4 ms·
Humans evolving to escape from bacterial iron piracy
- ars 12y agoSounds like TbpA would make an excellent target for an antibiotic.
- hga 12y agoNot necessarily. The one bit of actual research I was able to do (in the late '70s) was in a lab that had serendipitously discovered a new iron scavenging mechanism in E. Coli. If you put it in a sufficiently iron poor environment (e.g. all the glassware was treated with HCL and then bathed for days in deionized water) it would synthesize a previously unknown iron binding protein and grab what it could. So we shouldn't assume this is the only way many bacteria can get iron, but it's perhaps worth checking out. And a focus on iron in general might be a fruitful approach.
- teddyh 12y agoIt annoys me when people try to look intelligent by inserting literary references without actually knowing what they are talking about, either by not remembering nor bothering to look it up, or never having read it in the first place, simply guessing and make stuff up. Any one of them are by themselves indicators of poor journalistic practice. What else did the article’s author not check or simply make up? > Alice Liddell first encounters the Red Queen in Chapter 2 of Through the Looking Glass. Alice tries to catch her, but although they each run faster and faster, neither of them ever gets anywhere. Although the writer of the article specifically references chapter 2, they obviously did not read it, nor even glance at the illustrations. 1. The character in the book is only ever named as “Alice”. The real person which the author knew, and on which the character “Alice” is based, was indeed named “Alice Liddell”, but they are not one and the same. 2. Alice does not try to “catch” the Red Queen. In fact, Alice and the Queen are running hand in hand, and it is the Red Queen which urges Alice to go “Faster! Faster!”. The accompanying illustration shows the Red Queen running and holding Alice’s hand, dragging her behind her since Alice has trouble keeping up.
- magicalist 12y ago> It annoys me when people try to look intelligent by inserting literary references Besides the old middlebrow dismissal question you should be asking yourself before posting ("is that the most interesting thing one can say about this article?"[1]), let me ask you this: is the distinction you're making here at all material to the article? Did you consider the possibility that the author hasn't read Through the Looking-Glass in a while (a "Ph.D. in Cell Biology and Genetics" means you have to put off a good bit of recreational reading for a number of years) and thought that the explanation was close enough as background information about why a 40-year-old, fairly famous evolutionary theory is named the way it was? And again I'll ask: do either of the author's two mortal sins you've pointed out in any way change the aptness of the metaphor or give the audience an incorrect impression of why it was named the way it was? Because I'm pretty sure they don't. Sorry if I'm a little heated, but you might say it annoys me when people try to look intelligent by dismissing interesting things by nitpicking irrelevant details. Or maybe we shouldn't assume people's motives ("try to look intelligent"? seriously?), grant a little principle of charity, leave a correction for the author, and then engage in actually interesting conversation. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4693920 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4693920
- pcthrowaway 12y agoI think it's a fair criticism to point out a fault in an author's literary reference, when that reference is used as a metaphor for something else in the article. For example, if I were to use a sour grapes analogy to explain how compression optimizations beyond a certain point are not worth the effort, because the gains decrease as the difficulty increases exponentially, that would ignore the point of the fable, which doesn't tell a story of a fox that realizes the grapes higher up are not as good as the ones lower on the tree; rather, he decides the grapes he can't reach must be sour. Misremembering the story you are using to help explain a concept can serve to confuse people who use that association as a 'hook' to remember how that concept works later.
- magicalist 12y agoIt's not the author's analogy. The article is referencing a concept named the Red Queen hypothesis[1], and the only thing that's material to the explanation is the phrase "Now here, you see, it takes all the running you can do, to keep in the same place" as that's literally the only Carroll in the original paper[2]. Nor is it being used to explain a concept. Not only is the entire rest of article being used to explain this particular instance of the concept, the very next sentence gives a simplified explanation of the Red Queen hypothesis without analogy. The "literary reference" is not a literary reference at all. It's pointing out that Van Valen was making a literary reference by choosing that name. And it's still not misleading. The difference between "Alice Liddell" vs "Alice" and "catch" vs not caching might be correct vs incorrect, but it still has nothing to do with the reason the hypothesis is named as it is. "They must run and run just to stay where they are." is right in there. Finally, on a meta note, this is exactly the kind of thread asking oneself "is that the most interesting thing one can say about this article?" can avoid, because it isn't. Luckily there are some biologists in the article's comments on Ars to save the day (though you have to wade through some noise first), if anyone's interested in more. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_Queen_hypothesis http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_Queen_hypothesis [2] http://ebme.marine.rutgers.edu/HistoryEarthSystems/HistEarthSystems_Fall2010/VanValen%201973%20Evol%20%20Theor%20.pdf http://ebme.marine.rutgers.edu/HistoryEarthSystems/HistEarth...