14 ms·
> it's an astronomical 24% That's lower than the income tax rate for a middle class American. Why is this rate astronomical? Are there also high property and i
by humanrebar 12y ago
> it's an astronomical 24%
That's lower than the income tax rate for a middle class American. Why is this rate astronomical? Are there also high property and income taxes?
EDIT: It's an honest question. I know what a VAT is, but I have no frame of reference for how the overall tax scheme is especially egregious for the individual taxpayer. Some other tax rates (income, property, etc.) are surely relevant. A 24% VAT with absolutely no other taxes sounds nice, for example.
- goodJobWalrus 12y agobecause it's much bigger than sales tax in any of the us states?
- pja 12y agoThat will be in addition to income and property taxes. By way of example, UK taxes look like: * ~40% income tax, first £10k untaxed. * 20% VAT on most goods (food, books, children's clothes are untaxed, heating fuel is taxed at 5%) * Annual property tax of around £1000 on the typical dwelling. * 28% capital gains tax, first £10k untaxed in any 1 year. Dividends are effectively taxed as additional income. In reality UK taxes are of course much, much more complicated than the rough outline above :)
- arethuza 12y agoWorth noting that if you sell shares in your own company (e.g. your start-up is acquired) you probably won't pay 28% CGT as you will qualify for some kind of tax relief - I paid 10% CGT on the sale of our company ~12 years ago because of Taper Relief, this has apparently been replaced by Entrepreneurs' Relief: https://www.gov.uk/entrepreneurs-relief/eligibility https://www.gov.uk/entrepreneurs-relief/eligibility
- TimSAstro 12y agoMinor correction on income tax: 0-10K: Untaxed, 10-40K: 20%, 40K+: 40%,
- pja 12y agoNo, because I'm including National Insurance (both employers and employees) under income taxes. Employers NI is 14% of headline salary, so the effective tax rate for high earners is more like 50% than 40%. Meanwhile middle income people pay 12% NI on top of their income tax and 14% employers national insurance so the real rate of tax on the cost to their employer is about 40%. Go do the sums & you'll see. Like I said, the reality is much more complicated, but the figures I gave are roughly in the right ballpark.
- dghf 12y ago> food, books, children's clothes are untaxed Some food is untaxed. For example, cakes are untaxed but biscuits are taxed (or maybe it's the other way round). There was a court case to decide whether Jaffa Cakes were cakes or biscuits for the purposes of VAT: the court ultimately applied the principle that cakes were soft when fresh but hard when stale, while biscuits started off hard and then went soft; hence Jaffa Cakes were officially cakes.
- humanrebar 12y agoThis is exactly why the tax should be flat and other programs should counteract regressive effects. Well, it's one of the reasons.
- smackfu 12y agoSo Finland is one country that has 24% VAT (most are lower.) They have very low property taxes but very high income taxes (up to 30% federal + 20% local.)
- Sharlin 12y agoYou can't compare VAT to income tax, they are very different beasts. And yes, although I can't speak for the GP, in Finland (and other Nordic countries) other taxes are high as well. Not that I'm necessarily complaining, although VAT as a concept certainly has its problems.
- humanrebar 12y agoFor the purposes of comparing the effects on the individual taxpayers, it seems fair to me. Structural differences aside, a 24% VAT sounds great if there are no other taxes and there is some deduction or subsidy to counteract its regressive effects.
- moonchrome 12y ago>Are there also high property and income taxes? Yes - this is on top of (high) income tax/capital gains tax, etc.
- humanrebar 12y agoGood to know. Since I don't know what country you're talking about, can you give me some percentages to help me understand better?
- nagrom 12y agoYou're comparing income tax with sales tax. In the UK, on a salary of £40k (i.e. professional mid-career engineer), before you touch the money, the government takes about 25% for income tax and national insurance. Then, they take 20% of everything else that you spend unless it's non-luxurious foodstuffs, children's clothes or paper books. And, of course, if what you're buying is fuel, they actually take 85% of the price. In addition, you'll pay approximately 2% of the purchase price of a house to the government, and you'll pay approx. one day a month in after-tax income to the local council as a property tax. US has a 30% tax burden, UK has a 40% tax burden. France and Germany have >50% tax burdens. The last three have some form of nationalised healthcare though, which the US does not.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- tartuffe78 12y agoThe US does have medicare and medicaid, which aren't universal but still are nationalized healthcare for a lot of people.
