8 ms·
What Students Do (And Don't Do) in Khan Academy
- Spooky23 12y agoReading this article reinforced a perception I walked away with at an event where parents were complaining about common core related topics. The professional educator dialect of English is not very approachable for the layman. To many people it sounds like somebody throwing out $10 words to make the arguments sound more intelligent.
- TillE 12y agoEvery field has its own jargon. It's shorthand for commonly understood ideas that you don't want to waste a paragraph reiterating in common English. Just consider how computer programming talk looks to an outsider.
- jwmerrill 12y ago> The professional educator dialect of English is not very approachable for the layman. I think Dan's blog is largely pitched at other professional educators. All professions develop their own technical vocabulary. As an analogy, I recently enjoyed an article about the implementation of the v8 garbage collector by Jay Conrod: http://jayconrod.com/posts/55/a-tour-of-v8-garbage-collection http://jayconrod.com/posts/55/a-tour-of-v8-garbage-collectio... Here's a sample paragraph: "Distinguishing pointers and data on the heap is the first problem any garbage collector needs to solve. The GC needs to follow pointers in order to discover live objects. Most garbage collection algorithms can migrate objects from one part of memory to another (to reduce fragmentation and increase locality), so we also need to be able to rewrite pointers without disturbing plain old data." I think the article is an excellent piece of technical writing, but it would also be reasonable to say "the professional compiler engineer dialect of English is not very approachable to the layman." That said, good communicators need to be able to change their presentation based on the audience, and it's too bad that the people at the meeting you mention couldn't find a common vocabulary. If you want to see something by the author of this post that is pitched at the layman, he made a very nice TedX presentation a few years ago: http://www.ted.com/talks/dan_meyer_math_curriculum_makeover?language=en#t-202117 http://www.ted.com/talks/dan_meyer_math_curriculum_makeover?...
- Spooky23 12y agoAgreed. I've found that a lot of education officials hide behind that jargon, that's all. Totally get the domain specific jargon. I've seen my wife glaze in about 30s when I start muttering about tech stuff!
- WalterBright 12y ago> "the professional compiler engineer dialect of English is not very approachable to the layman." We compiler guys do that on purpose in order to keep our salaries high!
- VLM 12y agoOne sophistry problem is we will "ALL" theoretically take and pass Algebra, so the teacher does not have the luxury of specialized jargon, the teacher MUST be able to present it to the entire general public. A general education teacher is expected to present effectively to the general public as the core of their job, its not a nice to have or wouldn't it be interesting if it were possible. On the other hand, only maybe 1% of the population has to suffer thru garbage collector theory in CS classes, and of that 1%, maybe only 0.0001% ever implement a GC "in the real world" and can understand that post. There just aren't that many GC programmers and there are a lot of humans in the general public. In that case jargon is perfectly acceptable, even expected. Also the core of a programmers job is rarely making public presentations.
- jwmerrill 12y agoI didn't mean that teachers get a pass on opaque vocabulary when they're teaching students. I meant that, just like every other profession, they have a technical vocabulary that they use to discuss their own profession with other teachers.
- tokenadult 12y agoThe author writes, in the interesting blog post submitted here, "We should wonder why Khan Academy emphasizes this particular work. I have no inside knowledge of Khan Academy’s operations or vision." Actually, here on Hacker News we have had public discussions blessed with direct participation by Khan Academy developers, so I think I have some sense of what Khan Academy intends to do as it continues to develop online lessons. I've even had some off-site email interaction with Khan Academy developers after threads here in which I have "met" them while we discuss our common interest in mathematics education. I certainly hope that Khan Academy staff will join the discussion of this post. The author also writes, "I find it more likely that Khan Academy’s exercise set draws an accurate map of the strengths and weaknesses of education technology in 2014. Khan Academy asks students to solve and calculate so frequently, not because those are the mathematical actions mathematicians and math teachers value most, but because those problems are easy to assign with a computer in 2014." I think this statement is correct. The Khan Academy developers have devoted a lot of thought to how to computerize problems rather than exercises, and they are still working on building new problem types for the mathematics lessons. I'm actually quite impressed with some of the problem types that show up in more advanced mathematics lessons on Khan Academy that go beyond the eighth grade level implied by current United States curriculum standards. But the author's point is well taken that the Common Core, and good mathematics curricula around the world, expect reasoning and explanation from pupils in mathematics lessons already at elementary school age. That currently is indeed difficult to automate. The author's comments on development of Smarter Balanced Assessment (SBC) as a new platform of online mathematics instruction is of course especially interesting. I will be curious to see how this program continues to develop, and I would be glad to hear from developers of that program in this thread too. (Disclosure: I am a teacher of voluntary-participation prealgebra mathematics classes to advanced pupils of third-, fourth-, and fifth-grade age, using the Art of Problem Solving prealgebra textbook by Rusczyk, Patrick, and Boppana as a core text with many supplementary materials from around the world. I do not view Khan Academy as a competitor to my classes, but rather as a helpful supplement for many mathematics learners around the world. My daughter, who is of a younger age than eighth-grade age, is currently doing many of the same Khan Academy lessons as those just reviewed by the blog post author. I recommend Khan Academy to my friends, and it will probably stay in the mix for the mathematics studies of my three minor children for quite a few years yet.)
