3 ms·
I do it like this: - Password database in KeePass (the mainline version, not KeePassX or one of the other spinoffs) - Database requires both password and key
by smacktoward 12y ago
I do it like this:
- Password database in KeePass (the mainline version, not KeePassX or one of the other spinoffs)
- Database requires both password and key file to unlock
- Key file only lives on a USB thumb drive, which lives on the keychain in my pocket
- Database lives in a folder that is auto-synced to my various devices via SpiderOak (https://spideroak.com/ https://spideroak.com/)
- Password autofill provided by KeeFox (http://keefox.org/ http://keefox.org/)
Using a password and a key file provides a "kinda sorta 2FA" solution, since the key file is tied to a physical artifact (the thumb drive, "something I have") while the password provides "something I know." It's not perfect, however, since the key file could theoretically be separated from the thumb drive if someone got ahold of it.
A better 2FA solution would be one that incorporates a key that's completely tied to the physical token. However, I haven't found a great consumer-oriented product along those lines yet, despite much looking. The YubiKey is the closest, but after buying two of them and spending hours fighting with them, I eventually gave up trying to make them work; they force a choice between their one-time-password (OATH) implementation, which is theoretically awesome but in practice very finicky, and just using a static password stored on the key, which isn't really any better than my USB stick solution.
I chose SpiderOak for syncing the database over alternatives like Dropbox, primarily because SpiderOak appears to actually give a shit about security and privacy. But it doesn't really matter that much because without both the keyfile and the password they couldn't look into the database anyway.
I chose KeeFox for the browser integration primarily because it's well-reviewed and open-source. But if you're concerned about the security of autofill in the browser, you could omit it entirely and just copy the password from the KeePass app when you need it. As always, the right balance of security vs. convenience will vary from person to person.
- pavel_lishin 12y agoWhat happens if you lose that USB thumb drive, or if it gets damaged?
- samelawrence 12y agoI would guess there is a copy somewhere. Safety deposit box, etc.