3 ms·
Even a 1:1 teacher-student ratio would not improve education if that teacher cannot respond and adapt to the needs of the student. If that teacher is bound by
by logfromblammo 12y ago
Even a 1:1 teacher-student ratio would not improve education if that teacher cannot respond and adapt to the needs of the student. If that teacher is bound by a common curriculum and testing regime, or an otherwise rigid administration, you might as well teach with a bunch of robots.
Bring on the anecdote. Math is taught by very different methods now than those I remember, and I shudder to think about what is being taught in class now when my child can do a homework worksheet and get every single question on it completely wrong. And the reason, as far as I can tell, is because the curriculum is sometimes using logarithms and decimal-shift operations to teach multiplication and division. They are literally teaching kids to simulate the mechanical processes behind slide rules and abacuses in their brains in lieu of just memorizing the multiplication table. The entire system seems constructed around the complete avoidance of rote memorization.
But that is how I learned to multiply. Memorization of the multiplication table from 0x0 to 9x9 was absolutely required. You could not progress at all if you could not quickly look up any of those 100 numbers. 55, really, thanks to multiplication being a commutative operation. Or 36 if you could also remember that 0xn=0 and 1xn=n.
Rather than ask kids to memorize and index those 36 numbers for quick recall, I see piles of nonsense about "compatible numbers" and "reasonable numbers" and other concepts of dubious value outside the narrow context of quickly selecting the correct answer in a multiple-choice test, without actually doing the work.
I actually had to teach my child that the exact answer to a math question is, in fact, a reasonable estimate.
To top it off, judging from Feynman's anecdote about being on a textbook selection committee, this same nonsense, or cleverly repackaged iterations of it, has continued unabated for decades. Wakalixes make it go. Wakalixes pay the bills. Wakalixes extract the tax dollars and deliver it to the rent-seeker. And the students continue to learn, or fail, largely based upon whether their individual teachers care more than the median amount.
The economics of public education create too wide of a separation between the interests of the student and the signers of the checks. No matter how hard you push on that rope, the load will barely move. Adding more money will not help when there is already very little connection between the amount spent and the observed outcomes.