3 ms·
Another one: Any time an agency of the government collects a fine to deter bad behavior, the money must be given to another agency that is significantly removed
by jessriedel 12y ago
Another one: Any time an agency of the government collects a fine to deter bad behavior, the money must be given to another agency that is significantly removed from the decision making process that sets the fine, or to charity. Likewise for seized goods, etc. If the county police department starts writing more tickets for rolling stops, the money just ends up with the parks department. (Obviously it is possible in principle for different agencies to collude, but the same can be said about all checks and balances. The point is to make coordinating the collusion difficult/dangerous.)
People can complain all they want about individual instances of civil forfeiture or predatory red-light cameras, but those sorts of issues are all caused by the incentives induced when the agency that enacts the fine benefits from the money collected.
(This does not apply to the separate penalties/restitution used to compensate victims, pay for fixing actual damage, etc..)
If some agencies are currently dependent on revenue through fines, then this requires a one-time adjustment to their budget. But this is good as it just means that the cost of running their agencies becomes more transparent.
- ashark 12y agoI think traffic and parking fines should fund public transportation.
- chrishynes 12y agoThat sounds like a good idea on the surface but it doesn't actually discourage anything. If the revenue is getting into government at all it still has the same perverse incentives. Case in point: the many small towns that get a substantial chunk of their overall revenue from fines and police action --https://www.google.com/search?q=town+police+revenue https://www.google.com/search?q=town+police+revenue
- redacted 12y agoI think the better way would be that such fines are sent straight to a national/federal agency, which in turn disburses the fund across the entire country as needed. That would prevent any corrupt small-town police force from simply fining people to raise money because they may never see any of it themselves.
- nostromo 12y agoJust destroy the money. There should be no incentive for the government to collect fines. We should incentivize fewer crimes and fewer fines, not more. If you're worried about deflation, then another solution would be to put all the fines collected into a fund that is split up and given directly back to the citizenry every year. But the point is that crime shouldn't fund government as it's a perverse incentive.
- alexbecker 12y agoIt's worth noting that from the federal govt's perspective, destroying money and collecting it are basically the same. As long as the supply of money decreases, they can just print more.
- chrishynes 12y agoSending the revenue up the chain only enables graft and corruption at a larger scale, not to mention constitutional issues at the federal level at least. The only solution I see is to make enforcement absolute and trust that enough people get hit with unreasonable fines that they vote in someone who will end them. The big issue here is selective enforcement keeping the pool of people affected small enough that they can't effectively fight back.
- WalterSear 12y agoThose revenues aren't going to an agency that is removed from the situation. The revenues should be going to the state, or the federal level. Or simply removed from circulation