2 ms·
> However after noticing (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6621560 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6621560) that LastPass' vault is easily broken into
by Someone1234 12y ago
> However after noticing (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6621560 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6621560) that LastPass' vault is easily broken into when open
So to use an analogy, you're unlocking your front door, showing a stranger into your home, and then are upset because they can steal stuff once inside?
They've already defeated all of your security if they have complete unrestricted access to your LastPass vault. The fact they can hit F12 and use the developer bar to inspect the DOM or restrive passwords from behind ###### is both expected and not a security issue.
> even with strict reprompt settings
That wasn't in your link. How do you bypass reprompt?
> I'm starting to trust their security model less and less.
Why? None of the reasons you've given are technically sound.
> I opened a support ticket about the obvious password breach detailed above, and they say it's an inevitable consequence of Chrome's broken security model in extensions.
It has nothing to do with Chrome's "security model." If you have completely unrestricted access you have complete unrestricted access. End of.
You are literally accessing a UI that can display all of your passwords in plain text and you're complaing because you can see your passwords in plain text... Well, yeah...
> Well, if that model is broken, I don't want to use it.
You haven't explained how it is.
> I find it misleading that LastPass even offers a reprompt option, since it is so easy to retrieve passwords from the application when it is logged in, even if a reprompt is required.
Huh? Can you explain how you're able to bypass the reprompt prompt?
> Sure, it would slow down unsophisticated attackers, but you don't need to be that sophisticated to change the type of an input.
It shouldn't slow anyone! You've giving the attackers complete unrestricted access to your password database. Nobody should be slowed, everyone should have a complete overview.
> I have been trying to use it with very fast autologout policies but it very annoyingly asks for a password twice (once to login, once as a reprompt) as well as the Yubikey for every single site. The usability is garbage.
Then turn the reprompt off and just have it ask for login...
> What do you use and what do you like/dislike about it?
I use LastPass, but I'd consider something else if any of your complaints had any technical credibility at all.
- STRML 12y agoI think you're misunderstanding how you bypass the reprompt. LastPass has two separate features - auto-logoff and reprompt, and you can tick a bunch of boxes to decide which features you want reprompt for. I usually tick most of them. You can then set a reprompt delay (from 0 to 24 hours), and while still logged in, you are reprompted at every interval when you try to use LastPass' features. This is a nice alternative to simply having it log out at intervals or log out when idle; some defense against a swiped computer or malicious coworker, etc. Of course the usual rules apply and you should never leave your computer unlocked but it is a nice feature. I would except that many LastPass users use the reprompt model instead of the auto-logout model, as it allows you to use some nice features (like site/form detection) that you wouldn't get when logged out. So the workflow with reprompt is simply: go to a site, click the autofill button, get prompted & type password, continue on. This is significantly easier than clicking the extension button, deliberately logged in, waiting for decryption, then clicking the autofill button. Unfortunately, if you rely on reprompts and somebody does get a hold of your computer, they can do some trickery with the inspector and lift your passwords so long as you are still logged in. This makes the reprompt useless; may as well not have it at all.
- Someone1234 12y agoSo your reason to drop LastPass is that you don't like their implementation of an optional feature even though an alternative is readily available (auto-logout)?