3 ms·
Fun, but not as good as the ATC game I know from the bsdgames package in many Linux distributions. This is a lot more graphical but there are a few disadvantage
by lucb1e 12y ago
Fun, but not as good as the ATC game I know from the bsdgames package in many Linux distributions. This is a lot more graphical but there are a few disadvantages, mostly regarding input:
- Callsigns are long. In, let's call it bsdgames ATC, you have to type only one letter to indicate an aircraft. When Z is reached, you've long cleared A so the letter can be reused. This is more realistic though, I guess.
- It is not clear to me what an aircraft wants. Do all the flying ones want to land and all the landed ones to fly? Because in bsdgames ATC they each have a destination.
- The locations on the map (where you can fix an aircraft on, the triangles) are small and you have to properly look to make sure you typed it correctly. There is no highlighting like for planes.
- Runways are even harder to read. Here too there is no highlighting like for planes.
- You cannot send, as bsdgames ATC calls it, delayed commands (e.g. "N926JW fix QUITE then turn 0").
- You can not set an aircraft in "ignore mode", or otherwise mark it as "I have finished giving it directions".
- There is no command autocompletion. In bsdgames ATC you type "atdab0" to indicate "plane A, Turn to direction D (90 degrees) At Beacon 0." Or as the game displays it while you type the letters: "a: turn to 90 at beacon #0". After typing every letter, the game will display the next word to indicate it understood. (E.g. typing "at" it will display "a: turn to" and "atda" displays "a: turn to 90 at".)
There are a few things I really like though:
- The score system makes it not immediately 'game over' when you make a single simple mistake.
- It not only looks more modern, but because it's graphical and not ASCII there is a lot more space on the map to maneuver (at least it looks like that, maybe there are simply more planes). It also gives way more space for fix locations (triangles).
- Either this is common for ATC systems, or it looks like the good old bsdgames ATC. I like that it is a modern version which, with rather minor improvements, is better than the original.
- zlsa 12y agoAuthor here. - I wanted to be a realistic as possible, hence the long callsigns. However, all you have to type is the shortest unique callsign and that aircraft will be selected. - If the aircraft has a red strip, it wants to land; if it's blue, it wants to takeoff and depart the area. - The fix names are now bigger. - The runway names are bigger. I'll make them more obvious, too. - You cannot send delayed commands, just like real life. - You can type "baw1234 tu 90 d 3 sp 2"; like callsigns, you only have to type the unique first few characters of the commands.
- lucb1e 12y agoThanks for the reply. Perhaps my comment sounded a bit too much like negative criticism, it wasn't meant that way. Re:re: - "cannot send delayed commands, just like real life". It's not standard to tell pilots to fly a certain path, e.g. to a point and then head south? (I'm not sure, that's why I ask.) - "shortest unique callsign" Yeah well, it might help to always make the first two or three characters unique, then you can be certain it always works without having to check the list. Realism is kept that way. - "you only have to type the unique first few characters of the commands" Yes, but it doesn't autocomplete while typing. Though I guess learning those abbreviations might be part of the game. In any case, thanks for making this. I've already mentioned some good points so I won't repeat myself :)
- 0xffff2 12y ago> Yeah well, it might help to always make the first two or three characters unique, then you can be certain it always works without having to check the list. Realism is kept that way. Unfortunately these two are fundamentally at odds. In real life the call signs are based on carrier (or tail number if no call sign is assigned). In the current iteration, there are two airlines, United (all of the UAL flights) and British Airways (all of the BWA flights), plus the Cessna "airline" that mimics general aviation craft by prefixing the call sign with "N".