9 ms·
New York Magazine's Boy Genius Investor Made It All Up
- nodata 12y agoIt looks like at least one story is still up: http://nymag.com/news/articles/reasonstoloveny/2014/mohammed-islam-stock-trading/ http://nymag.com/news/articles/reasonstoloveny/2014/mohammed... Can't find a reaction yet. Edit: they updated it. "We presented it as a rumour all along".
- couchand 12y agoAn unbelievable amount of money for anyone, not least a high-school student, but as far as rumors go, this one seemed legit.
- danso 12y agoBetween this and the Rolling Stone U.Va-rape story...this has been a bad month for New York-based magazine reporting (and a boon for media critics). The NYmag reporter insists she made no error, because her lede paragraphs talks about a "rumor". Yeah, but the point of being a journalist is to find out the truth behind rumors, not just to say, "Hey, did you know that there are rumors about a high school boy?" The reporter claims she saw "bank statements"...the validity of which seem to be in question if the boy has recanted everything. I wonder if she got taken in by the good-ol edit-the-HTML-of-official-documents-with-the-Web-inspector trick? On the upside, at least this teenager doesn't have to bear eternal Internet shame for being part of a public prank/lie. His name is pretty much Google-proof, or at least as Google-proof as someone named "Jesus Christian" would be. That said...I just Googled "Mohammed Islam" and was pretty surprised to see all the top results relating to the young man at hand. I would've thought that Google's algorithm would've associated such a query with Islam the religion and the prophet Muhammad.
- kristianc 12y agoIt might be Google's recency algorithm coming into play, or he could be coming unstuck through the variable spellings of Mohammed (of which, I think Muhammad is actually the most common, at least in the West.)
- kmfrk 12y agoAlso Gladwell's plagiarism in the New Yorker.
- hnnewguy 12y ago>but the point of being a journalist is to find out the truth behind rumors Agreed. Defending the story as reporting a rumour is even worse. As a journalist, being duped is one thing; not caring enough to print a real news story is another.
- throwaway90446 12y agoIn both of the stories you cite, it's a case of journalists beginning with a narrative and then seeking a story to corroborate that narrative. Whether it's feel-bad narratives like "rape culture is rampant in fraternities" or feel-good narratives like "downtrodden teenager wins big with his pluck and smarts", journalism has become driven by narrative. It no longer reports news.
- bobcostas55 12y agoCowen did a great talk against narratives a few years back: http://lesswrong.com/lw/8w1/transcript_tyler_cowen_on_stories/ http://lesswrong.com/lw/8w1/transcript_tyler_cowen_on_storie...
- Fede_V 12y agoI completely agree. It's also a consequence of trying to compete with outlets like Buzzfeed that produce a huge amount of low quality stories on a shoestring budget, then optimize the hell out of SEO to get very high traffic.
- judk 12y agoWhat do you mean by "become" and "no longer"
- jonifico 12y agoI suppose Google's algorithm also bases itself on the current information trends at the time of searches, and with the ridiculously large amount of news stories about the kid, it is to be expected (I live in South America, and we also got a lot of reports about the kid). Now, the kid is not your average school-goer, but definitely petite enough to get himself in this situation. I blame him, but definitely not as much as the reporter, this looked like a load of BS right from the moment I saw it.
- jebus989 12y agoIn fairness the original "reporting" was for some buzzfeed-y 12 reasons to love New York, alongside "Because We Were All Taylor Swift Once" (which seems to be some tautology about being excited about NYC, not really sure). Anyway, over the last few hours Pressler switched her twitter to protected so I don't doubt she's getting sufficiently called out for this error.
