4 ms·
I doubt this will be a popular post, but I'll make it anyway. If there are some seizures of directory authorities or other project infrastructure, this won't b
by mike_hearn 12y ago
I doubt this will be a popular post, but I'll make it anyway.
If there are some seizures of directory authorities or other project infrastructure, this won't be some totally unpredictable occurrence. It was only about a month and a half ago that some relays were seized as part of a general takedown against Tor hidden services. The Tor project posted this blog in response:
https://blog.torproject.org/blog/thoughts-and-concerns-about-operation-onymous https://blog.torproject.org/blog/thoughts-and-concerns-about...
That blog post convinced me to shut down my relay. The reason is, to an ambitious prosecutor this blog post looks like:
"We view law enforcement operations as attacks and are looking for ways to defeat them, because we are determined to shield the identities of our criminal clients"
... which is exactly what resulted in the operators of the Silk Roads getting arrested even though they were not personally selling drugs.
The blog post makes casual reference to the "enormous social value" of hidden services and claim they're worried about "secret police repressing dissidents", but doesn't cite any actual examples. Actually I've never heard of a hidden service that has enormous social value - whilst there are a small number of .onion addresses that aren't completely illegal or unethical, for all the examples I know of the operators are not anonymous.
To police forces around the world who keep having investigations hit a dead end because of Tor, going after the project directly will not seem very different than going after services like Liberty Reserve. The people running it are stating publicly that they will do their best to frustrate investigations, and that is dangerously close to admitting participation in a criminal conspiracy. Thin ice doesn't even begin to describe their current situation.
- nate_meurer 12y ago> "Actually I've never heard of a hidden service that has enormous social value" You make it sound like you've actually looked. Perhaps you've spoken to some Ukrainians, or protesters in Turkey or Honk Kong, and they've assured you they have little use for "hidden services"?
- mike_hearn 12y agoI have looked (or at least paid close attention) and I am unaware of anyone in Ukraine, Turkey or Hong Kong using hidden services for political reasons. Additionally, Tor gets way less traffic from people trying to evade national firewalls than VPN services do. They aren't the big fish in that space at all.
- cloakandswagger 12y agoYou heard it here first folks. Mike_hearn has scoured the earth and cannot find one person using hidden services for non-criminal purposes.
- mike_hearn 12y agoCan you? Besides, I'm not sure what your point is. Societies don't tend to judge a thing by whether there's a single good use, somewhere. They weigh things up. Hidden services can be enumerated, so it's not impossible to find one if there's some awesome hidden service somewhere. But such a site would get a lot of attention very quickly. It wouldn't be secret very long. Hopefully this whole story will amount to nothing. It'd be very sad if Tor disappeared. But let's face it - when you have the Prime Minister of a technically advanced western country tasking one of the worlds most advanced intelligence agencies with "break the dark web" they were going to hit serious problems sooner or later anyway. And mostly that's because of hidden services. It'd be a crying shame if this one feature with hardly any legitimate usage caused the entire project to tank.
- louthy 12y ago> Societies ... They weigh things up. Societies don't 'weigh' anything up. Governments with idealogical leanings make decisions regardless of evidence. You only have to look at the 'war on drugs' to see how, regardless of the evidence put before them, politicians will blindly follow their ideologies. 'Weighing up' implies a reasoned judgement, based on the arguments for and against and based on the available evidence. To think that the UK or US (or any other) government works that way is naive.
- olalonde 12y agoI agree that they are vastly inflating the utility of Tor for people in repressive regimes given how easy it is to block Tor at an ISP level (e.g. Tor is completely blocked in China).
- ossreality 12y agoDo you understand how the internet works? Probably not.
- canjobear 12y agoThey pointedly didn't mention China in their list of repressive regimes: "Iran, Syria, and Russia". I think for most people, China is the first country that comes to mind when you think about internet censorship. But my experience is that it is impossible to connect to Tor there. Maybe they are acknowledging that tacitly. Or maybe they were trying to make the blog post more palatable to US government readers, since Iran, Syria, and Russia are currently bad guys, while things with China are supposed to be fine.
- wfn 12y agoAs 'blunder has mentioned elsewhere, you should use pluggable transports (try obfs3, scramblesuit, fte in https://bridges.torproject.org/options https://bridges.torproject.org/options) when in mainland China. Don't use vanilla Tor bridges or vanilla Tor there.
- justcommenting 12y agothere are ~1200 directly connecting users [0] and ~200 bridge users [1] who might dispute the assertion that 'Tor is completely blocked in China'. instead of casting aspersions on a free software project, i would encourage you to please help make tor more useful for these users, or to build your own alternative. [0] https://metrics.torproject.org/userstats-relay-country.html?graph=userstats-relay-country&start=2014-09-21&end=2014-12-20&country=cn&events=off https://metrics.torproject.org/userstats-relay-country.html?... [1] https://metrics.torproject.org/userstats-bridge-country.html?graph=userstats-bridge-country&start=2014-09-21&end=2014-12-20&country=cn https://metrics.torproject.org/userstats-bridge-country.html...
- mrsteveman1 12y ago> The blog post makes casual reference to the "enormous social value" of hidden services and claim they're worried about "secret police repressing dissidents", but doesn't cite any actual examples. I'll give you one: Russia currently has laws that, among other things, require the author of a blog to register personal information with the government if the blog has more than 3,000 daily readers[1]. The law is specifically intended to prevent anonymity. When working as intended, hidden services enable those blog authors to protect their identity and ensure the government doesn't harass, arrest or kill them. [1] http://www.bbc.com/news/technology-28583669 http://www.bbc.com/news/technology-28583669
- mike_hearn 12y agoIt's much, much easier for them to just write a Wordpress or Blogger blog, hosted in the USA where Russia can't get access to the logs. Or in any other jurisdiction that won't respond to Russian requests for their data. The big advantage is - anyone can read your blog. Not just people who are willing to download and use the Tor browser. Most famous cases of dissent in recent times have preferred to play jurisdictional arbitrage rather than use Tor. Snowden is being kept safe by Russia, his information was published by a British newspaper that then shifted reporting to New York to avoid the UK government goons. Apparently for now that's good enough. This is why I talked about specific examples of hidden services being used in this way and actually getting real traction - I can't think of any.
- dbdr 12y agoI see your point about hidden services severely limiting the practical accessibility of the content. But isn't it a good idea to use Tor rather than HTTP(S) to compose that blog in such situation?
- mike_hearn 12y agoIn theory yes, in practice most people I know in places with strict firewalls use commercial VPNs rather than Tor (faster, easier). Also if you're hosting on a site like Wordpress or Blogger all the government sees is an SSL connection to wordpress.com or google.com. They don't get to see if you're reading or composing. So in practice it's probably good enough.
- mrkickling 12y agoHere is one example, journalists.
- sysfu 12y agoI'm surprised that you considered running a relay too risky after that blog post and shut it down. If it was an exit node OK, but a relay? Really?!