- iandanforth 12y agoPlease for the love of maths do not "align" with the common core standards. It would be the saddest, most disheartening thing imaginable* for Khan Academy to become a feeder to the American standardized testing system. The author writes: "If one of Khan Academy’s goals is to prepare students for success in Common Core mathematics, they’re emphasizing the wrong set of skills." I would like nothing better than the academy to publicly state this is NOT a goal of theirs. Being good at math and passing math tests are orthogonal* concepts. In my experience teaching to the test is the fastest way to kill the love of any subject because, at the end of the day, the only answer you can give to the question "Why is this important? or "Why should we do it this way?" is "Because the test says so." It's death to independent thought. I don't know who his advisor is but please kill this dissertation before it gets out into the world and he uses it for self promotion on Good Morning America. *intentional hyperbole
- spicyj 12y ago(I work at Khan Academy.) We have no interest in preparing students for tests just for the sake of it, but if you look at the Common Core standards you'll see that they are well thought out (really!) and designing a curriculum around them is a very sensible thing to do. Of course, we won't restrict ourselves to the material covered by the Common Core if/when we feel there are gaps. We're interested in helping students learn to solve problems, not in teaching them how to take tests.
- jacksonaedwards 12y agoKhan Academy is obviously a useful tool for learning, and of course it's part of a child's education, not all of it. The point I think Dan is making is that if you 1. say you're aligned to the common core, and 2. provide mastery statistics to suggest a level of comprehension or depth of knowledge tied to those standards then that should predict well a child's performance answering questions aligned to the standards but outside the KA system (e.g. a Smarter Balanced Assessment) That means until that ideal is reached KA could say "Mastery at X depth of knowledge but note, for this standard Y is required" or allow teachers to write free response questions and have them tag the questions by standard, type, depth of knowledge etc. and grade them by hand in the KA system. Including hand graded questions (by a student's teacher)with an adequate tagging system KA mastery statistics might be significantly more accurate.
- mathu7 12y agoI think all these sites (treehouse, code academy etc) are going to be hit with class action lawsuits for implying that their app/whatever will make you proficient at coding, and even land you a job. There are no shortcuts to becoming good at coding. It takes much longer and is much harder than these sites make it seem.
- mathu7 12y agoyay down-votes. I'm not gonna delete the comment. I'll just make a new account
- 21echoes 12y agoin case you missed why your comment didn't add to the conversation: Khan Academy and the article are both not about coding or learning to code. This article is about math.
- jimmaswell 12y agoKhan Academy did start to include a programming portion at some point.
- 21echoes 12y agoyes, Khan Academy has lessons on a huge number of topics. no, nothing in the posted article has anything to do with "implying that [Khan Academy] will make you proficient at coding"
- Patrick_Devine 12y agoI've noticed with most critiques of KA that they set up a straw man of what KA is trying to accomplish, and then they attack that, almost always without giving a better alternative. The fact is KA is a great tool for learning many subjects, and will only continue to improve. The biggest take aways should be: - spaced repetition of subject matter is extremely useful for long term memorization - bite sized, repeatable lessons allow students to digest more and "rewind" over parts of lectures they may have missed - "gameification" and small rewards are useful for getting students to keep pursuing a subject - students shouldn't move on to more advanced subjects until they've mastered a particular foundational skill No teaching tool or method is going to be perfect, but I think KA gives parents, educators and most importantly students a really useful tool for self-paced learning that traditional methods can't easily offer.
- IndianAstronaut 12y agoIt should be noted that there are huge vested interests who want to tear down Khan academy and similar sites.
- zo1 12y agoWhich "huge vested interests" are you referring to specifically? I can understand that if the Khan academy were to really take off, it'd shake quite a lot of educational institutions. Everything from universities, state-funded schools, teachers unions, the works. And I don't think a lot of them would like that, as I it would appear to the individuals running/manning them that their jobs are on the line. The reason I say state-funded schools wouldn't like this is because they work on a false premise. Supposedly that education is not free/cheap enough, and that government funding is required to make it work for the masses. You take away that, and public/state schools become glorified daycare so that the parents can stay productive instead of having to babysit their offspring. One addition: I've just setup a recurring donation to the Khan academy. One small step at proving that society can function without state-coercion.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- 12y ago
- codingdave 12y agoKhan Academy isn't perfect. But it improves every year. I like it for what it is, and have high hopes for what it might become.
- gravity13 12y agoCan Khan Academy ever become something other than Khan Academy? That's a profound question for me.
- tjl 12y agoWhile I like the idea of Khan Academy, there are problems with some of the contents of the lessons. For example, the lesson on Hooke's Law definitely has issues: http://www.leancrew.com/all-this/2012/12/khan/ http://www.leancrew.com/all-this/2012/12/khan/
- mkramlich 12y agoI visited KA for the first time in a while. It used to drop me into a table of links to videos on various academic topics. Very simple, useful, fast, and the Obviously Right Way (TM) to do it. At least in the default case, and for the casual or first-time visitor. However just now it required me to signup/login. Signing up asked for PII, which is intrusive and strictly unnecessary for letting me see educational videos. I gave a fake email, along with the other fields. It then complained it couldn't send an email to it. When I pressed their button to fix the email address, it then popped up a window for me to enter it, however it was auto-forcing it down into an obviously stupid position such that it was impossible to hit its Submit button. You can enter a new address but not hit Submit because too close to the screen bottom's edge. I love the orig vision, and the core content (Sal's lectures and his style) but looks like they're now falling down at the simple stuff along the edges of the problem space. Failing over inside the unnecessarily added complexity (GUI/JS shenanigans, control fetish, privacy intrusion, etc), rather than in the essential inescapable parts (text, images, embedded canned video, links, curricula design, effective communication, etc.)