4 ms·
I'm surprised not to see the usual contingent of malthusians out in force. We're saving more kids than ever; surely this means we're all doomed, right? BillG sh
by toyg 12y ago
I'm surprised not to see the usual contingent of malthusians out in force. We're saving more kids than ever; surely this means we're all doomed, right? BillG should spend all this money on sterilising (poor, non-white) people instead, right?
(ok, ok, this is a bit trollish, but my point stands: the world is getting better and the sky is not falling -- deal with it)
- skrebbel 12y agoSoo, you missed a trollish debate so you're trying to start it even though you don't agree with the presumed point which, in fact, nobody is making?
- toyg 12y agoI didn't say malthusians are trollish, I admitted I was being trollish. I am just curious about why they're not trying to spin it in their usual fashion.
- _nedR 12y agoWell, The average intelligence of the Hacker News commenter is a tad above that of Youtube or the Daily mail. Bill Gates himself has repeatedly stated that reducing mortality and improving quality of life has consistently proven to reduce population growth : http://annualletter.gatesfoundation.org/#myth-three http://annualletter.gatesfoundation.org/#myth-three Everybody here already knows this of course. ;)
- cbd1984 12y agoSadly for you, we're second-order contrarians around here! Non-contrarian: "Saving kids is good!" First-order contrarian: "Malthusianism! Overpopulation! Blargh!" Second-order contrarian: "Education leads to reduced population. People have fewer kids when they know child death is very rare." Third-order contrarian: "Population collapse! End of growth! Blargh!" Fourth-order contrarian: "We've dealt with worse and survived. Maybe space colonization will provide a positive impetus for population growth and a new engine for economic growth."
- toyg 12y agoWell, it looks like the regular contrarians have finally caught on: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8757464 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8757464