3 ms·
> Because it's so, so easy to get trapped in a cycle of endless below-livable jobs just to support yourself. That's an appeal to emotions and has nothing to do
by protomyth 12y ago
> Because it's so, so easy to get trapped in a cycle of endless below-livable jobs just to support yourself.
That's an appeal to emotions and has nothing to do with the argument.
> My personal belief, and I'm more than willing to pay more for goods and services to support it, and I live in a country where we have a liveable minimal wage, is that every job if worked 40 hours should be enough for a very modest, but not totally hopeless life. You also then have time off to use to improve yourself via school or some other way.
You are more than willing to pay more, but the very people you talk about who need cheap goods and services to stretch a budget don't have that extra money. The forcing of every job to be "living wages" removes a part of the labor force that is willing and able (due to parents or other income) to provide services for less money. Removing part-time, dependent labor from the the market increases the costs of goods and services for everyone and screws poor people. You might feel better, but it has a detrimental effect.
> If you're working back-to-back jobs 80 hours a week that pay nothing you have zero time for yourself, zero time for good planning and zero time to attend any kind of classes.
This is a different issue. This is the disappearance of full-time, low skill jobs. There are many factors including changing laws that have impacted this area. Our current bad economy and companies preparing for changes in health care laws are two. Worsening the situation by raising the minimum wage is only going to get more people fired / hours reduced or speed automation (McDonald's self ordering machines).
Doing something to help people get an education or training is one thing, eliminating a whole class of workers that make goods and services cheaper is a problem.
I remember the paper, and remember a negative reaction, but do not have time to read and find my sources on it again.
- Already__Taken 12y agoHow is your fist point an appeal to emotions there's nothing evocative at all. If you have multiple below living wage jobs you've still a fixed amount of time in the day you can work just now you're being paid less for when you do work AND have higher transportation costs by definition. Maybe job security is an advantage as you won't get fired from everything all at once. You keep repeating how the suggestions will make things more expensive for poor people. We're suggesting to pay poor people to not be poor.
- protomyth 12y agoYour suggestions mean that people will have more money but less purchasing power. They will still be poor, and a part of the workforce that has existed from the beginning will be gone. That part of the workforce has an effect on keeping goods and services at a lower price. Raising the cost of labor and getting rid of those "I just need some spending money jobs" results in companies looking to replace the higher cost workers or raise prices. Neither of these things benefit poor people. "We're suggesting to pay poor people to not be poor." I'm suggesting that the best bet for poor people is to provide a path to training that allows them to have jobs that are higher value to employers. Making low value jobs cost more doesn't help. It hurts as these people don't have high value skills and you are removing spending money from others that could be in the workforce.
- TheSpiceIsLife 12y ago> The forcing of every job to be "living wages" removes a part of the labor force that is willing and able (due to parents or other income) to provide services for less money. This, and I think every one of your points, can be sufficiently addressed with one word: Australia. My 19 year old unskilled housemate gets paid minimum wage $21.08 per hour as a casual.[1] She works 4 days a week and supports herself just fine. They say the cost of living is high in Australia, and it is -everything is expensive here- but we have options: we live in a share house and pay $100 a week per room (four of us) including electricity and Internet. She doesn't own a car, and doesn't smoke cigarettes or drink alcohol. Financially she isn't struggling at all. The minimum wage for full time employment is $16.87 per hour, which includes 10 day a year sick leave and 20 days a hear paid leave.[1] Also, because everyone here is paid a 'living wage' we're able to afford to pay social welfare. 'Newstart Allowance' is paid to unemployed job-seekers at $515.60 per fortnight.[2] It isn't a lot, below the poverty line apparently, but it is enough to rent a room buy food. I do not think any of your arguments hold water. 1. http://www.fairwork.gov.au/about-us/policies-and-guides/fact-sheets/minimum-workplace-entitlements/minimum-wages http://www.fairwork.gov.au/about-us/policies-and-guides/fact... 2. http://www.humanservices.gov.au/customer/enablers/centrelink/newstart-allowance/payment-rates-for-newstart-allowance http://www.humanservices.gov.au/customer/enablers/centrelink...
- protomyth 12y agoThis, and I think every one of your points, can be sufficiently addressed with one word: Australia. Youth unemployment (both 15-19 and 15-24) is trending higher[0][1] but the government doesn't seem to think that's a crisis[2] and it has gotten worse since that statement[0][1]. My 19 year old unskilled housemate gets paid minimum wage $21.08 per hour as a casual.[1] She works 4 days a week and supports herself just fine. They say the cost of living is high in Australia, and it is -everything is expensive here- but we have options: we live in a share house and pay $100 a week per room (four of us) including electricity and Internet. She doesn't own a car, and doesn't smoke cigarettes or drink alcohol. Financially she isn't struggling at all. The minimum wage for full time employment is $16.87 per hour, which includes 10 day a year sick leave and 20 days a hear paid leave.[1] Point 1, I said it increases the cost of living which you confirm. I'm not sure a frugal person with 3 roommates making 25% above the minimum is a good example. Also, because everyone here is paid a 'living wage' we're able to afford to pay social welfare. Since it looks like Australia is running a A$48.5 billion budget deficit[3], it looks like you really cannot afford it. In fact, the range of changes look like you are going to reduce social welfare to cover the budget. For students, it seems the cost of university education (the main path in turning an unskilled person to a skilled person) is going to have a jump[4]. This is looking much worse for youth since the need to become skilled labor is going to hit a bit of a wall if the university education costs jump per one of the governments proposals. 'Newstart Allowance' is paid to unemployed job-seekers at $515.60 per fortnight.[2] It isn't a lot, below the poverty line apparently, but it is enough to rent a room buy food. I do not think any of your arguments hold water. We have unemployeement payments in the US, so I'm not seeing its relation to minimum wage. I am don't believe Australia proves high minimum wage is a good thing. The argument is high minimum wage cuts youth and unskilled employment and removes a class of worker from the workforce. Looking at [0][1], I think the trends show just that. 0) http://www.ausstats.abs.gov.au/ausstats/meisubs.nsf/0/333D19DB6FA8BABFCA257DAA000C941F/$File/62020_nov%202014.pdf http://www.ausstats.abs.gov.au/ausstats/meisubs.nsf/0/333D19... 0b) small side note: I do wonder why the change to this reporting is occurring according to 1) http://www.aph.gov.au/About_Parliament/Parliamentary_Departments/Parliamentary_Library/pubs/rp/rp1314/QG/YthUnemployment http://www.aph.gov.au/About_Parliament/Parliamentary_Departm... 2) http://www.smh.com.au/federal-politics/political-news/christopher-pyne-denies-12-per-cent-youth-unemployment-is-a-crisis-20140929-10nsm2.html http://www.smh.com.au/federal-politics/political-news/christ... 3) http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2014-12-09/abbott-removes-policy-barnacles-in-bid-to-boost-appeal.html http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2014-12-09/abbott-removes-poli... 4) http://www.brisbanetimes.com.au/national/tertiary-education/university-fees-the-known-unknowns-20141217-124vqd.html http://www.brisbanetimes.com.au/national/tertiary-education/...