3 ms·
How could distribution of the encoded images be infringing a patent? It's the distribution and possibly use of the encoders and decoders that would be within th
by wtallis 12y ago
How could distribution of the encoded images be infringing a patent? It's the distribution and possibly use of the encoders and decoders that would be within the scope of patent law, not the output itself. The encoded image isn't the invention.
If I own a patented 3d printer, would you be worried that those patents could restrict my ability to distribute the objects printed by it?
The javascript decoder would certainly be covered by the patents as much as any other decoder, so it doesn't solve the patent-related barriers to adoption even if it takes care of the practical issues with using the format.
- codexon 12y agoErr, because MPEG-LA and the other patent holders that didn't join knows that Fabrice Bellard didn't license the patent from them, so you used an unlicensed encoder. If you stick that poly-fill on your website they can also sue you for distributing the decoder to everyone that downloaded the javascript file.
- reubenmorais 12y agoIANAL, and this might be a simple case of letter vs. spirit, but my understanding was that shipping the decoder's source is allowed, so with a JS implementation you're theoretically safe. This was one of the arguments around Broadway, the JS H.264 decoder.
- tjohns 12y agoI'd argue there's a difference between shipping source code, and actually embedding it in your page via a <script> tag. Once you embed the script into your page for execution, you're building a derivative work -- not just publishing technical details. Otherwise JS would become a universal patent loophole, which I'm pretty sure a judge would find fault with. (IANAL also.)
- WildUtah 12y agoThe usual technique is to claim the encoding technique, the decoding technique, and the data structures expressed by and expressing the technique. There's also equivalents and the doctrine of induced infringement. The patent courts and ITC have looked very unfavorably on First Amendment claims and on defenses based on lack of infringement within the USA and technologies with alternative non-infringing uses not being liable. The Supreme Court is less extremist than patent courts on insisting that patents pre-empt the Constitution, but the Supreme Court takes very few cases and you'd already have spent millions to get there and -- most importantly -- the patent courts largely don't consider Supreme Court cases to be necessarily binding precedent next time around.