3 ms·
I like AMD. I told the CEO of NetApp he must fire me if going with an AMD processor (Opteron) in the high end (aka most profitable, flag ship) filer turned out
by ChuckMcM 12y ago
I like AMD. I told the CEO of NetApp he must fire me if going with an AMD processor (Opteron) in the high end (aka most profitable, flag ship) filer turned out to be the wrong decision. That said, I hate AMD, they can't execute for crap.
It wasn't for lack of vision. Fred Weber, their CTO at the time, had solid ideas about moving AMD into the lead for x86 scale chips. AMD kept thinking they were a chip making company and didn't unload what became Global Foundries fast enough. Not to mention that everyone who has to play with x86 is playing with the deck stacked against them. Massive memory machines are coming, all the cool kids are over at HP building one on "the machine" project. AMD could have built that machine 10 years ago, or at least laid the ground work for it. AMD owned a huge chunk of the FLASH market, they could have spun silicon in a way that would allow for mixed FLASH and DRAM on the "north bridge", it would have changed a lot of the economics of things. But when you're constantly about to die, it is really really hard to make strategic moves. So unless AMD stops perceiving itself as being on life support it won't be able to muster the courage to move forward on things where it could make a huge difference. And its not clear to me if it has fallen under the power curve or not. Fred took a huge risk when they did the Sledgehammer (aka Opteron) architecture. And I watched how much pain people went through trying not to piss off Intel to use it (including NetApp). And got to see how it totally stomped the living crap out Intel's Netburst designs. (Intel was pushing Itanium as their 64 bit / large memory answer, which also underperformed Opteron machines)
But the reverberations of that triumph were not good, AMD's inability to execute meant they stumbled on the next few bits. They got the jitters, canned Fred, and went for something "safe". Not a good plan for world domination.
- raverbashing 12y ago"AMD kept thinking they were a chip making company and didn't unload what became Global Foundries fast enough" Ah but they were only capable of do that after their settlement with Intel (I mean, the Intel anti-trust settlement) Before that if you wanted to make x86 chips the condition is that you manufactured the chips or something like that
- ChuckMcM 12y agoVery valid point. The albatross of x86 licensing/patents is a hard one to git rid of.