3 ms·
The article is filled with loaded terms but misses the consequence that is very important. The end effect is wealth transfer from the wealthy to the poor. Let
by dnautics 12y ago
The article is filled with loaded terms but misses the consequence that is very important. The end effect is wealth transfer from the wealthy to the poor.
Let's rephrase the thesis in this way, based on my personal experience. My secret of ridesharing is that I was once part of an exploitative, hierarchical, socialist organization (academic science) that kept me in a cycle of poverty[0] intended to depress my wages, limiting my growth opportunities and discouraging out-of-the-box thinking.
I then quit my job, and began working for 'ridesharing'. First, lyft, then uber - and gave myself an immediate runway to launch a nonprofit science organization to cure cancer. Not only did it afford me the independence to pursue this, but I also gave myself a pay raise and began investments. Then, I moved from San Diego (which has an economic climate that makes ridesharing difficult in the 'equilibrium' condition, which had been reached) to San Francisco (where drivers are in high demand and low supply) and gave myself even more of a pay raise (almost 2x) affording me even more of a safety net and more free time to work on the science.
Hell, I even have investments.
[0] spam the populace by telling them they ought to get degrees in STEM, create an oversupply of PhDs, which lets you pay them 30k to work 80 hours in a lab, and then restrict their ability to be promoted to professor so they're constantly struggling.
- bravo22 12y agoI think what the article is also saying is that you need an imbalance for this new "model" to work. I agree that there is a slight net effect of wealth transfer but if the gap was smaller to begin with then there would be no need for the wealth transfer.
- dnautics 12y agoI'm not disputing that either. On the other hand, it's not only the rich that use Uber (and certainly not Lyft), so the OP's argument is a bit hyperbolic. There is this very interesting effect that DUIs have a disproportionately negative consequence the poorer you are; and the price point for both services is low enough that it makes using those services very attractive for people outside the top income bracket.
- abandonliberty 12y agomoney transfer <> wealth transfer. You've made some good moves by going where the market values your skills. The system that enables efficient/cheap access to your labor is facilitating, but not causing your increase in wealth. In many other locations, it would not.
- foobarqux 12y agoCan you share what one would expect to make per hour, net of expenses and depreciation?
- dnautics 12y agoIn san francisco i've been making $40/hr gross (but I expect it to average out to $30-35. My n=3 days, which are all in december and have been amazing because it's rainy), with a cost per hour of about $5-10 and that is an overestimate. Expenses here are very low. I don't count depreciation because my car had 90k miles on it to start (but it's not a clunker! I've maintained it very well).