- jacquesm 17y agoThat's true, but the fact is that such a question would never be asked of a guy. That is what makes it sexist. After all, if it is none of the employers business when they're talking to a guy why should that change when interviewing a woman ?
- yummyfajitas 17y agoThe employer may believe it is their business (regardless of gender), but that the probability of a man missing work due to children is considerably lower than a woman doing so. Similarly, employers might ask reserve officers about service obligations, while not bothering to ask them of civilians. They could do this not out of a bias against military folk, but simply because reserve officers have a considerably higher chance of missing work due to service obligations.
- tptacek 17y agoHow insightful. They are similar cases! So much so that it is also unlawful to consider an applicant's pending service obligations during hiring.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- jacquesm 17y agoThe interesting thing here is that as an employer you really don't want to go in to territory like that, because if you end up not accepting the employee for the position you are open to legal action because of having asked such questions during an interview. Most larger corporations have a pretty long list of stuff that you have to familiarize yourself with before being allowed to interview people independently for exactly that reason. Or they'll have someone from HR breathing down your neck during the interview. Seriously, these questions are off limits. At all times. An interview should concentrate on the applicants capabilities, suitability for the job in terms of teamwork, qualifications and so on. Go outside those boundaries on the asking side and you are in trouble. If someone volunteers information like that and you use it to make your decision better be ready to back it up with a 'real' reason or you are still going to be open to trouble. That's one of the reasons why rejection letters are such inane boilerplate, most companies are loathe to tell you why you were rejected for fear of opening themselves up to legal issues.
- 17y ago
- tptacek 17y agoYou know how the original article talked about how people that didn't believe there were being sexist ("just Bayesian!") are incapable of detecting sexism? Case in point. Whatever you think about the question, apart from the fact that it's unlawful to ask, it's incredibly douchey. It's none of your business, and implies that you think the woman is going to be a complicated hire because she's got kids. In case it wasn't clear enough, the idea isn't that the interviewers are concerned for the kids. They're not. They just think they can predict the absentee rate for people by their chromosomes. Women with kids have to stay home when the kids get sick, right?
- yummyfajitas 17y agoI never suggested the interviewers were concerned for the kids -- my implicit assumption was simply that they want to avoid employee absence. The only assumption I'm making is that P(absent|women with children) >> P(absent|no children or man). Do you dispute this prior? Similarly, you might also (unlawfully) ask about potential military service obligations if a person listed "Army Reserve" on their resume. Would that necessarily be motivated by anti-military bias? Of course not; it could simply reflect a desire that employees predictably show up to work. (As pointed out downthread, illegal != sexist.) Note that I didn't say anyone was or was not sexist; I simply said they might not be.
- tptacek 17y agoI don't care whether the people are sexist, yummyfajitas. The process is sexist. I saw it firsthand: it's harder for a woman with kids to get a tech job than it is for a man to get the same job, absent any difference in qualifications. What, exactly, is it that you want to argue about here?
- yummyfajitas 17y agoThe process is designed simply to find employees who will show up for work, not to eliminate women. So the process isn't sexist either. Just because something disproportionately harms women (or men) does not make it sexist. It is only sexist if the goal is to reduce the number of women (rather than the number of absent employees, as in this case).