4 ms·
This is why virtually every small-time musician I ever spoke to called for some sort of unobtrusive, universal DRM -- and if you care about music, you should to
by bitwize 12y ago
This is why virtually every small-time musician I ever spoke to called for some sort of unobtrusive, universal DRM -- and if you care about music, you should too.
- nkurz 12y agoI think this is a matter of perception. I feel like I've known quite a few small-time musicians, and I think I've only heard one express a desire for better DRM. Obviously there are more, since presumably you and the people you know are examples, but I don't think those who desire better DRM are anywhere close to a majority. If anything, as stereotypical lower-income music lovers I find the minority who are familiar with the DRM express a desire (right or wrong) for greater access to free or low priced music, both for themselves and others worldwide. The general desire is to increase the ease with with those who love music can access it. Many wouldn't object to better DRM (if they knew what it was) but the emphasis would be on better modes of distribution with less economic discrimination.
- _almosnow 12y agoI don't see the reason for the downvotes. Maybe because "DRM is bad". But I agree with you, there has to be an open dialog about a way to control (yes, orwell-lovers, CONTROL) the way intellectual property gets shared on the internet. The internet may (and should) be free but that doesn't mean that you should be free to do whatever you want in it; just as the guarantee of being free in the real world doesn't entitles you with the right to go kill or steal from someone else.
- smosher_ 12y ago> > called for some sort of unobtrusive, universal DRM -- and if you care about music, you should too > I don't see the reason for the downvotes. Perhaps because this reads like "you have to want DRM if you care about music" with no supporting argument. I don't believe profit is the best motivator for artists and much of the music I listen to (and all of the music I make) is made by unpaid producers. With that point of view DRM is entirely uncalled for. I'm not trying to argue that point of view here, just presenting it as a contrast to reveal the hidden assumptions in the assertion made above.
- bitwize 12y agoProfit is an immensely powerful motivator up to a point. Being able to put food on your and your kids' table with your music will enable you to create MUCH more music than you otherwise would be able to.
- smosher_ 12y agoThat is true but my point is: that's not the whole story. There are other solutions to be discussed. The point I'm making is that there is a way to care about music where DRM is entirely valueless. I'm not saying you need to have to agree with my personal position on DRM or on music, but don't tell me I have to like DRM on flimsy circular grounds.
- _almosnow 12y ago>I don't believe profit is the best motivator for artists ... Then we don't live even in the same world. By taking into account how much people has the economical means to just "make music for the sake of it", I'd believe that a very small proportion of all artists actually don't seek profit for their work. That aside, I believe that the right to defend your intellectual property is of extreme importance and the digital counterpart to ensure that right is, guess what?, DRM. If your platform (i.e. the internet) does not give you a way to protect intellectual property then creators will eventually dissapear or move somewhere else; you can't expect to just get things from some place and never put something in return for that, a system needs to be sustainable in order to exist by itself. DRM tries to make the overall creator/consumer ecosystem more sustainable, and there's nothing wrong with that. That is the supporting argument behind "you have to want DRM if you care about music".
- eropple 12y agoAny time some selfish jerk (and you are definitionally a selfish jerk if you happily claim that profit isn't the best motivator for artists) comes round on this topic, I always link Ryan Estrada's amazing Twitter: https://twitter.com/forexposure_txt https://twitter.com/forexposure_txt Not down with DRM in the slightest, though, but that's because it doesn't work. Even the first-run benefits of it for big companies doesn't exist for the long-tail market of indies. You're very off-base and you're advocating a path that only hurts people.
- imaginenore 12y agoAnd it's stupid. It won't stop your art from being pirated. It will only make the lives of your legitimate customers more difficult.
- tunesmith 12y agoI've always thought that a short-sighted argument. DRM and piracy have different effects at different popularity levels.
- coldtea 12y agoI don't know. I've seen DRM that has never been cracked for quite popular software. Propellerheads Reason for one.
- eropple 12y agoReason 6 hasn't been cracked because it uses a physical dongle. My understanding is that Reason 7, with the new system not using the Ignition Key, has been cracked.
- bitwize 12y agoNotator for Atari ST has never been cracked either. Its primary author, Dr. Gerhard Lengeling, is a multitalented genius who spent as much time on the copy protection scheme as he did on the software itself. Some people really want to be paid for their work.
- bitwize 12y agoDRM is effective because while it doesn't prevent piracy, it hinders it, making paying for the work the most attractive way of getting it for many consumers. If DRM can be made unobtrusive enough to make the hindrance of piracy much, much greater than the hindrance of DRM for the vast majority of consumers, it is a net win for artists, distributors, and ultimately consumers. Anti-DRM sentiment is often repeated blindly by pirates and neckbeards ("but muh software freedoms!") but when looked at economically, it makes all kinds of sense.
- vilhelm_s 12y agoI'd much rather people stopped making music than they stopped making DRM-free computers. I care a little bit about music, but I care about computers more.
- wwweston 12y agoDRM probably isn't necessary. We mostly need a legal and cultural structure that recognizes you should pay for recordings (and outlets that let you do so easily). There'd be some leakage (as there's been as long as there's been consumer recording tech), but people know the difference between participatory patronage and mooching, the market would provide a way to choose and do both. And perhaps the biggest threat to this is buffet streaming services like Spotify, which give the veneer of legitimate participation and remove incentives to buy, but reduce the remittance to artists to a vanishing fraction of what recording purchases can provide.