4 ms·
MIT Computer Scientists Demonstrate the Hard Way That Gender Still Matters
- pseudosavant 12y agoThe lack of civility and humanity on the Internet can be astounding. You are a neanderthal if you think it is ok to heckle (at best) or threaten (at worst) women in tech.
- pron 12y agoI think much of this behavior is due to people's young age, and the complete lack of understanding of what sexism is. I often see people here on HN confuse sexism (which is a systemic, often cultural discrimination against women, usually with no malice involved) with misogyny (disdain or contempt towards women). They fail to realize that most of us are sexist without realizing it, and that doesn't mean we're evil -- just a product of an unfair society. Instead of listening and trying to find hidden biases (which are sometimes as interesting to spot as a well-hidden bug in a program) they start getting defensive, and quickly progress from sexism to outright misogyny.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- Zigurd 12y agoIt's pretty educational. Very few people on this site fall into racist, sexist, homophobic patterns. We would like to believe cops are mostly good. But... If you want to be horrified by what cops really think, go to a cop discussion board. If you want your image of a post-racial America shattered, go to Facebook and search for Ferguson. If you want to find out if there is still a big huge problem with sexism in the tech industry, do a Reddit AMA.
- tzs 12y ago> You are a neanderthal I'm not quite sure whether that remark is racist or speciest, but as someone whose DNA is 3.3% Neanderthal according to 23andMe testing, I say screw you either way.
- Zigurd 12y agoHe should have used "troglodyte," which is a safely fictional proto-human, to imply someone is an unevolved cave man.
- killertypo 12y agothe disrespect and downright abuse of women in technology is both disturbing and downright disgusting. When will it end? What will it take for people to back off gender for a moment and listen to what people have to offer. Who cares what is between your legs when your contribution is a gift from the heart and mind.
- detcader 12y agoIt will certainly take more than referring to men as "people" when what is actually meant is "men", the perpetrators of the abuse you refer to.
- killertypo 12y agonot always, but most certainly is true very often.
- imanaccount247 12y ago>Who cares what is between your legs when your contribution is a gift from the heart and mind. How ironic when that is the exact statement they are complaining about in the first place.
- totony 12y agoI'm not sure to understand HN's ranking system. This is top page and is an article extrapolating sexism in a particular field from being trolled on reddit, which seems to me quite common. (Also, the article had 5 points and one comment as of this posting) On subject: As I said, concluding something from being trolled by people on reddit does not seem valid.
- latj 12y agoI asked a serious non-gender related question and never got an answer. A significant portion of MIT is the R&D extension of the pentagon. If an MIT researcher brings up an ethical issue related to the application of their research, does it spark a discussion or are they ignored as someone who is not focusing on the problem at hand? Or, are people who ask thoses sorts of questions already filtered out by this point? It is not gender related but probably the most important question you could ask an MIT academic. Its too bad they chose not to answer.
- detcader 12y ago"People treat girls and boys differently from an early age, giving them different feedback and expectations." Bold, italicize, underline. So many of my fellow men would never dispute that organized religion is only sustained through socialization of young children, but few seem to observe the similar pattern for sex ineqaulity.
- tomp 12y agoI think not many people would oppose that statement. Where opinions differ is whether one or the other sex is given an advantage in a particular subject/area of life.
- catshirt 12y ago"The interactions in the AMA itself showed that gender does still matter." does it really? it sounds like if their gender was omitted in the first place, the topic would not have been breached. i'm not saying their conclusion is incorrect, i'm just confused by how they got there. say for example, a "gay computer scientist" did an AMA. some people would (rightfully) ask "why does your sexual orientation matter?". others will make fun of them for being gay. the only thing i'm convinced of is that some people like to harass and provoke and troll. and for those people, minorities are easy targets. and the internet is the easiest and safest place to do it. and when you're dealing with an audience of 5000 people on Reddit, statistically speaking a subset of them are going to be that kind of stupid. edit: the fact that my comment, and literally over half the other comments in this thread are grey, support my simpler conclusion that uncivil people exist.
- jack-r-abbit 12y agoI think people are incorrectly reacting to you questioning "does [gender] really [matter]?" It appears to me that you are questioning "does [the AMA] really [show]?" I think you made sound questions in a civil way. I don't see why you should be downvoted. But HN is fickle at times.
- catshirt 12y agothanks for a thoughtful response. your analysis is correct. but, given that the article convinced me of nothing, further posing the question "does gender really matter" seems fair as well. i thought my intent was clear when i explained "i'm not saying their conclusion is incorrect, i'm just confused by how they got there." i didn't intend to disagree with their conclusion- i was simply drawing another conclusion from their data.
- omonra 12y agoI thought exactly the same thing. Their complaints fall into two: 1) People questioned why they brought up being female 2) Trolls asked stupid/offensive questions We can all quickly agree on #2. It's 100% unacceptable but simply reflects (as you pointed out) that certain % of population are assholes, not widespread gender issue. However - #1 seems valid to me. In the words of supreme court justice Roberts - "The way to stop discrimination on the basis of race is to stop discriminating on the basis of race". Ie if you want people to stop discriminating on the basis of gender, stop making it a deal. One may agree or disagree with this logic - but it's silly to point at it as example of 'gender discrimination'. YOU may want to make your gender an issue, but others' not wishing to join you in it doesn't mean anything.