4 ms·
It's very interesting that the project has some advanced notice about a threat. My first guess would be that a nation has made some demands of the project that
by discostrings 12y ago
It's very interesting that the project has some advanced notice about a threat.
My first guess would be that a nation has made some demands of the project that the project won't comply with, and that country has suggested they will seize the directory authority servers located inside it if the demands aren't met soon. [Edit: a new comment by arma on the original story, "To be sure to keep our source safe, we're not providing more details quite yet", makes this seem less likely.]
Or perhaps an insider has leaked some plans to the project.
Along another line of thought, if the US government wanted to further complicate online privacy, I imagine they'd choose a time like now, when headlines about the "cyber intrusions" of 2014 are at a peak. I wonder what other actors could have large enough power over their directory authority servers for the project to post this message.
Edit: Indeed, from a post below by paralelogram [0] and by checking https://atlas.torproject.org https://atlas.torproject.org , it appears 4 of 9 are in the US. There are also two in Germany, one in the Netherlands (as well as another there that is only for bridge relays), one in Austria, and one in Sweden.
[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8775009 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8775009
- cjbprime 12y agoBut taking out four nodes isn't enough to cause a full consensus outage.
- deciplex 12y agoWe still haven't discovered the thing that the US government can ask, that the Swedish government will refuse. So I think they'll be able to get five.
- Zigurd 12y agoIt could be an opportunistic attack on Tor by MPAA members. If the FBI surveyed all their IT people regarding attacks and they all complained about Tor, they might be able to stampede the FBI and cooperating LEAs into a takedown of directory servers.