4 ms·
I share deep concern about police militarization and police brutality. These problems have been raised for years, particularly in the context of War on Drugs, b
by smsm42 12y ago
I share deep concern about police militarization and police brutality. These problems have been raised for years, particularly in the context of War on Drugs, but also in larger context of alienation of population from the government, and were largely ignored by the wide public, happy to be "tough on crime" and laughing at those libertarian idiots with their obviously exaggerated concerns. It is good thing that the topic finally starts to enter the public conscience and that people start to realize there should be strict limits to government power in general and the police power as the most frequently encountered one in particular. I share the sentiment expressed here: http://esr.ibiblio.org/?p=6557 http://esr.ibiblio.org/?p=6557 about the deep problems that exist and I think it's good people start to realize these problems exist. I think also here: http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/12/03/framing-for-light-instead-of-heat/ http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/12/03/framing-for-light-inste... it outlines some of the problems people need to be aware of when looking for solutions.
But when I read recent reports about arson, looting, windows smashed, trash cans overturned and lit on fire, businesses destroyed, police officers assaulted with rocks, explosives and firebombs, millions of damages caused, when I read about "burn that bitch down" - I think maybe this particular instance is not what I want to be part of at all. Maybe associating with this wouldn't do as much to combat either public perception of police needing to be tough or any particular prejudices.
And then I read something like this: http://reason.com/blog/2014/12/10/a-college-president-had-to-apologize-for http://reason.com/blog/2014/12/10/a-college-president-had-to... and this https://twitter.com/onekade/status/543202210516303872/photo/1 https://twitter.com/onekade/status/543202210516303872/photo/...
and honestly, I don't know what to think.
- Xeoncross 12y agoEvery time there is a legitimate concern about a possible current/future problem, it seems something happens to either dismiss - or divide those against it. It's really an interesting phenomenon. Most people believe truth is relative though, so I guess it's not logically surprising that there is no consensus.
- smsm42 12y agoI'm not sure what "the truth is relative" means. Do you claim that some event may have happened or not happened depending on your point of view - I mean, really happened or not happened, not just our knowledge of it could be possibly wrong or incomplete? I'd say "citation needed" on the claim that most people believe in such thing.
- sowhatquestion 12y ago"All lives matter" sounds a little different when you consider it in context: http://chainsawsuit.com/comic/2014/12/08/all-things-considered/ http://chainsawsuit.com/comic/2014/12/08/all-things-consider...
- smsm42 12y agoThat picture illustrates somebody putting water not on "all" houses but on one house - that does not appear to be burning (while attributing to the imaginary opponent the exceptionally stupid strawman argument of "we should always care about everything equally", which nobody ever has made) The implication to the current situation would be that somebody claims only non-black lives matter while the problem - I take the problem to be police brutality in general, or underlying causes of it, whatever you consider them be, since in the specific instances it is too late to do anything to prevent it, and as such can not be represented as "putting water on the fire" - does not happen exactly to such people. I do not think this is an adequate representation of the issue (see ESR link for more on that). But, the exclusivity is not the largest problem - I get the event-reaction pattern and the fact that specific instance can represent larger issue (even though I disagree with what exactly the large issue is). The violence is what I have the most problem with.
- king_jester 12y ago> But when I read recent reports about arson, looting, windows smashed, trash cans overturned and lit on fire, businesses destroyed, police officers assaulted with rocks, explosives and firebombs, millions of damages caused, when I read about "burn that bitch down" - I think maybe this particular instance is not what I want to be part of at all. Maybe associating with this wouldn't do as much to combat either public perception of police needing to be tough or any particular prejudices. If you really were deeply concerned about police brutality and its disproportionate application against black people, then you would wholly understand that and outburst of anger and violence is a likely reaction when people are pushed to their limit. The current wave of protests are not those riots, they are organized action to protest this reality. Moreover, your approval means nothing while those lives are still destroyed and dominated by unjust systems and institutions.
- smsm42 12y agoMaybe understand - as I can to some measure understand somebody who was abused as a child, grew up as a violent adult and finally when insulted by somebody strikes out and kills him - but certainly not excuse or support. Even this understanding is somewhat strained - so the problem is police thinks they should be extremely tough to citizens and always suspect they are violent and up to no good - and to prove them wrong, lets burn our city down, destroy local businesses and pelt the police with rocks and firebombs? Then, surely, they'd know the errors of their ways and learn to treat us as responsible non-violent law-abiding citizens that we are. Does it sound like something that makes sense to you? >>> The current wave of protests are not those riots This was this monday: http://www.foxnews.com/us/2014/12/08/violence-erupts-at-berkeley-protest-for-second-straight-night/ http://www.foxnews.com/us/2014/12/08/violence-erupts-at-berk... I have doubts the same people have changed in a week and would be completely benign now. >>> Moreover, your approval means nothing while those lives are still destroyed and dominated by unjust systems and institutions. It is true, that my approval means nothing to them. I'm just explaining why myself - and I suspect, many others - while supporting the overall goal of lowering police brutality - and actually having been supporting it way before current events - would not take part in these protests, as the top comment suggested. I think it is still relevant to the discussion. >>> while those lives are still destroyed and dominated by unjust systems and institutions. If you want to convince the silent majority the police is going too far and ends up hurting innocent people (or hurting not-so-innocent people way more than it is acceptable), making their TV show them pictures of fires, destruction and general mayhem may be not the most effective way to achieve it.
- peterfirefly 12y agoI don't understand why you were downvoted. Can somebody (preferably a downvoter) explain it to me?