- kingkawn 12y agoDo you think this is a reflection of New York-based magazine reporting in general?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- nemanja 12y agoYes, this story made me cringe really hard as I was reading it last evening. First off, if the reporter just bothered to speak with only one person who ever traded derivatives, she would have learned this was a complete hoax. Simply put, even if the kid started with $1m and ended up with say $60m after two years (being generous all around given the context), that would still amount to 6,000% return. Here is why that couldn't happen - He made directional outright bets. In other words, say he bought call options betting for the price of the underlying security to go up. This is akin to buying underlying security with massive leverage. If the bet goes your way, you could make a massive return (for example, in Oct '05, I made ~1,000% one-day return on a very small amount buying Google out of the money calls expiring the next day and selling them in the money after stock picked up following earnings report). This is an incredibly dumb strategy and it is completely unscalable to the figures quoted in the article. First, public/listed options are incredibly illiquid in most stocks/securities, and particularly at strikes that could yield this return. This would limit him to making really small bets. Second, you would need a catalyst for a significant price move, which doesn't come too often, so most of the time you would just bleed your option time-value ("theta decay"). Finally, and most importantly, no one is lucky 100% of the time and this type of directional strategy is sure to backfire on you and cost you ~100% of principal (trust me, been there, done that) He traded volatility. This is effectively a hedge fund strategy, where you buy the option and short the delta of the option in underlying security ("delta hedging"). The hedge gives you protection against the price moves in the underlying and you effectively make money for small moves in the security, regardless of whether it goes up or down (due to "convexity"). Most of the time, you earn pennies on the dollar as the price fluctuates a bit and you trade your delta, and perhaps some of the time you make a bit more if the price moves a lot ("gamma event"). Now, here is the kicker - this is not fool proof either. The strategy trades the risk in the price of the underlying security to the risk in volatility - in other words, if you buy volatility high and sell low, you will still lose money. Most listed options have notoriously bad bid/ask volatility spreads and retail investor would unlikely make any money consistently and reliably enough following this strategy. Needless to say - no way to scale it to the numbers quoted in the article using listed options. Hedge funds and derivative desks at banks mostly trade in OTC (Over The Counter) options which are bespoke bilateral contracts with a ton of protective provisions (averaging periods, stock borrow protection, illiquidity protection, etc) and they still have to take a view on volatility and they do get it wrong sometimes. Even for professionals who are wicked smart and do this day in and day out, the only reliable way to make money is to buy volatility on the cheap in a special situation. There are a few other strategies that come to mind (e.g. Black Swan) but there has been either no catalyst to make it work or they would be inaccessible to a high school kid from Queens. The second part that really made me cringe were all the negative references to SV by the kids and by the reporter in her subsequent Tweets. Reality of the situation is that, whatever you may think about early stage bubble in SV, SV tech companies actually create real value, have actual products and serve actual customers/users. Finally, what is sad about all this is that Mohammed appears to be a smart talented kid and I can't help but think he tainted his prospects quite a bit with this debacle. On the other hand, all this makes a hell of a "what I learned from a failure" college essay.
- judk 12y agoGoogle favors recent news sites over old general knowledge.
- aikah 12y agoYou forgot the BitCoin creator story,that was entirely fake.The guy didnt even know what Bitcoin was.Just because he was called Satoshi it was good enough for the journalist.
- thret 12y agoThis sounds suspiciously like the plot of a Farrelly brothers movie.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- Rainymood 12y agoNo fucking shit. Seriously guys? Was this a surprise to anyone? If it's too good to be true, then it probably is. Words to live by.
- tomp 12y agoOn the other hand, Facebook did buy WhatsApp for $18bn.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- frakkingcylons 12y agoWhen they were bought, WhatsApp had hundreds of millions of users every month in parts of the world most companies barely reach. This was a high school student supposedly beating the market to the tune of $72m during lunch period.
- silverbax88 12y agoI have to agree. I only saw the headline yesterday, but even quick mental math led me to think the headline was just clickbait.
- coverband 12y agoIf anyone fron NYMag is reading this -- I'm the son of late Nigerian king Joseph Mabadu and would like to share my billion-dollar fortune with him if he can help me transfer my wealth out of the country. As a show of good faith, I'm also willing to hand him over my title for the Brooklyn Bridge. Please call urgently to discuss...
- nchlswu 12y agoHow much do PR firms cost? and how well off do you have to be to afford one?
- ep103 12y agoI'm going to guess in the ballpark of 72 million
- MertsA 12y agoI'd be really interested to know if the New York Magazine is footing the bill for the PR firm, it already looks quite bad on them and it could make sense for them to do so just to save face.
- imjk 12y agoNot that this is the case here, but crisis PR firms would love the publicity from an event like this and many would be willing to take this on pro bono. If you think about it, this is a really easy case for the PR firm that brings huge amounts of publicity, so they're really getting their bang for their buck. The clients in this case are just high school "kids" whose story got taken out of context and exaggerated by the manipulative "media". Any wrong doing can really be swept under the rug with a sincere apology. Who can't relate to the follies of youth, esp when there's powerful media enterprise trying to exploit them?
- bvm 12y agoThe fact the name of the PR firm is mentioned in the article probably means it's (at least in part) PR for the PR firm as much as anything.
- filmgirlcw 12y agosigh
- majeure 12y agoBREAKING: Facebook buys Mohammed Islam for $72,000,000,000.
