Reply to EDIT: Your logical estimation was based on the wholesale elimination of several options, of which, I think "competent but wrong" has the largest possib

Reply to EDIT: Your logical estimation was based on the wholesale elimination of several options, of which, I think "competent but wrong" has the largest possibility. I don't think which I believe and why matters much here, but this is a "false choice" fallacy that seems to be based on personal opinion and doesn't accurately set up the question for others to answer. I think that should be called out.