5 ms·
I also seem to remember that, and I believe Musk attributed so much savings to it because there was very little right of way that needed to be worked out, he wa
by kbenson 12y ago
I also seem to remember that, and I believe Musk attributed so much savings to it because there was very little right of way that needed to be worked out, he was going to put it in the median of I-80. That reduces the theoretical cost quite a bit.
I think that's the goal of the company doing this, to test the feasibility of the design in more detail. It's also why I'm inclined to give them some weight in their assessment of the costs. But not too much. If I was an investor in some of this testing, I would want to go over their cost assessments with a fine toothed comb. It does seem this is one of the biggest unknowns in the proposal, and it's also one of the things that could change the most depending on where it's implemented, making it hard to make definite statements about.
- tptacek 12y agoIt's tough to seem to remember something about a source that is contradicted in the source itself. I think you should start by reading the link, and then opine on it.
- kbenson 12y agoNo, it's not tough to seem to remember anything, human memory is very fallible. That's why I prefaced the statement with that bit, because I was in no way sure. That said, my memory wasn't that bad. Here's what I was slightly misremembering from the proposal: By building it on pylons, you can almost entirely avoid the need to buy land by following alongside the mostly very straight California Interstate 5 highway, with only minor deviations when the highway makes a sharp turn. [1] So it's I-5, not i-80, and it's beside the highway, not in the median. I'm not sure how either of those mistakes affect the point I was trying to make to the degree it's not worth addressing, so I'm unsure why you used a rhetorical tactic instead of just correcting (since you obviously knew it was incorrect) and addressing that point, but that's your prerogative. 1: https://www.teslamotors.com/sites/default/files/blog_images/hyperloop-alpha.pdf https://www.teslamotors.com/sites/default/files/blog_images/...
- tptacek 12y agoYou're not addressing the source I provided; in effect, you're affirming the consequent in this argument.
- kbenson 12y agoWe are talking at cross points. My, and I believe others, issue with the source you posted is that after stating that the actual central-valley land is cheap, it ignores the rights-of-way costs, which is where many believe a lot of the cost savings really are. It's hard to be definitive with the sources I've seen so far, because while they are all happy to post numbers for costs, few seem willing to break those down into what the cost is for, and since we are talking about different types of structures, it's hard to say whether the comparisons apply well. As an example, your source states that the tube weight (for the larger plan) would be up to twice a train weight and thus would not cost less to build, and links to his own listing of train weights which are, as he states "To the best of my ability, I've tried to give dry weights, without passengers." That seems to imply that this is also without cargo. To my knowledge, most rail in the Western U.S. is built to handle cargo, and I imagine that's much heavier than commuter trains, and that could greatly affect building cost (to be clear the hyperloop could move cargo as well, but the relative dynamic weight of the cars to the static tube weight is much lower, yielding a smaller weight range). That leaves me without enough information to assess whether this is even a fair and valid comparison to make. There are other important factors as well, such as the weight of the hyperloop cars traveling through the tube that would need to be addressed if the tube weight was more favorable to train weight. What this comes down to is that with respect to building cost, your source leaves me less that assured that it has done more that a cursory review of the information and applied possibly inaccurate numbers and assumptions. There's just too many details that are left out to know. At the same time, the original hyperloop proposal was lean on specifics as well. I guess the difference is that I don't see this situation as painting either stance as "fantastical," there's just not enough concrete information presented for me to know either way. 1: http://pedestrianobservations.wordpress.com/2012/03/13/table-of-train-weights/ http://pedestrianobservations.wordpress.com/2012/03/13/table...
- 12y ago
- dragonwriter 12y ago> I also seem to remember that, and I believe Musk attributed so much savings to it because there was very little right of way that needed to be worked out, he was going to put it in the median of I-80. A casual glance at a map of where I-80 runs might suggest that that wasn't quite right.
- kbenson 12y agoThat's right, it was I-5. For some reason I often confuse them, even though it's obvious one is north/south and one is east/west. I'm on portions of I-80 about once a month, but I-5 generally no more than once a year.
- bdamm 12y agoYes, it was I-5 of course. Also it is easier to acquire rights to land when you don't divide the land but rather have pylons.