4 ms·
> Artists literally have to beg publicly for money, to resort to what amounts to a medieval patronage scheme, just to survive at all, all because the audience h
by dnautics 12y ago
> Artists literally have to beg publicly for money, to resort to what amounts to a medieval patronage scheme, just to survive at all, all because the audience has simply decided en masse that the value of all creative work is effectively zero.
What is the alternative for 'begging'? That's a loaded term for what could be considered 'advertising' or 'self-promotion' instead. Do you suppose artists are entitled to cash that falls out of the sky proportional to the effort they put it? Where, then, would be the accountability that what they do is actually valuable to someone? Would you rather art be funded through a government grant system, where people are "begging" and dissembling and using political connections to get their money?
Don't confuse value with price. The price is zero because the supply is incredibly high. Partly because the tools have been democratized; it's easy to pick up a guitar and start playing, or a digital camera and start snapping pictures.
- waterlesscloud 12y agoI think if you want something an artists produces, you should be willing to pay for it. If it's not worth paying for, so be it. Just don't take it anyway. That's all artists want. It's not the least bit unreasonable of them.
- coldtea 12y ago>Do you suppose artists are entitled to cash that falls out of the sky proportional to the effort they put it? No, I just suppose that artists are entitled to us paying their asking price for what they offer -- or not getting it at all, if you can't be bothered with paying. Or, to put it in another way, it's the consumer that is NOT entitled to free art when that art is put up on sale by its creators.
- anon4 12y agoBut if the consumer can't choose their price, then the market can't work. Usually you have choice between nearly-equivalent alternatives at different prices with more or less bells-and-whistles. But with art, a nearly-equivalent alternative violates copyright, so you can't choose a cheaper alternative, because there isn't one. Because everybody else is banned from selling one. The answer can't be anarchy obviously, but it also can't be installing spyware on every device to stop copying. The larger public has shown that they're absolutely willing to throw every single artist under the bus in order to free themselves from the shackles of copyright. The intersection of art and business is somewhat really weird. You're making something whose entire reason for existing is making people feel nice in some way, but it's never an actual physical product like a bar of chocolate. It's an experience. Depending on who you ask, that is either the most important product of civilization, or some useless baggage tying up useful hands. You need to make the former group pay you money. Fortunately, people understand that things cost money and should be willing to pay you a reasonable price. Unfortunately, most middle-class and above people fall in the latter camp, so most of your fans will be poor and for them a reasonable price might be less than what you want to get. Personally, I have never paid more than twenty bucks for a game.
- coldtea 12y ago>But if the consumer can't choose their price, then the market can't work. Well, who said it has to work as a competitive free market merely for any particular and very specific album/song, instead of at the genre level? Besides, buying it at the artist's asking price has worked for 8+ decades -- for as long as there were physical media.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> But if the consumer can't choose their price, then the market can't work. Usually you have choice between nearly-equivalent alternatives at different prices with more or less bells-and-whistles. Actually, unless you have competing sources of near substitutes, a market can't work (or at least have the properties that are held to make a market ideal) period; allowing purchasers to set prices against the wishes of sellers doesn't solve this problem, it just changes the details of the failure. To the extent that works of art are not easily substituted commodities, they simply do not support an ideal market. > But with art, a nearly-equivalent alternative violates copyright No, it doesn't, unless its actually derivative. Copyright protects against copying, not coincidence.
- jarcane 12y agoI should not here: I was not using that term to be derisive, though many others have used it in that sense when targeting Patreon in particular. I actually have seriously considered a Patreon project myself, and I've crowdfunded multiple books, so I've no mean view of it personally, only of a society that has made such things necessary. And indeed, Patreon is a good example of the same principle: KS and Patreon creators get no end of shit on, often worst of all from their own fans and even paid supporters. You are demonized for asking for money, and then demonized for not offering more than you can afford for that money, demonized for not being transparent enough, picked apart and demonized for what figures you do release, and then further demonized for failing to live up to that expectation on release.