- aroman 12y agoOne thing I'm still confused about: if the parents have literally excommunicated him/functionally (temporarily) disowned him, who's idea was the PR firm, and moreover, who is paying for it?
- pavel_lishin 12y agoI doubt he's literally disowned. This sounds like some hyperbole on his part, as well as theirs. Look at the quote: > So what did your parents think when they’re reading that you’ve got $72 million? > Mohammed Islam: Honestly, my dad wanted to disown me. My mom basically said she’d never talk to me. Their morals are that if I lie about it and don’t own up to it then they can no longer trust me. … They knew it was false and they basically wanted to kill me and I haven’t spoken to them since. He didn't say they haven't spoken to him; they didn't say they did disown him. I've had my parents angry at me, to the point where they've yelled and said "I could kill you!" - but they're not literally going to murder him, and they're probably not literally disowning him.
- aroman 12y agoI didn't mean to suggest they were literally disowning him — that's why i said "functionally" and "temporarily".
- awwstn 12y agoThey might be working for free as part of some sort of partnership. In the aftermath of this, a good PR firm would have no shortage of ideas for monetizing these kids' infamy. In fact, it's quite possible the NY Observer paid a pretty penny for this exclusive interview.
- imjk 12y agoA crisis PR firm would love the publicity from an event like this and many would be willing to take these clients pro bono (not that they did in this case).
- gadders 12y agoDid anyone actually believe the story when they first read it? My first thought was "Yeah, right."
- jonnathanson 12y agoI doubt anyone here believed it. The rest of the Internet? All bets are off. Look at how many Buzzfeedy hoaxes get passed around like wildfire on Facebook, week after week, often by the same people in your circle. Some people -- and by "some," I mean a disappointingly large proportion of people -- don't think critically about what they encounter on the web. For them, it's not about the article. It's about the headline, and how the headline makes them feel about themselves, about the world, or about their friends. By the time they see a catchy or feel-good headline, they're already racing out to share it with everybody. If they actually get around to reading the article attached to the headline, the reading is incidental.
- pwthornton 12y agoHonestly, this story is so unbelievable that it leads me to believe that many journalists have no idea how investing or the stock market work. Even if he started with $100,000 to invest, it would be an insane annual yield. A yield so high, that even crazy frauds like Bernie Madoff wouldn't promise it. It's not that you couldn't make $72 million dollars by investing in the stock market in a few years, but rather that it would usually take a rather large principal to do so. This isn't the same as the UVA rape story, as that took months of reporting and fact checking. That's one of the biggest journalistic mess ups in the last decade or so, and will have far reaching consequences for Rolling Stone. We'll be discussing the UVA rape story for the entire next episode of my podcast. This is the more run-of-the-mill story about how a lot of journalists have so little knowledge about things outside of journalism that they get duped by these stupid and false feel good stories. This is more embarrassing than harmful.
- talmand 12y agoIt seems that many "journalists" these days can't be bothered to learn much about anything that they "report" on. I miss the old days of "two sources or we don't print".
- danielweber 12y agoJust a few days ago the New York Times took a google translate of an Italian Huffington Post article as the source for a papal proclamation.
- aikah 12y agowell nobody but advertisers is paying for that.How can you expect anything serious when your client isnt the reader?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- ghshephard 12y agoBernie Madoff offered returns in the 10% range. If he had started with $100K, after three years, he would have claimed to have $33K in returns, for a total of $133K. Just to put these kids claims into perspective.
- Fede_V 12y agoThis is the really dangerous consequence of chasing after stories that have nice narratives. If a story fits your ideological narrative perfectly, you should be twice as skeptical - real life stories are messy, imperfect, and very rarely perfectly illustrate whatever theory you have in mind.
- defen 12y ago> If a story fits your ideological narrative perfectly, you should be twice as skeptical That's exactly what Richard Bradley said (first prominent person I know of who publicly doubted the Rolling Stone UVA story; he was Stephen Glass's editor at George magazine) http://www.richardbradley.net/shotsinthedark/2014/11/24/is-the-rolling-stone-story-true/ http://www.richardbradley.net/shotsinthedark/2014/11/24/is-t... "The lesson I learned: One must be most critical, in the best sense of that word, about what one is already inclined to believe."
- danielweber 12y agoOn another forum I was on, there was a guy with the handle Japhy who coined Japhy's Law: that which you most want to be true is that which you should be most skeptical of. It came up all the time in political discussions as various participants would pull in sources showing how their side was right, but would crumble when subjected to the slightest examination.
