2 ms·
You accurately describe the many subtleties in audio engineering and pitch perception, but you omit the conclusion that, at least for pathological cases, there
by baddox 12y ago
You accurately describe the many subtleties in audio engineering and pitch perception, but you omit the conclusion that, at least for pathological cases, there is no objective "note in question." Two reasonable people, both musically educated, can have different interpretations of a note, especially in the context of a particular chord or musical arrangement.
- tacos 12y agoAgree, with caveats: in the context of vocal tuning there's often a desired note that represents the melody. And objectively there's often a note that a musician intended to play. Even if the instrument and signal path cooperate to capture this intent (the inharmonicity of the string itself; nonlinearities of the microphone and amplifiers; resonances in the instrument soundboards and rooms themselves) you're already chasing ghosts! Then add in a mixing engineer boosting and reducing frequencies, a tape machine varying in speed ever so slightly, and a mastering compression step throwing away amplitude detail -- and you've really got to wonder what the hell someone thought they were doing by running FFTs on a 50 year old analog mix and pretending they've got insight into the original solo instruments.