5 ms·
Say that I wasn't happy with the salary that Google is paying me. It's a good salary, but I want more. After all, my labor has already generated more revenue
by nostrademons 17y ago
Say that I wasn't happy with the salary that Google is paying me. It's a good salary, but I want more. After all, my labor has already generated more revenue for the company than I am likely to make in my lifetime. I, of course, don't have to work with Google - I can quit at any time. But in reality I can't, since my competition is also willing to work for the same wages and I have to eat. So I have to play by Google's rules, even if I believe they don't pay me enough for the value I am making.
Do you have much sympathy for me?
Why, then, do you have much sympathy for Rupert Murdoch and his billion-dollar corporation?
It's an analogy, and like all analogies, it's imperfect. But it's perhaps more apt than you'd expect. You might argue that I could easily quit and get a job at, say, Yelp or Facebook. But News Corp could easily block Google and form a partnership with Yahoo or Microsoft - heck, there's rumors that they are doing just that. Or you could say that I should quit and form my own business - well, News Corp could easily go hire a crack team of 100 programmers to build their own indexing engine. Except they probably won't find the good ones, since everything indicates that Google is a better place for a computer scientist to work than News Corp.
You might also argue that I'm already paid for my labor. Well, News Corp is already paid for the their headlines and their brief teasers: they're paid when people visit their page and advertisers put up money for that privilege. They just want to be paid more. It's not all that different from me wanting a higher salary because I generate far more value to the company than I cost.
- felixmar 17y agoOne difference is that you could work for thousands of software companies. In search there's Google and somewhere down the road Bing. Everyone else faces a near impossible road uphill. What if the only places you could work is Google or Microsoft? Do you think you would still get a fair treatment from either?
- nostrademons 17y agoIn many other industries, there really are only 2-3 major employers you could work for. My sister's choices (petroleum geologist) are basically limited to ExxonMobil, ChevronTexaco, ConocoPhillips, BP, and to a lesser extent Valero. If you're an auto assembly worker in Detroit, your choices are basically Ford, GM, and Chrysler. My point isn't that you'll get fair treatment (you won't), it's that life's not fair. It sucks to be an employee, it sucks to be a small business owner, and it particularly sucks to be one of the above when all your counterparties are giant monopolies. But as a society, our response to most people in these positions is "Suck it up and deal - you knew what you were getting into when you took the job." News Corp has been on the winning side of the "We're the only game in town" bargain a lot - they just finally met someone who plays the game better than they do. I really dislike the idea of changing the rules of the game because one billionaire is suddenly losing, when we didn't change the game when millions of middle-class families were losing.