3 ms·
Jacking up prices in response to a humanitarian problem is called 'profiteering'. It is economically sound, but it's not ethical. If they want to show it worke
by vacri 12y ago
Jacking up prices in response to a humanitarian problem is called 'profiteering'. It is economically sound, but it's not ethical.
If they want to show it worked, they should release numbers - proportionately how many uber drivers were 'enticed' back onto the roads? Show people that it actually works, rather than wave hands around saying 'mutter mutter logic mutter mutter save lives'.
- calbear81 12y agoI challenge the contention that it's profiteering because of the potential for the price increase to ease macro demand and supply challenges. It's a different case with something like bottled water since that has a fixed supply, jacking up the price does nothing to increase the availability of more bottled water in a short period of time.
- wutbrodo 12y agoProfiteering is generally applied to cases where allocative efficiency is increased (those who are willing to pay the most are used as a rough proxy for those who need it the most). That's where the "economically sound but unethical" thing comes in, since you're not actually providing any more of the direly needed good, you're just shifting around who gets it. In this case, raising prices is pretty much directly increasing supply, which is a net good for everyone (you're avoiding the case where someone wants to pay X and someone wants to sell for X but there's no avenue to do so). Agreed that from a PR perspective for those who can't grasp simple economics, they should release their data on surge factor vs drivers on the road.
- vacri 12y ago"directly increasing supply" - this is why I say they should say how effective it was. If a 4x price increase increased supply by 2%, that doesn't sound very effective.
- josu 12y ago> It is economically sound, but it's not ethical. In this case on the one hand you have people desperately trying to leave a place, and on the other hand you have drivers sitting at home not wanting to risk their lives for $x/mile. When Uber jacks up prices, you are creating incentives for those drivers to get out of their homes and start allowing people to desperately leave the places where they don't want to be in. Highers prices>More drivers>More people leaving the dangerous places There is nothing ethically wrong with it. I could even argue that the unethical thing would be not to jack up prices, since this would put less cars on the streets and consequently less people would be "rescued".
- vacri 12y agos/uber/food and s/sydney cbd/famine area "I could argue that jacking up the prices for food in a starving area is ethical, since it would encourage diversion of food from other areas, bringing in merchants who would otherwise not visit" Or maybe ethics is a little broader than just economic invisible-hand logic?
- youWontLikeThis 12y agoAnd if you cannot afford to pay, here is a well deserved bullet for your head.