4 ms·
A VC's take on Paying to Pitch
- philk 17y agoThe ability (and willingness) to pay to pitch to angel investors is a filter of a kind, but it's selecting for traits that you don't want in startup founders: 1) An inability to network and sell - if they can't get to see angel investors without ponying up cash, how on earth are they going to get customers? 2) A willingness to spend what is (at the time) a large portion of their capital on something that isn't necessary. By definition if you're looking for angel investment you aren't flush with cash and some of the amounts listed (up to 10K), are substantial amounts of money to waste. 3) An inability to understand the role of incentives in human behavior, specifically, if the angels they're pitching to are being paid then they're more likely to be interested in listening (and getting money for doing so) than actually investing. Essentially these people are paying money to overcome their lack of entrepreneurial ability. Why any serious angel would view these as better candidates for investment is beyond me.
- smikhanov 17y agoBecause there are top-notch angels that get all the best deals with the best entrepreneurs. I guess there are plenty of other millionaires in the Valley looking for (reasonably) good investment in the tech field, but they can't write "Hackers and Painters", and they can't understand hackers that good because they made their fortune in a hedge fund. "Lack of entrepreneural ability" may actually turn to be a provincial naïvety (think of wannabe-entrepreneur from North Dakota who just came in Valley), and is not usually a sign of certain failure. [EDIT] PG also has an essay on this somewhere.
- julien 17y agoI mainly agree with the article and you. Yet, I cant help but think that the VC/angels market is NOT perfect, in a sense that not all the best project get financed by the best angels. So forum like these still need to exist. However, their business model must change.
- jacquesm 17y agoIndeed, it is a filter of sorts. It filters out the bad VCs and angels, those that wanted to make money OFF the startups in stead of together with.
- Luyt 17y ago(Also posted in another thread) This sounds a bit like the "Own your own business" scams. http://skeptoid.com/episodes/4095 http://skeptoid.com/episodes/4095
- heyrhett 17y agoI recently saw an angel investors club in Austin Tx give a talk. They require a fee of $500 to give a pitch, but the attitude of the angels was much more offensive to me than charging startups to pitch. This is how they said it works: Every few months they hear 5-minute pitches from 40 or so companies, and narrow it down to 5 on a whim. Those 5 get to come back and give 1/2 hour pitches, and then they pick 1-2. They told us not to worry if we don't make the top 5 since they don't really think that hard about who should make the top 5 anyway. What's funny is that their investment size is typically around $100k. If they make $500 each from 40 pitches, that's $20k, or 20% of their investment. These guys were all the same kinds of guys who were bullies in high school, and this is just a way that they can keep bullying nerds. They're not really really trying to make tons of money off of these fees though. Keep in mind, in their world, everything costs a lot. It costs them $20k per year to join the country club, etc., so they just expect that people should always pay a lot of money to impress other people. Their angel investor club probably spends as much money on parties and other stupid shit as they do on actual investments. Anyway, to me, the biggest turnoff was not the actual fee, but the whole process used by this particular angel organization.
- sachinag 17y agoIf this is true, then you should really publicly out them. I don't get why on earth you would "protect the innocent". If we're all in this together, then we need to alert each other - as loudly as we can - when we see things that aren't right.
- heyrhett 17y agoIt was these guys: http://www.centraltexasangelnetwork.com http://www.centraltexasangelnetwork.com Their pdf says you get a 10 minute pitch, maybe that's right instead of the 5 minutes I rememembered: http://www.centraltexasangelnetwork.com/Resources/CTAN_Funding_Process.pdf http://www.centraltexasangelnetwork.com/Resources/CTAN_Fundi...
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]