- jordache 12y agoYes because ordering freshly squeeze apple juice at a place of eatery denotes baller status.. the author is crazy
- omarchowdhury 12y agoWell he's under 21 and a Muslim, so can't really drop $10K on the goose.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- austenallred 12y agoThe average person would be blown away at how sloppy (and really non-existent) fact-checking has become in the Internet age. Most people on HN seem to be a little bit pessimistic about it, but it's likely way worse than you think. Of course, we know that random people retweeting garbage on Twitter aren't fact-checking, but I'm talking about the largest media organizations around -- they just don't care enough to check. We don't need to look any further for this than ISIS. Not only is ISIS controlling the whole world's talking points by carefully crafting what news they'll release, but they're spreading stories all the time that are completely bogus. Look, for example, at this story about ISIS crucifying one of its own members for corruption: http://english.alarabiya.net/en/News/middle-east/2014/06/27/ISIS-crucifies-one-of-its-own-in-Syria-for-corruption-.html http://english.alarabiya.net/en/News/middle-east/2014/06/27/.... It all started with a tweet from a now-deleted Twitter account, because ISIS wanted to spread the idea of how intense they are and how strongly they fight their perceived evil. So they plant a story about how they crucified one of their own members. Every media organization knows that's free pageviews, so they report it. But look at the feature photo in that story, which constitutes most of the "tip" from the tweet. Do a reverse image search and you find the original source: It's a Danish Roman Catholic reenacting Christ's crucifixion in the Philippines. http://d.pr/i/183Sf http://d.pr/i/183Sf. The story of the ISIS crucifixion was made up out of thin air, based on a photo that was easily discoverable (and in the AFP database), but now the lie is in every mainstream media publication I can think of, from CNN and The Telegraph to The Guardian and the New York Times. They didn't even have time for a reverse image search. And ISIS wins. A lot of what my startup does is fact-check stuff that's going on in the media (it's a newsroom for the Internet - https://grasswire.com https://grasswire.com), and every media organization (and I mean every) from Al Arabiya and the New York Times to Newsweek to Rolling Stone and New York Magazine are quite frequently full of inaccuracies and intentional lies. Sometimes people catch these lies, a few people freak out for <24 hours, and we all forget about it. The notion that a publication's relevance is based purely on its accuracy is, in my opinion, false. We don't have the time or energy to process which media organizations we trust and which have mislead us, because, unless we're ruthlessly sitting behind a computer fact-checking stuff, we probably don't even know that they're making mistakes in the first place. For every one person The Daily Mail pisses off by publishing its false stories, 100 people are reading it and saying, "Wow, The Daily Mail does some daring reporting." Very few people care anymore -- we don't have time to. In Trust Me, I'm Lying: Confessions of a Media Manipulator, Ryan Holiday talks about how easy it is to get lies to spread throughout the Internet, and thereby all of mainstream media. The premise is very simple. You find someone at the bottom of the press pyramid - the person responsible for putting out 4 or 5 articles a day so that his or her publication can get enough pageviews to stay alive. There's not a chance that person can do any sort of verification. You send them a "tip," get a few smaller blogs to write about it, and the snowball starts rolling. These publications all read each other, and most of them just want to pick up stories from each other and ride the wave of whatever's going viral. That's not just cat videos; that's stories about ISIS and Russian fighters in Ukraine and what we consider "hard news." The stuff we all talk about in the United States is mostly driven by PR folks who are carefully planting stories that push their agenda forward. In most other countries it's even worse. Few of my Russian friends are even aware of the fall of the Rouble and the pending collapse of their own economy. I don't know what the solution is (I'm trying to find/create one), and I don't want to pretend like this has only happened since the Internet came into existence, but I find most people put way too much trust in the press machine we've created. I would like to think that somewhere there are independent reporters and people who are digging up stories, but I've come to realize that most stories aren't ever dug up - they're pitched.
- joeblau 12y agoIs there anything in place to ensure accountably of news releases in news organizations? I'm pretty sure that if enough of this happens; the reputation of the news organization will suffer.
- TheOtherHobbes 12y ago>Is there anything in place to ensure accountably of news releases in news organizations? News organisations are in the business of shaping public opinion and/or providing public entertainment. They're not in the business of encouraging informed debate - which is a minority interest at best, and bad for business at worst. So - no. There is no accountability in journalism or in media ownership.
- cbd1984 12y ago> Is there anything in place to ensure accountably of news releases in news organizations? Who do you want ensuring accountability? A government? Another private entity?
