3 ms·
My statement was totally fair. I'd rather you reply to the core point then 6 replies about how FICA is paid. I don't want to argue the mechanics of taxation on
by zaroth 12y ago
My statement was totally fair. I'd rather you reply to the core point then 6 replies about how FICA is paid.
I don't want to argue the mechanics of taxation on W-2 vs 1099! I was totally happy to accept 'danans' much more conservative numbers because we still end up with a maximum of $35,000 net benefit from $115,300 of compensation!
This is, with danans math, which is adjusted from mine by not even counting;
Employer portion of health care cost
Employer share of FICA
Excluding direct employment costs
Excluding indirect opportunity cost
Use average disability payment, instead of max
Exclude SSI payments
Exclude rent control
Exclude property tax circuit breakers (21 states, not CA)
Exclude EITC
If my point still stands after all those are ignored, I think we can stop arguing the mechanics of FICA and realize there's a huge fucking social service+taxation problem in this country, so big that at many points of the curve from $0 - $150k, almost across that entire curve, earning more, earns you less.
Like I said, the only way to properly calculate all this is to code it all up and chart it. But the laws are insanely complex (we've proven that just now, right?) I don't think anyone has ever tried.
- dragonwriter 12y agoYour core point is entirely dependent on the relation of additional income to additional costs; if that relation is calculated incorrectly, then the core point is not supported.