3 ms·
If I actually trusted the FDA to do their job properly maybe I could spend less time staring at brand names in the cold aisle. If we all trusted the FDA implic
by zaroth 12y ago
If I actually trusted the FDA to do their job properly maybe I could spend less time staring at brand names in the cold aisle.
If we all trusted the FDA implicitly, then the next logical step could be to actually ban the entire concept of applying brand names to off-patent pharmaceuticals and rework the entire cold aisle into a patient-education + active ingredient grab bag. In such a world, phenylephrine is phenylephrine, guaifenesin is guaifenesin, and all shoppers would care about is the form factor and dosages.
I've read on HN about exactly how many fucks the FDA gives these days when billion dollar pharma is forging test results while they knowingly pump crap generic meds with zero quality control out of their dirty factories. See, for example, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8468099 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8468099. So that leaves us with the flimsy fallback of hoping brands like Mucinex believe good QC is absolutely essential to maintaining their market position.
TFA claims American consumers waste "tens of billions" on brand name pills. I'm sure this stat isn't just cold/flu meds, but probably including blockbusters like Lipitor vs generic as well. That's like a $10 billion tax because we can't fully trusted the quality and bio-equivalence reviews the FDA is tasked to enforce?! By comparison, the total FDA budget is $4.5 billion.
- zaroth 12y agoTo give a specific example of where this works in practice, take buying a good piece of steak. While some chains try to brand their beef one way or another, all you really want to look for is "USDA Prime". The USDA... they really, really know how to grade a cut of beef. I trust them implicitly, when I see "USDA Prime" I know exactly what I'm going to get. Now imagine having that same level of trust in the FDA. "Guaifenesin 1200mg 24 Hour - FDA Prime" would be all I need to see, and I'm grabbing that bottle. Spend a cool $5 billion setting up that program for the Top 100 generics, and you save Americans, what, maybe about a trillion dollars over the next 30 years? Just like with beef, this isn't about controlling production, or subsidizing the factory, but simply establishing public trust in an inspection process.