4 ms·
Do people who otherwise did an acceptable job get canned just because they ranked at the bottom? That's the concern about the practice, I think.
by davidw 12y ago
Do people who otherwise did an acceptable job get canned just because they ranked at the bottom? That's the concern about the practice, I think.
- michaelochurch 12y agoAlso, many companies make the mistake of making performance reviews part of the transfer packet. It seems like it just makes sense (you have "data"; why not use it?) but it actually fucks up the culture. It's basically never a good idea to have past performance reviews come into play in a transfer decision. First of all, it makes individual workers have their eyes on the scoreboard (reviews) rather than the game, because there's no escaping mediocre reviews; if you get smacked, you're stuck on a team forever. (And, sometimes you have good workers who get shitty reviews to prevent flight.) Second, it slows internal mobility to a crawl, because people getting lousy reviews can't move and people getting good reviews don't want to move, lest they risk getting mediocre scores and showing "negative trend" (making promotion nearly impossible). So, collaboration stops (due to the impossibility of lateral or diagnoal movement) and departmental position becomes permanent and tribal, and you get the "warring departments" dynamic. Even if you don't agree that departmental rivalry is a bad thing, what it tends to mean is that, due to the unpredictable sabotage events, whole sectors of the company become unreliable and upper management finds itself duplicating effort and running "bake-offs", but talented people avoid bake-off projects like the plague, so you get a "Dead Sea Effect". Usually, when people talk about stack-ranking, they're also talking about Enron-style performance reviews (that is, performance reviews that are part of the transfer packet). You can theoretically have one and not the other, but they tend to go together.
- ryanobjc 12y agoYes. That is exactly what us happened. I know a few people who were edged out like that. Make no mistake, Amazon is not a great place to work. Ok place to work maybe. Good if you have managed to fit in. But even after that, they underpay. Friends with literally a decade of time out in are making relatively low considering their wide areas of responsibility.
- npinguy 12y agoYou can criticize Amazon for a million things, but underpayment is not one of them.
- xyzzy_plugh 12y agoYou're the first person I've ever heard defend Amazon's compensation. What are your sources?
- npizzolato 12y agoGlass door claims $98k for SDE1 and $113k for SDE21]. How much do you expect? [1]: http://www.glassdoor.com/Salary/Amazon-com-Salaries-E6036.htm http://www.glassdoor.com/Salary/Amazon-com-Salaries-E6036.ht...
- aroton 12y agoI want to point out, this is SALARY only. Don't forget about stock/bonuses.
- fru2013 12y agoAmazon's compensation is not much different than other tech firms in seattle (at least according to glassdoor).
- Devthrowaway80 12y agoSenior people at Amazon that I personally known and worked with have said they were undercompensated compared to offers from other, similarly-sized companies. Most of the good ones no longer work at Amazon.
- consideranon 12y agoComparing with my friends over at Microsoft, while the base salary is certainly lower, cash bonus and stock pretty much equalizes compensation, at least as an SDE I. Total compensation is lower than Google/Facebook, but that's a high bar for ANY company. I think this myth really continues both because people tend to only pay attention to base salary and don't consider cost of living/state taxes, and due to the fact that Amazon does underpay warehouse workers, as evidenced by the current strike in Germany. I can't speak for higher level positions though. But Amazon tends to strongly favor giving out more stock over more cash, which goes back to the same issue of not comparing total compensation.