5 ms·
> Prosecuting those who committed illegal acts, even though they were assured of immunity, sends a clear message that individuals are still responsible for the
by justin66 12y ago
> Prosecuting those who committed illegal acts, even though they were assured of immunity, sends a clear message that individuals are still responsible for their actions.
They weren't really offered immunity, they were assured by the Office of Legal Counsel that they were doing something legal. Get bad advice from your lawyer as to what is legal and what isn't, go commit a crime, and see what happens.
- probably_wrong 12y agoFor a counterpoint, you might want to look into Argentina's "Law of due obedience"[1]. Of course, Argentinean law doesn't affect US law, but the fact that this law was eventually repealed sets an international precedent that "I was just following orders" is not a valid defense from prosecution. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ley_de_Obediencia_Debida https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ley_de_Obediencia_Debida
- claudius 12y ago"I was just following orders" has already been established as an insufficient defense in the 1946 Nuremberg trials and essentially all later trials against WW 2 war criminals. It is by now pretty well established that crimes against humanity in general and torture in particular are not justifiable.
- pmoriarty 12y agoThis (along with striving to get good PR) is one of the main reasons the US government is so keen to redefine the word "torture" to mean something that they don't do. The same goes for the words "terrorism" and "terror". "Shock and awe" == good "Terror" == bad "Torture" == illegal "Stress position" == legal decapitation with a knife == horrific and evil decapitation by shrapnel == worthy of a medal assassination by the American govt == good assassination by other governments == bad killing by poison gas on the battlefield == bad killing by poison injections in a prison == good
- TylerJay 12y agoWhat about when it is combined with duress? Like if you refused once and were told they would kill your family if you ever refused again or quit? I'm just curious. I agree with the spirit of the idea that following orders is not valid justification, but being under duress is a well-known and generally accepted justification for committing a crime. Can you shed any extra light on this?
- cabalamat 12y ago> being under duress is a well-known and generally accepted justification for committing a crime In what jurisdiction? duress (or necessity in general) is only rarely a valid defence in English law.
- justin66 12y agoWar criminals who would have been shot for abandoning their posts (almost all of the low-level guys fall into that category) have been, and continue to be, prosecuted for those crimes. It's not a hypothetical, it's still in the news. http://www.cnn.com/2014/07/23/justice/nazi-charge-philadelphia-man/ http://www.cnn.com/2014/07/23/justice/nazi-charge-philadelph...
- nraynaud 12y agoYes, there is no amnesty for human right crimes, that means those people were only protected inside Argentina. And the Nuremberg defense doesn't work against the Nuremberg laws. On a side note, it was not exactly repealed, because you can't repeal an amnesty (ie voting a new law that removes it). They found that its creation was unconstitutional, meaning that it was void from the onset, like it had never happened. Learning about those 2 laws (+ley de pounto final for the ones giving the orders) when I was in Argentina was extremely formative on a law doctrine point of view.
- sseveran 12y agoIf you are an agent working in a black operation you by definition cannot talk to a lawyer.
- bradleyjg 12y ago> Get bad advice from your lawyer as to what is legal and what isn't, go commit a crime, and see what happens. I should start out by saying that I hope the torturers, their superiors, and enablers are prosecuted by anyone that can get their hands on them: a future US administration, the ICC, a European nation, anyone. That said the US legal analysis is very tough. The lawyers they were given "bad" advice by weren't just lawyer, they were representatives of the sovereign that would seek to prosecute them. That raises due process concerns that aren't present in an ordinary advice-of-counsel defense. In addition to Constitutional problems, the Detainee Treatment Act of 2005 and Military Commissions Act of 2006 create statutory defenses for torturers. The key language is "it shall be a defense that such officer, employee, member of the Armed Forces, or other agent did not know that the practices were unlawful and a person of ordinary sense and understanding would not know the practices were unlawful. Good faith reliance on advice of counsel should be an important factor, among others, to consider in assessing whether a person of ordinary sense and understanding would have known the practices to be unlawful." To be sure, that's not a unlimited immunity provision, but it does make prosecution more difficult. The Military Commissions Act also changed the substantive provisions 18 U.S. Code § 2441 (war crimes) to make much less conduct qualify. Finally, except in cases where torture resulted in death, there are statute of limitation problems. Depending on which statute is use the limitation period for non-fatal torture or war crimes generally are either five or eight years. In sum, there are many barriers to US prosecution. It may be much more practical for the wrongdoers to be prosecuted under the international law regime that began at Nuremberg. Given universal jurisdiction for violations of jus cogens this can happen in any country in the world, and there is no statute of limitations doctrine internationally.
- justin66 12y agoGood point about the Detainee Treatment Act of 2005 and Military Commissions Act of 2006. I'm not so sure about the good faith reliance on advice of counsel thing, however, for the obvious reasons. The torturers and the OLC are part of the same chain of command... As a practical matter I don't currently see the political will for prosecutions. If the public demanded it, maybe, but frankly I think a lot of the public feels complicit, in many cases unapologetically so. That all makes me very sad and I do hope these people start slipping up and travelling overseas...