5 ms·
I commented about using any drug entails some finite risk of bad effects. The apparently common belief that "designer drugs" shouldn't be "illegal" is certainly
by barrkel 12y ago
I commented about using any drug entails some finite risk of bad effects. The apparently common belief that "designer drugs" shouldn't be "illegal" is certainly not supported by the article.
I can see your line of thinking: X has risks, X should not be done, thus make X illegal and X will not be done and the risk will no longer exist.
But that's not the way the world works. Making X illegal does not prevent X being done. Instead, it creates incentives try and find people doing X and put them through the criminal system. That introduces a whole separate set of risks. And making X illegal reduces the probability that problems created by X will be treated in time. Another set of risks. Etc.
The question you should be asking is: are the risks of X greater than the risks of making X illegal?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- tjradcliffe 12y agoWhile I agree that is the appropriate question to be asking, it's worth considering the length and complexity of the drug pipeline for creating new legal drugs, as a way of estimating the risk of new illegal drugs, which go through nothing like the same degree of testing: http://www.pacificbiolabs.com/drug_stages.asp http://www.pacificbiolabs.com/drug_stages.asp A new legal drug in its first iteration frequently through animal models frequently has a breakdown of 80% or more effectiveness, with the balance of the population mostly experiencing no effect and a small remaining fraction experiencing negative side-effects. The drug will then be tweaked and twisted to increase the size of the population it is effective on and drop the size of the negative side-effect population to as close to zero as possible. This is a hugely expensive process. It is where a good fraction of the hundreds of millions of dollars that go into the development of legal drugs wind up, and it is necessary because biochemistry differs very significantly across individuals. What the makers of illegal designer drugs appear to be doing is more like a developer who says "works on my machine" and then ships. No testing, no QA, no coverage... just ship based on a single working instance in a particular environment. That's a recipe for disaster, and while the disasters are mostly recoverable, the process is fraught with risk. This does not mean that making it illegal will change anything, because near as we can tell from the data the law barely changes human behaviour. Making abortion illegal does not change it's rate but just makes it unsafe. Making murder legal would not result in a vast increase in the rate of murders--it would result in blood-feuds and other mechanisms that the codification of law was designed to prevent. People don't refrain from murder because it's illegal (for the most part) but because they believe it's morally wrong. The law follows from that widespread moral belief, not the other way around. So legalization and regulation may well be the best way to go, but given the ordinary standards of drug development that might create an underground grey-market where things are almost as bad, safety-wise, as they are now. A carefully targeted criminalization, that focuses solely on drug makers rather than distributors or users, might be a better solution. So long as we keep in mind that the goal is to minimize harm, including the harm done by law enforcement.
- xkcd-sucks 12y agoOn the other hand, plenty of really good legal drugs fail for reasons which might not be relevant to many people-- Strange metabolism in select ethnic groups, possible tox issues after chronic use, etc. For example, plenty of people involved with developing Vioxx bought tons of it before it was removed from the market, because it was such a good nsaid. These people decided that their mode of use wasn't problematic, or that the benefits of using the drug far outweighed the possibility of adverse reaction. While the Market and the FDA decided the drug should be pulled, the people who stockpiled it are certainly more informed than most medical doctors. If LSD were trialled for psychotherapy today, it would probably be rejected on the grounds that it could make crazy people experience severe adverse effects. With most novel recreational drugs, there's plenty of "phase 4" anecdata which suggests safety, at least in the short term and at cautious doses. Really nasty adrs usually show up fairly quickly, albeit at the expense of a few lives. If "legal" (nonrecreational) drugs could be put directly into phase 4 testing, drug development would be so much easier-- Animal models are a really crappy substitute for humans, especially with CNS stuff. I suppose it's a balance of Bad Big Pharma poisons us vs. Bad Big Pharma doesn't make cheap/new drugs...
- bigiain 12y agoThere's also the unspoken "X has risks, and I don't want to do X, therefore X should be illegal". I ride motorcycles. I have friends and family involved in scuba diving, paragliding, football, rock climbing, hell - even horse riding. _All_ of those activities have "well known risks of serious injury or death" associated with them, and each of them I've heard recent stories of death in the extended circles of my family and friends. I'm not sure whether the "designer drug" risk is anything like as high as some of those legal and "acceptable for your children" risks. My approach is less "asking are the risks of X greater than the risks of making X illegal?", but closer to "Quantify the risks of X, work out which can be mitigated or reduced without needing to ban X, make sure participants are informed of the risks, and if needed ensure training/insurance/licencing is available if required". Thirty thousand people a year are killed in motor vehicle accidents in the USA. We don't react by saying "Make cars illegal" - we manage, mitigate, reduce the risks (quite successfully, that 30k is down from 40k 10 years ago, and over 50k back in '79 and '80) - then we declare 30 thousand dead people a year an "acceptable cost" for the benefits of private car ownership. Why aren't we able to be that rational about "designer drugs"?
- austerity 12y agoI wish so much to hear at least a semi-coherent response to this from the pro-prohibition crowd.
- saiya-jin 12y agoThe most of pro-prohibition crowds are either not-so-bright people who grab all their wisdom from TV without any proper experience whatsoever beyond alcohol & cigarettes, or law-enforcement-related people. As in many other cases, I believe following money explains it nicely. Ignoring the former redneck case, the rest has actually good bussiness case for latter. Ie legalize weed US nationwide, and many prisons (let's not forget many are private owned by investors, who want only one thign - maximize their profits by having as many inmates as possible), DEA loses maybe 90% of the success claims they have, and maybe local police can have more time dealing with serious issues. For conservative politicians, its political ammo par exellence, since if they will go hardline on drugs, there are very few risks to their career, and they can always claim all the usual stuff (drugs are destroying families and young people, we care about them etc... ever heard that?). Ask yourself - what can a politician gain vs lose bybeing pro-weed in US? Too lazy to look it up, but if I remember correctly that one of DEA chiefs was also head of some UN panel on drugs, which then enforce rules for all UN member states (read whole world maybe except North Korea). From first glance, it might make sense. But show me one career-oriented competitive guy (and being head of such an agency, you have to be at least that, and have a lot of political games skills), who would undermine his own little kingdom, and make his own subordinates lose job by declaring that some of most popular drugs shouldn't be banned. One real example - weed & hashish have thousand years of history in hindu culture (look up shiva day when almost all india is high), yet they had to ban it after they joined UN. So, we can thank those guys for making policies that worldwide raise crime, help supporting organized crime on massive scale (brutal mexical cartels are a fine example, out of many, ie afghanistan) It's like thinking, that in banking/trading/brokering, it's always the client's best interest that's primary drive. Well yes of course, unless the bussiness is funded mainly by operational fees. WHat do those brokers do? Make you do as many operations as possible, of course, without being too obvious :) (*no references here :))
- zo1 12y ago>"I can see your line of thinking: X has risks, X should not be done, thus make X illegal and X will not be done and the risk will no longer exist." I've tried on numerous occasions to debate with individuals that hold such an opinion. Once you point out the obvious error in their reasoning, they quickly move the goal post. It then becomes more about "protecting" productive society, and the slippery slope argument that everyone will devolve into "addicted, unproductive and unhealthy junkies". Making out to seem like we want society to burn and be ruined, when in actual fact we just want to allow individuals to be free to do with their bodies as they please, because there is no moral right by others to prevent them from doing so.