3 ms·
I wish SoundCloud wouldn't transcode anything it gets into MP3 for playback. It ruins the quality. Yeah, they let you download the original, but playback throug
by shmerl 12y ago
I wish SoundCloud wouldn't transcode anything it gets into MP3 for playback. It ruins the quality. Yeah, they let you download the original, but playback through the site suffers if you upload Ogg/Vorbis for example. At least they could provide playback in original form to browsers which support it, and use MP3 as fallback for more crippled ones (like Safari or IE). Since they obviously host the original and transcoded file it shouldn't be hard to do.
Also, Opus support could be useful.
- pcthrowaway 12y agoI'm not sure what bitrate they use, but if it's 128kbps+ the difference in quality should be small to nonexistent.
- shmerl 12y agoOnce you encode lossy from lossy (even with high bitrate) the quality will be degraded in some way.
- pcthrowaway 12y agoAh, you mean if the source files are already compressed they get transcoded to mp3, which degrades them more.. gotcha. I assumed most musicians would have the sense to upload an uncompressed format.
- shmerl 12y agoYes, but there are cases when the only source is already lossy.
- coldtea 12y ago>but playback through the site suffers if you upload Ogg/Vorbis for example Who would use Ogg/Vorbis and not expect compatibility issues with third party services and products? It's not like Ogg/Vorbis was ever anything more than a solution in search of a problem that only few idealists adopted.
- Shebanator 12y agoAnd audiophile idealists should be using flac anyhow, in which case the conversion to mp3 wouldn't be causing any major issues (obviously mp3 encoding itself causes some lossiness, but it isn't nearly as bad as lossy->lossy)
- shmerl 12y ago> Who would use Ogg/Vorbis and not expect compatibility issues with third party services and products? It doesn't matter who, if the only thing you got is Ogg/Vorbis file and you have no lossless original. Normal browsers support it anyway, as well as Opus. Ogg/Vorbis was a solution to patents sick MP3. It was adopted rather well, except for those who can't stand not patent encumbered codecs (Apple for instance). Opus is in better position though, since it's part of WebRTC standard and Apple will have to support it even if they hate the idea.