6 ms·
There's a difference between thinking you can tell the difference or convincing others that you can tell the difference, and actually being able to tell the dif
by pmoriarty 12y ago
There's a difference between thinking you can tell the difference or convincing others that you can tell the difference, and actually being able to tell the difference.
Nowhere is this difference more strikingly demonstrated than in the studies that have been done on wine tasting.[1]
An example from the article:
Hodgson isn't alone in questioning the science of
wine-tasting. French academic Frédéric Brochet tested the effect of
labels in 2001. He presented the same Bordeaux superior wine to 57
volunteers a week apart and in two different bottles – one for a
table wine, the other for a grand cru.
The tasters were fooled.
When tasting a supposedly superior wine, their language was more
positive – describing it as complex, balanced, long and woody. When
the same wine was presented as plonk, the critics were more likely
to use negatives such as weak, light and flat.
[1] - http://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2013/jun/23/wine-tasting-junk-science-analysis http://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2013/jun/23/wine-tas...
- cryptophreak 12y agoI have no knowledge of or interest in the methodology of this particular study, but I can tell you my own experience: I can, under double-blind conditions, be given four different ages of The Macallan whiskey and correctly identify the year by taste.
- waterlesscloud 12y agoI keep seeing this kind of thing, but it goes directly against my personal observations. I've seen people blindly identify any number of wines, down to the exact vintage at times. There are people who can do this, I've seen it done.
- msandford 12y agoThat is literally what you have to do in order to be a sommelier. That's the whole test! If you can't do it, you don't pass. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sommelier http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sommelier http://www.imdb.com/title/tt2204371/ http://www.imdb.com/title/tt2204371/
- cbd1984 12y agoExcept when wine tasters can't distinguish between red wine and white wine with food coloring: http://scienceblogs.com/cortex/2007/11/02/the-subjectivity-of-wine/ http://scienceblogs.com/cortex/2007/11/02/the-subjectivity-o... http://www.newyorker.com/tech/frontal-cortex/does-all-wine-taste-the-same http://www.newyorker.com/tech/frontal-cortex/does-all-wine-t...
- personZ 12y agoExcept when wine tasters can't distinguish between red wine and white wine with food coloring This oft referenced study took oenology students and asked them to use adjectives to describe the odors of the wine. The only wines tested were white...and white with food coloring. It is unfortunate that red wine wasn't actually tested, as it would provide an interesting contrast, nor was taste actually tested at all. So as is all that you can go on is that given what appears to be a red wine, students who presumably have motives other than being entirely straightforward use red wine-type terminology. It is an interesting study, but is not quite the trump card that so many think it is. Further, it's a little silly how people are taking products with minor taste differences (most beers, wines, ryes, etc, are made with almost identical processes, yielding close to identical results), and then presuming to claim that the same applies to things that are dramatically different. That someone couldn't tell the expensive wine from the table wine does not prove that someone can't tell a beef burger from a veggie burger.
- cbd1984 12y ago> That someone couldn't tell the expensive wine from the table wine does not prove that someone can't tell a beef burger from a veggie burger. Well, yes. That's true. Don't confuse my contribution to the topic drift for a rejection of that point.
- msandford 12y agoI think you need to read up on what a sommelier is and what the exam is like. People pass it, and the pass rate is such that it's not due to random chance. I realize that you have a study that's vaguely related but the two are not the same. Not at all. What are the credentials of the people on the "wine tasting panel"? I can't find that information anywhere.
- Ntrails 12y agoExcellent, we can see that subtler differences are harder to identify, and that we can have subjective applications to flavour because humans are biased to like things in proportion to how they expect to. But I'd put money that every experienced taster was able to deduce in blind tasting the bordeaux from the (insert other wine type??). Indeed as I understand it from watching Frasier there are clubs which do these blind tastings all the time. In other words. I may tell you this bordeaux is cheap and acidic, but at no point was I mistaking it for a bottle of Rose.
- pmoriarty 12y agoWere these tests blind or double-blind?
- Ntrails 12y agoFrasier is a television show, I was trying to draw out the story. I know literally nothing about wine having had maybe 6 sips in my lifetime. A similar argument can be made about confusing two types of potato vs a potato and a parsnip. Yes pleasure is subjective, and taste is to some extent. In general there are limits to this effect. Yes, I could effectively overcook the taste out of both things, mush them into a texture-less paste, and then stuff them full of enough herbs and spices to mask any semblance of their original flavour. At that point perhaps I've won - but then I'm not sure it meets the claim.
- lisper 12y agoActually, there have been studies where they put red food coloring in white wine and given it to self-styled experts who could not tell that what they were drinking was not red wine.
- gfunk911 12y agoI hate this example. It's not blind, it's deceptive. It's funny, but it proves nothing. I agree with the general inability of wine tasters to discern nearly as much as they believe, just not this particular example.
- lgas 12y agoThere's a huge difference between telling two wines apart and telling a meat patty and a veggie patty apart. The later is more like being able to tell wine and root beer apart.
- electrum 12y agoThe wines were the same: "He presented the same Bordeaux superior wine"
- zyxley 12y agoI don't know anything about wine, but I can definitely tell the difference between, say, chicken, turkey, beef, and alligator if you made them into sausages. I'd be seriously surprised if I couldn't tell insect apart from any of those.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- jpindar 12y agoMythbusters did a segment testing the claim that many different meats taste like chicken. http://www.discovery.com/tv-shows/mythbusters/videos/tastes-like-chicken/ http://www.discovery.com/tv-shows/mythbusters/videos/tastes-...