4 ms·
Meditation associated with preserved telomere length in breast cancer patients
- ajarmst 12y agoA more accurate headline might be that meditation appears to ameliorate genetic damage associated with stress. But I guess that's less surprising, exciting and clickable than implying that meditation causes Lamarckian inheritance.
- codyb 12y agoLife is all about that Lamarckian inheritance buddy boy!
- xxxyy 12y agoYes, and it is worth noting that telomeres, while technically being DNA, do not code any proteins. In fact their complexity is at a completely trivial level - just a repeated sequence of "TTAGGG". This is also the part of DNA that does not get sequenced with the rest of one's code. There is a lot of speculation on what else can extend telomeres [1]. So yes, a clickbait. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Telomere#Lengthening http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Telomere#Lengthening
- dang 12y agoWe edited the title in an attempt to make it more accurate and neutral. If anyone suggests a better one, we can change it again.
- geekam 12y agoCan people who meditate point to good resources on how and where to start? Books, videos, blogs etc.
- thatswrong0 12y agoMindfulness in Plain English (http://www.urbandharma.org/udharma4/mpe.html http://www.urbandharma.org/udharma4/mpe.html)
- dwc 12y agoGreat recommendation. It's an older edition of a print book (still in print for decades) that's online for free with permission. It's well done, clear, and has very little woo in it.
- purerandomness 12y agoUCLA Mindfulness Awareness Research Center: http://marc.ucla.edu/body.cfm?id=22 http://marc.ucla.edu/body.cfm?id=22 Jon Kabat-Zinn doing a session at Google: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3nwwKbM_vJc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3nwwKbM_vJc And, of course, Headspace: https://www.headspace.com/ https://www.headspace.com/ Just sit back, relax, and enjoy one of those. And then all of them.
- geekam 12y agoIs it worth paying headspace 8 bucks a month?
- fnordsensei 12y agoMeditation is a lot less complicated than sometimes advertised. It can be helpful to know that alternative terms for the same activity is "contemplation" or "deep thought". It's a skill though, and you'll get better at it over time. Set a timer for five minutes, sit down in a comfortable position (usually better than lying down, to keep yourself awake). Count your breaths until 10 and then count backwards down again. Repeat until the timer goes off, and bam! Meditation accomplished. Don't worry if your mind drifts off, that's not a sign of failure. Just keep doing the task at hand (counting). Use headphones if you need to block out sound. Slow music without lyrics or plain nature sounds usually work better. Once you have that down, there are about a billion variations and ways to continue, but starting out doesn't have to be more complicated than outlined above. Usually we wish to measure progress when undertaking any kind of endeavor, especially new ones, but measuring (or even defining) progress when it comes to meditation can be hard sometimes. It may require discipline on your part in order to overcome the perceived lack of feedback, but I assure you that you'll be very glad that you kept at it once you do start to notice what happens.
- Scarbutt 12y agobut I assure you that you'll be very glad that you kept at it once you do start to notice what happens. Can you expand a little on this? What does one starts noticing?
- fnordsensei 12y agoI'd be disinclined to describe what you'd notice as that might lead to you looking for those milestones in particular. Everyone is probably wired a little bit differently and may end up noticing different things. If one were given to drama, one could say that part of the practice is to sort of walk out into the wilderness and purposefully NOT bring a map, making exploration a part of the game. To give you an example (with the disclaimer above in mind), I've a friend who noticed that he doesn't need as much sleep when he meditates regularly. Stop meditating, need for sleep increases. That's not the case for me, I need about the same amount of sleep regardless of amount of meditation. If I'd been told that less sleep is achievable, I might have been discouraged by the fact that this particular perk is nowhere to be seen for me. But I happen to know not to use another person's map for my personal wilderness. For me, focus, patience, attention, memory and a very even (almost immutable, lately) temper are some of the things that have come out of this.
- powerset 12y agoreddit.com/r/meditation is pretty decent
- glaugh 12y agoI've tried quite a few things and the most useful thing for me has been https://www.headspace.com/ https://www.headspace.com/ . It's "daily" guided meditation (that after not too long is barely guided). The narrator's voice is really good, not too hippie, very calming. Everything is pleasant and well-designed. This was also pretty good, if you'd rather read a book: http://www.amazon.com/Search-Inside-Yourself-Unexpected-Achieving/dp/0062116932 http://www.amazon.com/Search-Inside-Yourself-Unexpected-Achi...
