3 ms·
It's an interesting case, which raises a few issues. On the surge itself, I think it's a bit instructive to imagine two worlds, call them World 1 and World 2.
by dllthomas 12y ago
It's an interesting case, which raises a few issues.
On the surge itself, I think it's a bit instructive to imagine two worlds, call them World 1 and World 2. In World 1, every person has the same ability to pay and attachment to money - their willingness to pay changes only by virtue of how much they need the ride. In World 2, every person needs the ride precisely as much, their willingness to pay is solely due to differences in their financial circumstance.
In World 1, the ideal response in every sense would seem to be surge pricing. Those willing to pay a higher price would have their greater need met, at a price they agreed to. Refunding them is fine but arguably unnecessary.
In World 2, we're clearly discriminating by class (what you think about that depends on your moral framework; I don't love it) by initially presenting the higher price, whether or not it's refunded. It's interesting to note that refunding in this case is particularly weird - you're giving money back to those who need it least - except when you consider that Uber probably has greater ability to pay than anyone in Sydney...
The real world, of course, doesn't resemble either of these.
In all cases offering more to drivers is desirable, other things being equal.
One thing that I haven't seen discussed is that there could be a distinction between moving people to some minimum safe distance, and moving people beyond that.