5 ms·
My point of view is this. Capitalism is the most effective way known of getting people to do what it gets them to do. However you have no control of what that
by btilly 17y ago
My point of view is this.
Capitalism is the most effective way known of getting people to do what it gets them to do. However you have no control of what that is.
Therefore if you want to have clean water supplies, universal education, national defense, police, unproductive people not starving in the streets, etc then you need to divert some resources away from capitalism. This is the justification for taxation and government.
The justification for Michael Moore's point of view is that he wants to see those things happen, and capitalism doesn't do that very well.
However be very careful about using government to try to direct capitalism to meet your goals. Because well-meaning interventions regularly fail spectacularly due to unintended consequences. One of which is that any influential group that is regulated by government will try (and eventually usually succeeds) in getting control over their regulators.
- fauigerzigerk 17y agoYour view is basically the consensus in western democracies. However, the more radical left claims that this kind of balance between a democratic state and capitalism can never work because capitalism will always be able to corrupt the state. It's this reasoning that allows them to put the entire blame for the current crisis on capitalism in spite of the fact that it's the governments and central banks of the world who inflated the credit bubble by providing easy money for so many years.
- teamonkey 17y ago> In spite of the fact that it's the governments and central banks of the world who inflated the credit bubble by providing easy money for so many years Yes, but they're doing that to profit - capitalism at its most pure :)
- borism 17y agoProfit? Really? Taking on debt is not considered profit in my books...
- teamonkey 17y agoPerhaps not, but it is (or was) down as a profit on their books, which is how the whole sub-prime fiasco came about. Or at least if not "profit", it was certainly a means for them to make profit.
- btilly 17y agoReally! Getting lots of other people to take on debt results in many other people making immediate profits to the short term benefit of all. Consider. We get Sally to take out a large mortgage on her home. The person issuing the mortgage takes the mortgage, sells it to an investment bank, and makes an immediate profit. At the investment bank they take those loans (small investments with considerable risk), bundle them into a deal, and slice and dice off several (rated) safe tranches that they sell for a profit. The purchasers of said debt get to take money that wasn't making interest and put it into something that makes money, resulting in an immediate profit on the books. All of those companies along the way record profits, and pay generous bonuses to the people who did those things. Those bonuses are a profit to the individual that is kept whether or not the organization runs into future problems. Which creates perverse incentives. There were many individuals who realized that they were doing something unsustainable. But if you don't do it, you'd lose your cushy job, while if you do it you make nice bonuses. From their point of view the possible eventual failure of Lehman etc were externalities and they were motivated by their current bonuses. Furthermore back in the neighborhood, Sally didn't sit on her money. Instead she spent it. The various businesses she spent money at get to record profits on those sales, which in turn goes to hiring people, paying healthcare premiums, etc. None of that would happen if Sally didn't take out that mortgage. In short what has happened is that the taking on the debt results in causing money to circulate. As money circulates, multiple people record profits. This is well understand, and is why standard macro-economic theory says that money is effectively created when debt is taken on. And, on the whole, this is a good thing. The problem, of course, is that just as money gets created by the taking on of debts, money gets destroyed when debts are abandoned. And when people take on debts they can't afford, they do get abandoned. Which is the current problem we are dealing with right now.
- WinterAyars 17y agoWell, i think we could do a better job of protecting government from corruption than we currently do. It would make a big difference if we had, for instance, publicly funded elections.
- lionhearted 17y agoThe problem is the word "capitalism" - it implies just for-profit enterprises. But capitalism is really just how Marx branded "free enterprise." > Therefore if you want to have clean water supplies, universal education, national defense, police, unproductive people not starving in the streets, etc then you need to divert some resources away from capitalism. Capitalism - free enterprise - handles all of those pretty well except national defense and maybe policing. Charities are part of capitalism. Infrastructure's not so bad for government to build. In wealthy countries, charities vastly outperform government in alms and welfare because it doesn't create power structures that people try to hijack and lobby. As for government in education, it corrupts education completely. Look at the standard American middle school and high school curriculum - very little of practically important things (scheduling, personal finance, establishing habits, interpersonal skills, critical thinking, problem solving), and a lot of nonsense. They teach algebra fairly well in American high school and almost nothing else. I can't believe that any educator would be in favor of government-run education: It sinks to a very low level, teachers are handcuffed by bureaucrats and public opinion in their teaching methods, honest perspectives on history, ethics, and civics become impossible to learn, bad teachers don't get fired, good teachers with non-traditional backgrounds don't get hired... like, government doing a lot of stuff is a relatively new idea, and it's a nice idea, but it usually doesn't work so well in practice.
- btilly 17y agoPlease do not confuse efficiency of directing money with being able to realistically address the problem. I grant that well-run charities are much more efficient than government. However not nearly enough money is voluntarily donated to charity to realistically address the problems that exist. Based on http://www.givingusa.org/press_releases/releases/20080622.htm http://www.givingusa.org/press_releases/releases/20080622.ht... we collectively donate about $300 billion per year. That's about $1000 per year per person. But to bring up one example, about 1% of the population gets schizophrenia, and about a third of those we do not have effective treatment for. In a country with 300 million people that's about a million people with an untreatable mental illness that is very expensive to deal with. At a minimum that would take 10-20% of the total available for charity for a cause most people haven't even heard of. Once you take out all of the money donated to causes donators care about - such as museums, cancer research, third world poverty, and a million splinter causes (such as the Electronic Freedom Foundation), there simply isn't enough left to address a lot of very real and expensive needs. Moving on let's look at your claims about education. I won't disagree with any of your criticisms. I've said the same and worse before. However I'm aware of one fact that you are probably not. Which is that, after controlling for parent's socioeconomic status, students who go to public schools in the USA do better on tests measuring their academic performance than students who go to private schools. (If you don't control for the large correlation with parent's socioeconomic status, public schools come out worse.) So as bad as the public option is, the private one seems to be worse! Not to mention that the big problem the public option solves is delivering education to those who are poor enough to not afford it for themselves. Not doing that would limit how much of an educated workforce was available in the future, to the detriment of everyone. But why does private education deliver a worse product? Part of the problem is that parents aren't as good of judges of the quality of their children's education as they think they are. So private schools are incented to do things that make parents think they are doing a good job at the cost of actually doing a good job. Incidentally education isn't the greatest illustration of the problem. Public health provides much better ones. For instance patrons of a restaurant are not in a position to judge whether sanitary procedures are being followed in the kitchen. Residents are unable to judge how good the water they receive is. Which is why public health was one of the first areas where economists came to understand why the invisible hand of the market didn't do a good job of provisioning the need.