4 ms·
> You can't count it as a cost on you without adding the value of the employer share to your base income. I agree with you, but I think I did that. I was tryin
by zaroth 12y ago
> You can't count it as a cost on you without adding the value of the employer share to your base income.
I agree with you, but I think I did that. I was trying to say $100,000 of payroll expense causes $15,300 of payroll taxes. Then the other taxes, and subsidy phase-outs, pile on from there.
> Its absolutely not even similar, much less "mathematically equivalent", to the latter alone, which is how you presented it.
You are right, they are not "mathematically equivalent", let me try again;
By "progressive subsidy" I mean a declining benefit as you earn more. That is, income from the government which decreases as you earn more. An example is Medi-Cal and ACA subsidies, food stamps, shit we didn't even mention SSI, etc.
By "progressive tax" I mean an increasing tax rate as you earn more. That is, an increasing number of cents out of each dollar in payroll expense is confiscated as you earn more. An example is Federal Income Tax.
The progressive subsidy offsets the benefit of early income, the progressive tax offsets the benefit of later income. The net effect is reducing the vast majority if not all of the the "Realized Family Benefit" from $0 - $150,000 of [household] payroll expense! I mean, it's disgusting to think about that way, but it's the economics of the system we've created.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> > You can't count it as a cost on you without adding the value of the employer share to your base income. > I agree with you, but I think I did that. You did not. Or you calculated the tax wrong, but it looks more like the former than the latter. > I said $100,000 of payroll causes $15,300 of payroll taxes. You said when "earning" $100k, you pay $15,300 of payroll tax, you did not say $100k of payroll causes $15,300 of payroll tax -- and interpreting earning in the usual way for such a discussion (i.e., the income shown on your pay stub subject to payroll tax) -- this is exactly correct; at $100k of such income, the total payroll tax (employer + employee share, Social Security + Medicare) is exactly $15,300. If you are looking at the employer's payroll expense, however, though, that's not $100k, its at least $107,650 (the employee's income subject to payroll tax -- which includes the employee share of the tax -- plus the employer share of the tax.)
- zaroth 12y agoAre we not saying the same thing two different ways? Earning $100k to me means providing services worth $100k. It's obvious when it's 1099 or self-employment. On a $100,000 '1099' or Schedule C income you owe $15,300 of payroll tax. I pulled the number straight from Schedule SE, Line 5. You will pay less income tax as a result, due to the 1/2 (e.g. $7650) deduction from income tax on Line 6. (I tried to account for that in my estimated $6500 of Federal Income Tax due, an effective 6.5% rate) Somewhere along the line the Fed tricked us into subtracting 7.65% off our W-2 compensation before we even see it, and even got us to think we didn't even earn it. It's fully institutionalized now. It's like VAT being baked in and no one thinks they're paying the tax, but they are! In my earning $100k example, the reported "Compensation" on the W-2 would be only 100,000 / 1.0765 = $92,893. My point is your W-2 is lying. The company is paying $100k for your services, and the IRS has their fingers in it before you even see it. Anyway, we are arguing a very minor point to a very serious issue. I think I've provided enough numbers that are accurate enough to see the insanity of the whole system. It doesn't really matter when in the "pipeline" the $7,650 is confiscated. It's enough to know that FICA is 15.3% of every dollar up to $117,000 per person, $234,000 per household.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> Are we not saying the same thing two different ways? No. > It's obvious when it's 1099 or self-employment. Ah, I see what you did -- you made the mistake of thinking that self-employment tax and W-2 payroll taxes are functionally identical, but just the way W-2 reports it is different and misleading. This is decidedly not the case, while the self-employment tax has the same rate as the combined employer + employee share of W-2 payroll taxes, the base value isn't comparable (since the latter is based on W-2 income, while the former is on the total, which is effectively equivalent to W-2 income plus the employer share of payroll tax.) As a result, the self-employment tax has a greater effective rate than the payroll tax, even though they have the same nominal rate. > Somewhere along the line the Fed tricked us into subtracting 7.65% off our W-2 compensation before we even see it, and even got us to think we didn't even earn it. It's fully institutionalized now. It's like VAT being baked in and no one thinks they're paying the tax, but they are! Perhaps, but the problem with your analysis isn't disagreement over who is paying the tax, but it is how you calculated the amount of the tax and what the income is that goes with it. Payroll tax and self-employment tax server similar purposes and have identical nominal rates, but do not have equivalent bases. So, if you make a statement about payroll tax and how it relates to the income it is based on, but your logic is driven by self-employment tax and the income it is based on, the conclusion will be incorrect.