- joeblau 12y agoSay I'm a news Agency with multiple broadcast mechanisms and I continually post incorrect information that in turn ends up destroying private citizens lives; Is there any recourse that private citizens can take against the organization? For example, can you take legal action for defamation of character?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- stale2002 12y agoGood on these Stuy kids! The media will print anything, and they deserve to be messed with every now and then. All in all, it was a really funny prank!
- dkrich 12y agoI don't understand why anybody would be blaming them. This is 100% on the author of the story and NY Mag. They published the story, it's their responsibility to fact-check it. I for one think it's hilarious that they got this story run at all, although I can understand the stress of being at the center of a hoax and all of the attention it brings.
- cmollis 12y agowait.. is this story a lie too?
- judk 12y agoDidn't we just have the bogus story of the kid who made $300k on penny stocks?
- kyleblarson 12y agoHe pulled numbers out of thin air to artificially inflate returns and paint a rosy picture of his personal economy? I'm sure the US Federal Reserve is already actively recruiting him.
- michaelochurch 12y agoThis feels slightly "Black Mirror" but, to me, it's inevitable. It's a charismatic story. It's somewhat of an advertorial, not just for a person, but for an idea: that someone at Stuyvesant (which is full of high-talent, mostly middle-class, students because the truly wealthy go to schools like Dalton that deliver Harvard if you show up for class, and Stanford as a consolation prize) can make $72 million on his wits alone. I would want to believe it, were I not knowledgeable enough on finance to smell the bullshit. The current corporate world is built on lies, repeated often enough until they become truth (reputation, prestige, credibility). There are facts, and occasionally those hit back against an aggressive lie; but most of what drives economic life (especially at the individual level) is brand and reputation and social proof. How many corporate executives got there without lying about their CVs, polishing their career histories and accomplishments, and generally manicuring their reputations using a number of tools including deceit? Probably zero. Occasionally, some corporate executive gets caught in a lie and is scapegoated, usually because he was stupid and lied about something easily refutable like where he went to college... even though they all do it. The sad thing here is that we're talking about a teenager who (a) stood to gain next to nothing and (b) probably didn't intend for any of this to happen at all. The disgusting thing is that, if he takes a fall for this, then he'll have fallen not because of any deception but because of social class. A middle-class kid makes the middle-class mistake of (possibly) lying about something that can be refuted, and gets burned. An upper-class kid gets a $5 million seed round on parental connections and Stanford Welfare (a more pernicious lie, because it looks like merit) and gets away with it, being allowed to play CEO for years until "adult supervision" is brought in to administer a company that he still owns.
- bullbozer 12y agoWhoa, slow down there. Your post is littered with assumptions. Probably zero How do you know this, exactly? even though they all do it Again, how do you know this? An upper-class kid gets a $5 million seed round on parental connections and Stanford Welfare (a more pernicious lie, because it looks like merit) and gets away with it Simply making up a hypothetical scenario does not support whatever point you are attempting to make here. Is there a specific example you are referring to? And besides, what exactly is this hypothetical upper-class kid "getting away with"?
- bsg75 12y agoThere are no journalists anymore. Just a bunch of social media junkies rushing to be "first".
- larakerns 12y agoThe average news consumer expects bite sized, outrageous chunks of information to wash down with lunch – it's a two way stream of degradation.
- eastbayjake 12y agoThe real shame is that this article would have still been great even if she'd done the fact-checking and found out he was lying. You've got two kids in suits buying apple juice and caviar, trying to convince a grown woman that he's worth $72 million. It's the makings of a great Vice article. I would have loved to read about these two kids as they try to pull a highly-transparent confidence scam while all the adults in the room know they're lying.
- wnevets 12y agoPeople enjoy pretending hard journalism is the rule rather than the exception. Having the internet & cable news destroy it is just another part of the fantasy TV shows like The Newsroom enjoy telling.
- razzaj 12y agoIn my opinion the VAST majority of people never fact check, and most of the remaining people don't fact check unless the reporter's views strongly conflict with their own. In the current case being discussed, some embarrassment, and probably some figurative spanking are the aftermath. In other more serious cases (crime, armed conflict, group terrorism, state terrorism) the aftermath of such a pattern is much more dramatic. The hard truth is that media outlets need money to survive, to get that money they do two things: publish News/views that won't upset people paying for ads; and publish scoops that sell. No one is going to read a magazine or news "paper" that is broke. But the hard question is: how do you effectively encourage properly done objective journalism? Is there a Reddit style karma scheme for news outlets? I imagine this will be effective if taken into account as an SEO signal.
- mbesto 12y agoAnd the real winners here? The media.