5 ms·
I think you also need the population density and a population that wants/needs to travel from A to B regularly to make it viable. Musk proposed LA->San Fran as
by grecy 12y ago
I think you also need the population density and a population that wants/needs to travel from A to B regularly to make it viable.
Musk proposed LA->San Fran as a commuter route - i.e. people would take it both ways 5 days a week.
How many people want/need to zip across the midwest both ways 5 days a week?
- rpedela 12y agoChicago to/from any city is great for freight and possibly commuters.
- fennecfoxen 12y agoBut the hyperloop isn't really targeted at freight, and would probably be a poor fit except for the most express of express freight. For general freight, Chicago already has plenty of railroad lines.
- nedwin 12y agoAlso commuters with the capacity to pay for expensive tickets - this thing isn't going to be cheap, at least not initially.
- ulfw 12y agoSo yea, he 'designed' it basically for himself (SpaceX in LA, Tesla in the Bay). Who else would do this commute daily (because it will certainly prohibitively expensive for just daily commuting)?
- goatforce5 12y agoPeople are using the Eurostar train to commute between France and London, apparently: http://www.ft.com/intl/cms/s/2/f26fe984-943a-11dc-9aaf-0000779fd2ac.html#axzz3MN53iXN6 http://www.ft.com/intl/cms/s/2/f26fe984-943a-11dc-9aaf-00007...
- ulfw 12y agoWell yea... "Also, the cost of Eurostar itself is not inconsiderable. There is a frequent traveller service that provides benefits, although not on price and there is no equivalent of a season ticket. Return tickets start at £59". Frankly I've rarely seen tickets under 150-200$. Doing this DAILY for a commute would add up, unless you're ridiculously wealthy (which I then suggest just getting a second home at your place of work for during the week).
- ChuckMcM 12y agoAnd while I could see that as a neat trick (I think Elon was going more for the comparison to the High Speed Rail boondoggle) it would be much more interesting if it could do something like Reno/SF or maybe Boise/SF so that folks could live in a nice place and work in a trendy place. But the whole notion of 'tasked' cities (living cities vs working cities) is still not well developed.
- HCIdivision17 12y agoThis is, perhaps, the most obvious Jetsons-suburb style future we can attain. It's so alluring and outlandish. I tend to work in plants, but I end up commuting just to stay away from the soul crushing industry. (Or soul-crushing industry, depending...) To be able to live in a nice garden village and then take a 40 minute ride out of state to my plant would be an utter joy.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- TrevorJ 12y agoThat's a chicken and the egg sort of question. We've developed pretty separate east and west coast economies and cultures since the travel times preclude much else. If they didn't I think we would see a lot of demand come from it that we don't see the need for yet.