- geekam 12y agoEdit: Do you pay for headspace or just use their 10 minute? I just signed up. Thanks for the book suggestion, I just bought this book.
- subdane 12y agoHere's a nice five minute example https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yMz_UagXkFk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yMz_UagXkFk
- MarkL4 12y agohttp://meditationstuff.wordpress.com/ http://meditationstuff.wordpress.com/
- ramblerman 12y agoheadspace is a tremendous app with a new guided meditation everyday. It slowly lets you build up your practice, as well as choose a specific branch of focus as you progress. The ptich sounds gimmicky, but I never managed more than 5 consecutive days on my own. With Andy (the narrator) I'm at 30 days and counting
- anentropic 12y agoIt could also have been the yoga "The first group was randomly assigned to an 8-week cancer recovery program consisting of mindfulness meditation and yoga" this is a crummy article with a crummy headline about one single study which may or may not also be crummy
- waps 12y agoMaybe it's as simple as this : Start a new research. Work with 1-sigma significance (~2% error rate allowed). Then investigate the favorite brand of soup of the brothers of cured cancer patients. Make sure to research about 50 brands. Huge news ! If you get your brother to eat soup brand 23 you have a significantly higher chance to survive cancer ! Huge article in every newspaper. What happened here ? 2% error rate.
- mrbonner 12y agoExercise can also change your DNA: http://well.blogs.nytimes.com/2014/12/17/how-exercise-changes-our-dna/ http://well.blogs.nytimes.com/2014/12/17/how-exercise-change... Exposure to radiation can change your DNA. Heck, everything can change (read mutate) your DNA.
- xxxyy 12y agoThe title of the article you provided is completely incorrect. There is no change to DNA detected by these studies. What gets changes is the expression level of individual genes. Expression level can be changed by almost everything, as it is exactly the fine art of turning ACTG sequence into living organisms.
- cordite 12y agoOr.. Just set up a context such that genes become disabled, enabled, or in combination, yield different behaviors due to the presence (or lack) of signaling structures. It's not like you suddenly evolve or jam a syringe of one minute retrovirus in your neck.
- steven2012 12y agoTelomeres are not the same as DNA.
- tokenadult 12y agoI see after a Google search that it has been mostly popular press outlets without experienced medical reporters who have commented on this story so far. For the most part, what we are seeing online are recycled editions of the study group's press release. The underlying journal publication "Mindfulness-based cancer recovery and supportive-expressive therapy maintain telomere length relative to controls in distressed breast cancer survivors" is open-access,[1] so medically knowledgeable people here can read the study and check whether its methodology makes sense. I note that the lead author of the study, Linda E. Carlson, is part of a group of cancer researchers promoting "integrative" approaches to cancer treatment. Another cancer researcher commenting on this approach thinks that "integrative" cancer therapy so far promises much more than it can actually deliver in improved patient outcomes.[2] The original headline of the Fast Company article submitted here, already changed by the Hacker News moderation team, is surely wrong, and it's not at all clear that this extraordinary claim will replicate if an independent group of researchers attempt to replicate the results. If I or any of my loved ones should happen to have a case of cancer (which is rather rare in my family), I will ask for advice on how to treat it from a doctor who practices science-based medicine. [1] http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/cncr.29063/full http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/cncr.29063/full [2] http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/selling-integrative-oncology-as-a-monograph-in-jnci/ http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/selling-integrative-onco...
- reader5000 12y agoYour argument appears to be that the word "integrative" implies non-science based medicine/research. Is there any reason to believe the journal Cancer is in some way lacking in scientific standards? I have no idea. But assuming it is a well-respected publication the results appearing in it require more evidence to dismiss other than a paper author does "integrative" research.
- tokenadult 12y agoOne of my problems with this study (and many preliminary medical intervention studies hyped mostly by press releases) is that it deals with a biomarker--telomere length--rather than with a hard endpoint, for example actual improved cancer survival and reduced all-cause mortality in the patients. Anyone looking on can read the paper for themselves for issues like sample size, the reported statistics, whether the expected finding was specified in advance, and so on. A recent submission to HN[1] cautions that press releases are not usually good guides to what a study has actually found. [1] http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/communicating-health-science-news/ http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/communicating-health-sci...