3 ms·
It's an interesting macro-scale analogy. You can demonstrate interference in a double-slit experiment with oil drop. But look what the article leaves out: You
by Zigurd 12y ago
It's an interesting macro-scale analogy. You can demonstrate interference in a double-slit experiment with oil drop.
But look what the article leaves out: You can't, as far as I can tell from the article, demonstrate the collapse effect of detecting which slit the particle passes through. In fact, you can always observe which slit the particle passes through, so measurement has no effect on the wave interference pattern.
If there is a "pilot wave" version of quantum mechanics, these experiments are only a suggestion of some of the mathematics. They appear not to be a macro-scale example.
- snarfy 12y ago> And just as measuring the trajectories of particles seems to “collapse” their simultaneous realities, disturbing the pilot wave in the bouncing-droplet experiment destroys the interference pattern. Did we read the same article? Pilot wave theory has the same mathematics as quantum mechanics. It's a different interpretation of those mathematics - the probability wave is real and physical.
- Zigurd 12y agoI read that. Note that it says "disturbing the pilot wave." That's not "measuring." The sentence is trying to draw an analogy with "collapse." But to do that you have to explicitly "disturb" the pilot wave. In these droplet experiments, you can measure all you want without affecting the wave and the interference pattern. This might point to an analogous form of quantum mechanics. But it also could be just an interesting but incomplete analogy in classical physics.
- snarfy 12y agoIt's akin to weak measurement - we can measure which slit the particle goes through without disturbing the interference pattern. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Weak_measurement http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Weak_measurement
- Zigurd 12y agoI'm not seeing how that is so. You can measure every aspect of the oil drop at every point along the path it takes, before and after and as is passes through the slits and it won't do a darn thing to the pilot wave and the interference pattern. The ability to measure is 100% classical 100% of the time.
- MacsHeadroom 12y agoWe can measure every aspect of the oil droplet because we're measuring it with trillions upon trillions of infinitely smaller and faster photons which give us a great insight without disturbing the structure. What would we bounce off of photons to get an equally accurate picture without disturbing them? The analogy isn't a problem. The fact that there's nothing small enough to observe photons like we can observe the oil is a problem, but it says nothing about the integrity of the analogy. In the analogy the water is space-time, meaning "observing" the droplet like we observe photons would require shooting another droplet past or into the first droplet.
- morpher 12y agoI agree with your first two paragraphs. But, be careful about the last. The pilot wave in Bohmian mechanics is not a wave in space time, but rather a separate physical entity. Basically the dynamics of both the particle and its pilot wave are described by different portions of the wavefunction. (The wavefunction is complex, and so has enough variables to describe two physical quantities).
- shoegumfoot 12y ago> In fact, you can always observe which slit the particle passes through, so measurement has no effect on the wave interference pattern. The first half of that sentence is true, while the second half is not (unless I am misinterpreting what you are trying to say). Empirically, nobody has (yet) managed to come up with an experiment that measures which slit the photon/electron/other quantum object passes through AND preserves the wave nature of the double-slit effect. In other words, when you set up an experiment to measure which slit is traversed, the characteristic double-slit interference pattern disappears. Again, I'm talking about this purely in practice, or what people observe when they try to perform this experiment[1]. Theoretically, this is result is completely expected. To determine which slit the photon traversed, you must interact with the photon to observe it. Any observation has two results: First, you know the state of the quantum object. Second, the quantum object is in an eigenstate of whatever operator you used to observe it. Since you have forced the photon into an eigenstate, the interference pattern disappears. [1] Not that you can still see two superimposed single-slit interference patterns, which might confuse some people into thinking they are seeing a double-slit pattern.