3 ms·
'What exactly did Google steal? Very exactly, Google steal "Headlines and very brief teasers". From the perspective of copyright law, yes, it can be classified
by jamesbritt 17y ago
'What exactly did Google steal? Very exactly, Google steal "Headlines and very brief teasers". From the perspective of copyright law, yes, it can be classified as quoting, so they can't sue google, but those "headlines and teasers" do carry news value and in some cases took large amount of resources to produce. Now, Google took it and provided link as a payoff. Is that payoff adequate? Murdoch and many news producers don't think so.'
This seems very much the same as walking past a newsstand, glancing at the headlines of assorted newspapers and magazines, perhaps flipping through one or two, to see what's happening. The stand owner is "giving away" the headlines, but how else are people going to know about the publications?
By similar logic, a newsstand owner should have to pay just to place a newspaper on display. Where has Murdoch been all those years while this robbery was occurring?
- greyman 17y agoYour analogy is logical, but there's still a difference. Newsstand and newspapers agreed beforehand the terms of their cooperation, and while they don't pay just for displaying the paper, they do pay certain amount of money for each sold piece, as is was agreed. But with Google, nothing was agreed beforehand, Google just decided that it will display the part of the content and will provide link as a payoff. But now I don't want to criticize Google, nor do I want to be Murdoch's advocate. I just notice that the newspaper critics don't look at the issue from publisher's perpective, thus making their articles a bit one-sided.