3 ms·
I think there's some ambiguity about whether you mean submitting your own blog entry, or making a submission that consists of text rather than a link. Literall
by 10ren 17y ago
I think there's some ambiguity about whether you mean submitting your own blog entry, or making a submission that consists of text rather than a link.
Literally, a "self-post" is the latter, and I see in one of your replies that that's what you meant. However, commentors have interpreted it both ways (and I thought you meant the former).
Perhaps you could clarify in the poll - though there are already 252+7 votes with the original text, so maybe a new poll is appropriate?
As for the poll: I think submitting a blog (the former) is definitely OK; but I don't have a clear conception on a "self-post" (the latter). It could lead to HN being a kind of mini-blogging service (blog > HN > tweet). Maybe that would be cool, but it's very different from what it is now; and it's too unknown for me to form a clear opinion, without some experience of it. Therefore, because I think you mean the latter, I can't vote!
However, someone commented that pg deliberately made the text of a self-post in a lighter grey, to discourage it... so he seems against it.
- alttab 17y agoI caught on to the subtly of the lighter text as well. I could kind of tell because when a Ask HN comes up with 3 paragraphs of text and its in that light color, the conversion rate form me actually reading it drops significantly.
- ErrantX 17y agoI have first hand experience of that; and your right.
- j_baker 17y agoYeah, it's been so long that I've heard "self-posting" used to mean the latter that I had forgotten about it. Isn't that a redit thing?
- 10ren 17y agoSo... which one did you mean? Your other reply * seemed to indicate the latter (as I say in the comment); but here you're saying that you'd forgotten about that meaning, so I guess you can't have meant it... * http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=875735 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=875735 ah, now I see: the commenter gave two interpretations, and you replied "that's what I meant" without specifying which one. I didn't notice the ambiguity, and read you as meaning the "grey text in a HN post"; but it now seems you meant the other meaning ("linking to your own blog"). Wow. Confusion upon confusion, which I didn't notice even when asking about it. :-?