4 ms·
Scientists use language and logic to translate monkey sounds into English
- officialjunk 12y agoI would like to see something like this for human babies
- winkywooster 12y agoDeb Roy's TED talk is kind of interesting on this subject. He captured the initial 3 years of son's language development and did analysis on it. http://www.ted.com/talks/deb_roy_the_birth_of_a_word http://www.ted.com/talks/deb_roy_the_birth_of_a_word
- ajcarpy2005 12y agoYes. I saw this when it was released and the data that was collected and compiled is quite high quality compared to most related research efforts. Science needs more research on human development and change over time. Even something as simple as a photo of a person per day. Actually computers should technically be able to unobtrusively measure our heart rate and breathing via the cameras in laptops with the algorithm that amplifies subtle changes in videos such as the redness color shift denoting heart rate and the rise/fall of the abdomen to indicate the breathing rate.
- canjobear 12y agoHere's a non-paywalled link to the paper, though I'm not positive that it is the final version: http://ling.auf.net/lingbuzz/001792 http://ling.auf.net/lingbuzz/001792 They give a game-theoretic formalization of their theory but I'm not sure that the formalization adds much beyond the summary in the article.
- shawnb576 12y agoI'd like to know if these sounds are learned, instinctual, or a mix of both. IOW, if you placed a monkey raised elsewhere into this environment would it know and/or adopt these sounds. Isn't assigning meaning to otherwise-arbitrary symbols/sounds a key aspect of language?
- codyb 12y agoFor humans, because of the diversity of sounds we can make, apparently the only thing approaching a universal word is "huh?" [0]. It'd be interesting to see how many sounds a monkey can make. If it's a very low number there'd probably be more universally used sounds but I'd imagine it's probably greater than most animals. I couldn't find a useful way to search for that. Unfortunately a lot of the results tended towards the "What sound does a monkey make" type of response and I'm not versed enough in linguistics or monkeys to query more efficiently. You can see on the map [1] that the Ivory Coast and Tiwai Island are more than close enough for the monkey's languages to have split off at a much earlier stage and evolved differently. I'd assume this is more likely the case. So I'm going to assume no, a monkey taken and raised elsewhere probably wouldn't instinctually jump into the trees upon hearing a "krak". But even the article states there are more experiments that need to be performed (although that particular experiment is a little insidious considering the intelligence of the animals you're kidnapping from (maybe if you saved one whose parents were incapacitated in some way)). Of course, you could just go to the zoo and yell "krak!" at some of the monkeys and see what happens! Might get you some weird stares! ;-) [0] - http://www.newstatesman.com/martha-gill/2013/11/what-one-word-thats-same-every-language http://www.newstatesman.com/martha-gill/2013/11/what-one-wor... [1] -https://www.google.com/maps/place/Tiwai+Island,+Sierra+Leone/@7.548611,-11.3475,7z/data=!4m2!3m1!1s0xf088754b8e50c79:0xdc371ce108f18a1f https://www.google.com/maps/place/Tiwai+Island,+Sierra+Leone...
- lukifer 12y agoI'm suddenly very curious about the universality of the similar "uh-huh".
- b6 12y agoWell, it seems strange to me. The article you link seems to suggest "huh" might be a universal word, but in the details, they show that it's pronounced differently all over the place. For example, it tends to be closer to "ah?" in Mandarin.
- drcomputer 12y agoI think that depends on what you call 'meaning'. Is meaning an intuitive, instinctive representation of something? What I mean is, for every word that exists, do those words trace back to a reality origin through a pattern of substitutions? Substitutions of symbol to reality are really just an associative relation. Substitutions between symbol to symbol are functionally operative the same way in which a substitution between reality and symbol works. So then my question is, is language really anything more than remembering that the cherry came from the tree? Once the cherry is disconnected from the tree, we have two things - cherry and tree. But before we distinguish them as parts, we recognize them as a whole. When I walk away from the tree, taking with me, the cherry - what happens if I still use the tree in my mind to represent the concept of fruit? It's a choice function. Does it matter whether I remember these things using sounds, symbols, images, experiences, or feelings? Language is interpreted and expressed across and using all of these domains. A poem carries greater meaning than the words do individually, and that is because there is emotional association that maps to the selection of words. We don't really call 'emotion' language, nor do we call 'art/music/math' language, yet these things arguably can have a strong influence across how we 'know' what language represents.
- jbuzbee 12y agoIt's already been done for dogs: http://languagelog.ldc.upenn.edu/myl/llog/FarsideDogTranslator.jpg http://languagelog.ldc.upenn.edu/myl/llog/FarsideDogTranslat...
- ChuckMcM 12y agoHow fun, I'm looking forward to using "Oh krak!" as an interjection. :-)
- tiglionabbit 12y agoSTEEEEEVE! Edit: What, you never saw "Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs"?
- sethammons 12y agoTypically, the community downvotes comments that don't add to the discussion.
- ionwake 12y agoI personally felt it added to the conversation. minus the edit.
- ternaryoperator 12y ago> ...some monkey dialects can be just as sophisticated as human language. These kinds of throw-away claims are a form of perennial nonsense. Nothing in the article suggests anything close to this being true. He looks at the shades of meaning of three sounds and yet asserts a similar sophistication to human speech. It's a regular meme in animal articles that this group (monkeys here, other times dolphins or whales) have language skills that rival humans. It's a kind of warm fuzzy feel-good claim asserted regularly despite supporting evidence.
- Houshalter 12y agoI don't think it's true but remember that decoding animal language is ridiculously hard. Our understanding of it is basically "play sound - see what animals say". And even that is nontrivial as the article points out. Relevant farside comic: http://i.imgur.com/QSR2AfI.gif http://i.imgur.com/QSR2AfI.gif
- Natsu 12y agoWhenever I see claims of animal language, I remember the Far Side cartoon where everything the dogs say translates to "hey!"
- EGreg 12y agoSounds to me like the Yo app is the equivalent of dogs barking. And look how many articles are written about its usefulness :))
- billybofh 12y agoOn another comic note : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3YKvtX8E-v8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3YKvtX8E-v8
- pvaldes 12y ago... and then I realize that the dolphins in the comic are repeating: "hey, do you speak spanish?" and "what's up?" in spanish to the humans... brilliant.
- yoha 12y agoFor those who do not know about Kanzi, I recommend the documentary “Kanzi: An Ape of Genius” (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QBlDGX95eys https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QBlDGX95eys).