3 ms·
What else does one do with history, besides just experiencing it like one does a good story? I didn't understand that when history seemed boring. After all, i
by ddingus 12y ago
What else does one do with history, besides just experiencing it like one does a good story?
I didn't understand that when history seemed boring. After all, it had already happened. The excitement is in what could happen.
Once a person actually does start exploring history of any kind, they reach a point where mere experience isn't enough, and as they get there, they realize the value of history is in the data associated with that history.
Another analytical thinker is born.
This isn't limited to college students. Anybody actually interested in a better understanding can and should be looking at history as a means to that end.
And it can be as simple as actually paying attention to life experiences at a minimum.
- agumonkey 12y agoThe scarcity of data makes history very subtle and interesting. Something we rarely get in schools since we're fed facts and dates (and only partial reasons). When you learn how an historian finally discover by cross referencing antique texts, remains of artwork, geology, etc, it's hard not to be thrilled.
- gyardley 12y agoIt's not the scarcity of the data that makes history subtle or interesting - after all, most periods and areas of study have a surfeit of data. Even when I was studying 17th century Russia, there were more primary source documents in the (terribly, horribly catalogued and organized) archives than I could possibly read in a lifetime. The truly subtle bits come from the need to thoroughly understand the Sitz im Leben - as best you can, the surrounding context in which the source was produced and the purpose for which the source was produced. Without that, you just end up with anachronistic presentism. In my opinion, the need to place oneself as deeply as possible in a completely foreign period and mindset before the interpretation of a new source can even begin is what makes historians excellent analytical thinkers - as well as extremely useful product managers and marketers.
- agumonkey 12y agoWell, the surrounding context is also part of the data, even though I understand that it's easy to forget embedding yourself in it to interpret the data already at hand.
- ddingus 12y agoYes. I've always framed this as a kind of simulation. When we can actualize things in our minds, we then can also process them in ways not possible in a basic sense.