- maaku 12y agoNationalized health insurance, which is a little different.
- icebraining 12y agoIsn't that the case in Germany as well?
- biafra 12y agoHealth insurance is not payed with collected taxes in Germany. You are paying for it seperately.
- acveilleux 12y agoI live in Quebec and technically I don't have nationalized healthcare but rather health insurance. It doesn't change the fact that I don have to pay anything out of pocket at any hospital I go to here. An itemized and detailed claim will be made on my behalf to the insurance agency to get everything paid. From a user pov it makes no difference how the system works.
- TheCoelacanth 12y agoVAT is essentially a sales tax. Sales taxes in the US are usually 5-10%.
- aragot 12y agoVAT varies from 10% to 25% in most countries of the world [1]. There is an income tax in _addition_ to it. I've calculated a total of net income/turnover rate as low as 34% in my country (France), albeit including all mandatory spending and not only taxes, and the detail is in my blog post [2]. [1] http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Value-added_tax http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Value-added_tax [2] http://adrien-ragot.me/why-i-say-70-percent-tax-in-france/ http://adrien-ragot.me/why-i-say-70-percent-tax-in-france/
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- Kiro 12y ago> Are there also high property and income taxes? Isn't that usually the case? High VAT, high income taxes.
- Nitramp 12y agoThat's the VAT tax, comparable to the sales tax in the US, so this compares as 24% vs ~6% or so in most of the US. Income tax is separate from that, and depends on country to, but seems to work out to quite similar percentages, at least between Germany and the US.
- dllthomas 12y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Value-added_tax#Comparison_with_sales_tax http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Value-added_tax#Comparison_with... VAT taxes sale, but it's not the same as a "sales tax". The rates don't mean the same thing, and it doesn't make sense to compare them directly without taking that into consideration.
- mcguire 12y ago"[24% is] lower than the income tax rate for a middle class American." Do you have a source for that? (I ask because I'm definitely upper middle class or possibly lower upper class and I'm only paying ~25% (and I'm in no way tax efficient). Everything I've seen puts the middle class income tax rate below 15%.)
- pc86 12y agoNot the person you're replying to, but maybe these numbers will help: - The median household income for 2013 was just under $52,000 [1] - For that same year, the marginal tax rate for a single person making that income was 25% [2] - If the household is married that drops to 15%. Most Americans on HN are very likely upper-middle class in income, since that generally means $62,500+ in personal income and a six-figure household income [3] I think these income stats are incredibly interesting. I never would have considered my wife and I to be upper-middle class either in wealth or income, but according to every set of figures I can find we're pretty solidly in the top 5-8% range nationally. It can be misleading what "middle," "upper middle," and "upper" really mean if you're strictly speaking about gross income. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Household_income_in_the_United_States#After_2010 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Household_income_in_the_United... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Income_tax_in_the_United_States#Marginal_tax_rates_for_2013 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Income_tax_in_the_United_State... [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Upper_middle_class#Income https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Upper_middle_class#Income
- humanrebar 12y agoThere's a ~15% payroll tax (income tax by another name) for social security and medicare. The bulk of the median household's remaining income will be taxed at 15%. There's some fudging for deductions, I suppose, but that's also leaving out state and local income taxes. The point was that a 24% VAT doesn't mean much to me when other major taxes are left unmentioned. It actually sounds like a great deal if income and property taxes are only nominal. EDIT: You're likely neglecting to include both halves of your payroll taxes.
- pietro 12y agoAll taxes are astronomical in most of the EU, but with national differences. In Denmark, in addition to a 25% VAT, there's an 8% payroll tax and a 40%-56% income tax, property taxes, huge environmental taxes, etc.