6 ms·
And in UK police officers don't even carry guns anymore. It's impossible to shoot anyone by accident(or deliberately) if you don't have a gun in the first place
by gambiting 12y ago
And in UK police officers don't even carry guns anymore. It's impossible to shoot anyone by accident(or deliberately) if you don't have a gun in the first place. If there is a situation which requires using guns, backup force with them can arrive within minutes. There is simply no need for a policeman who does routine patrols to be carrying a lethal weapon on him.
Is there a statistic clearly showing that more deaths are prevented than caused by police officers having a weapon on them at all times in the US?
- viraptor 12y agoAirport police/security in the UK still does carry guns. And not small pistols at the belt. Big guns carried in both hands - it looks almost as if they really wanted them on display. You can't miss them due to the contrast of what normal police on the street looks like.
- tehwalrus 12y agoThe armed police at airports, and those at Parliament, are the only armed UK police I've ever seen. (I'm a UK person, lived here all my life).
- joncrocks 12y agoThey have them sometimes in central London, I suspect when there are specific events/threat levels are higher. I've seen them a few times when I've been walking round London, always a bit shocked when I stumble across them.
- Otik 12y agoI was once in a car that was pulled over at a speed trap in northern England, and noticed that they had guns on their hips. When asked, the officer said that they manned low-priority things like speed traps the majority of the time that they were on duty so they could rapidly respond to any firearms-related incidents. With how few of those we typically have, it sounds like an incredibly boring job.
- Marazan 12y agoYou'll often see armed police outside court houses for high profile or gang related cases in the UK
- pmorici 12y agoThere was a info graphic in a recent Economist that said that the police in America shoot and kill 400+ American citizens every year. By comparison in many European countries that same statistic is less than 10 per year. In the US something like 70 police officers are killed on the job every year a fraction of those are from being shot by citizens and the majority are from car accidents. The notion that being a police office is somehow this extraordinarily dangerous job where you might be shot and killed at any moment is I think largely a myth not substantiated by facts. Police officer doesn't even make the top 10 list of most dangerous jobs in American. http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2014-11-30/fbi-report-accidentally-exposes-severity-police-state http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2014-11-30/fbi-report-accident... http://www.fbi.gov/about-us/cjis/ucr/leoka/2013/leoka-home http://www.fbi.gov/about-us/cjis/ucr/leoka/2013/leoka-home
- GFischer 12y agoThe Economist article you mention was even harsher, in most European countries the statistic is ZERO. http://www.economist.com/news/leaders/21636033-united-states-needs-overhaul-its-law-enforcement-system-americas-police-trial http://www.economist.com/news/leaders/21636033-united-states... "American law enforcement is unusually lethal: even the partial numbers show that the police shot and killed at least 458 people last year. By comparison, those in England and Wales shot and killed no one." I'm a HUGE proponent of nonlethal alternatives, I don't understand why there isn't massive funding for better tasers.
- hga 12y agoThere are no "nonlethal" alternatives, just less lethal as the words of art put it. One of the many reasons I haven't yet invested in pepper spray is that the threshold for my using it should be the same as for my handgun. Any time you get into physical combat things can get seriously ugly, see e.g. Eric Garner. As for US vs. European statistics, you always need to make sure each is honest (e.g. are they counting all populations in their countries? Counterwise, remove the US south and we look rather European), and there's no question that the US is flatly more violent, e.g. remove all homicides with guns and our rate is still higher.
- jmccree 12y agoThere's two things that seems to be missing here with regards to routine patrol officers being armed in the US. First, Great Britain is smaller than many US states. The population density of ~780/sqmi is higher than all but 3 of US states. The majority of US states are under ~200 persons/sqmi. Outside of major cities and suburbs the nearest backup officer can routinely be 15 or more minutes away. As well, many areas have dangerous wild animals to deal with. Bears, coyotes, wolfs, etc. that Britain has mostly eliminated. Secondly, in the US, we have the right to keep and bear arms, which means every one the routine patrol officer encounters should be assumed to be legally armed as well. It would put officers at a severe disadvantage to be unarmed when regularly dealing with armed suspects. In many states 5-10% of the population has a concealed carry permit, and in the majority (40+) of states open carry of a rifle is legal without any permit. Whether you agree with this or not, it's a fact of life in most of the US that a large percent of the population is legally armed, so there seems no reason to arbitrarily limit police from also being armed as any individual citizen could be.
- pmorici 12y agoAny city of sufficient size probably has it's own animal control department. It isn't like police are in mortal danger from wildlife and need the gun for protection from it.
- bluedino 12y ago>> As well, many areas have dangerous wild animals to deal with. Bears, coyotes, wolfs, etc. that Britain has mostly eliminated. This is only true for a very small handful of remote areas where few of the US Population live.
- waterlesscloud 12y agoI live in the second biggest city in the country and see coyotes almost every morning. And there are reports pretty much every year of bears wandering into town. I'm not sure I buy wild animals as a reason for cops to carry guns, but there's a lot more of wild animals in a lot more places than you seem to think.
- philwelch 12y agoThe UK and US have fundamentally opposing views of government, I think. The UK strongly believes in "good government". If the government makes mistakes or does something poorly, the press will challenge them on it with the expectation that things will improve. In the US, we are almost self-defeatingly cynical about the idea of good government. "That government is best which governs least" is a distinctly American motto. But I think we actually can expect more from our government, we just don't because we don't think it's possible. And so ironically we are stuck with a government that governs quite a lot, actually, and not that well. Already in the US, standard search and arrest warrants are unnecessarily performed by heavily armed SWAT teams. Depending on where you live, you better not have any pets if the police come for you because they will kill them. If we disarmed ordinary patrol cops in the US, they would just not do anything and send SWAT to do all the real work.
- biomcgary 12y agoIt does seem like a non sequitur that a country with the mindset "government is best which governs least" would routinely utilize SWAT teams. I'm curious about the social dynamic that transforms the desire for minimal government intervention to overkill in policing. I have a hard time believing that it is simply low expectations. Perhaps the low expectations exist because reform is structurally difficult (e.g., voting system, etc). On the other hand, perhaps the situation is slow to change because it is exactly what the majority want? Only poor and minority populations interact with police regularly.