4 ms·
Due to my background as both an American and (chemical) engineer, I am fluent in metric, American, and domain specific unit systems used in chemical engineering
by jandrewrogers 12y ago
Due to my background as both an American and (chemical) engineer, I am fluent in metric, American, and domain specific unit systems used in chemical engineering that are neither American nor metric. I can switch between these as necessary quite fluidly; it is an elementary skill as a chemical engineer.
I would argue that being limited to a single unit system is like being limited to a single language. In principle, no one needs more than one but in practice the differences in expressiveness for different purposes are interesting and useful. These differences in expressiveness are connected to the continued existence of different systems.
America is big enough and is sufficiently independent of trade in its economy (most of its stupendous production is also internally consumed) that the cost of not transitioning to metric is marginal. I understand why metric is a good system but simultaneously understand why the benefit of metric is dubious for the average American. Remember, American units are defined in terms of metric units; it is a preference, an American can precisely convert to metric at any time if they deem it useful. But they don't because it serves little purpose.
Basically, like their language, Americans occupy a big enough economic sphere that they get to define their standards. An enormous number of global standards are American in origin as it is. I don't sweat the lack of metric even though I use it routinely. Once you become familiar with enough unit and arithmetic systems, you quickly learn that they all suck in some context.
It is pointless to turn these things into religions.
- D_Alex 12y ago>I would argue that being limited to a single unit system is like being limited to a single language. In principle, no one needs more than one but in practice the differences in expressiveness for different purposes are interesting and useful. After considerable reflection, I have come to the view that in fact the differences are not interesing and not useful. What is useful though is consistency and ease of application (which the metric system has) and familiarity (which just depends on the circumstances). I work in the oil and gas industry, and I had to learn to think in terms of bizarre units like stcf/bbl, or pounds per gallon. In the end, the only driver was that once you digest enough information, you can compare things on a like-for-like basis... if you know the horsepower ratings of 10 car models, it is more immediately useful to be given the horsepower of the car you consider buying rather than its power output in kW. But in the end I see no downsides, only upsides, if the entire industry switched to the metric system. stcf/bbl (standard cubic feet per barrel) by the way is a customary measure of the amount of gas dissolved in the oil. After 25 years in the industry, I know for example that 1000 stcf/bbl represents a gassy oil that will take some effort to stabilise, and 100 stcf/bbl is a relatively dead crude... so inormation about new crudes is useful to me in this form. But - what a weird unit it is! The information could much better be provided as a dimensionless ratio, eg gas-to-oil ratio of 200 for gassy oil would be intuitive and better suited to use in further calculations, and once you've seen enough data expressed in this way, the familiarity issue is taken care of. I invite you to provide counterexamples, where the customary unit has an inherent advantage (familiarity does not count). I can't think of any.
- Mikhail_Edoshin 12y agoCooking units are much better suited for the task than metric units. Typographic units are non-metric and metric units are inconvenient in typography, because millimeters are too big for character sizes and too small for page units and centimeters are both too big and too small at the same time. French (?) shoe sizes are numbered like 38, 39, 40, 41, etc. and the difference between these sizes are 2/3 cm, because it's a practical difference to mass-produce different shoe sizes. It's not metric, obviously. Parsecs are not metric. Heck, light years are not metric; and look at how rich the unit is, it tells you a lot about the distance. Try to express the distance to Alpha Centauri in metric units and comprehend it.
- davty 12y ago1 light year = 9.4605284 × 10^15 meters
- knodi123 12y agoheh, the numeric part is pretty much 3*Pi.
- Mikhail_Edoshin 12y agoCan you actually name this number without looking in a dictionary? I cannot. Nine and a half zillions, I guess. So Alpha Centauri is like 44 zillion meters away; very enlightening.
- Tomte 12y agoYou can always invent a name (and "light year" is nothing else, just not based on a "round" number of meters). For example, since failure rates in safety engineering are usually pretty small and nobody wants to pronounce "something times ten to the minus eight" or similar, the term "fit" was invented to stand for 10^-9. (Although I admit that "failure in time" is a stupid name for a dimensionless constant) Similarly you could invent a "galactic length" or however you'd like to call it.
- wyclif 12y agoAmericans occupy a big enough economic sphere that they get to define their standards [Disclosure: US citizen here] While this is true, I don't think it's helpful to attach American economic/cultural dominance to the metric debate (at least wrt advocacy), because US and Imperial measurements and standards are almost identical. But that "almost" is an important qualifier. The root system they both share derives from the Middle Ages. Here's a helpful explanation of the differences: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparison_of_the_imperial_and_US_customary_measurement_systems http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparison_of_the_imperial_and_...
- jamesli 12y agoI would argue it is extremely simplistic to compare languages to unit systems side by side. In languages, it is both a way of communication and also a way of thinking, to say the least. Mandarin Chinese is my native language. My English is just ok, but it already gives me a new way of thinking, much more than a different perspective. Also, there are many words and phrases in one language that you can't find a matched translation in another language, even between languages that are closely related, like English and German. Different unit systems, on the other hand, can be converted to and from each other without losing anything. There could be some affinity attached to a system one grew up with. It is incomparable to languages, though.
- jacobolus 12y ago> Different unit systems, on the other hand, can be converted to and from each other without losing anything. This really depends what you’re trying to do. Learning electrodynamics is a lot easier if you use cgs–Gaussian units instead of SI units, cf. http://bohr.physics.berkeley.edu/classes/221/1112/notes/emunits.pdf http://bohr.physics.berkeley.edu/classes/221/1112/notes/emun...
- Shorel 12y agoOf course it doesn't affect people in the USA that much. It only affects all its neighbors and trade partners. It has a very real cost, but it's something you pass to others, just an externality with no lines in your own ledger.